Mini 1014 - Ghostbusters Mafia - Game Over

[XScorpion]

so he's either scum or town. either way he's flailing/panicking.... awesome work guys. -.-

There's a reason I'm not voting for him.

[BloodCovenent]

yea......

[Scott Brosius]

I want to ponder whether I can see BloodCovenent's doing that stuff as a townie. And why do YOU ask, Scott?

What jason said, it's non-committal and scummy to keep FOSing a person.

I'm reading Tazaro as strange town more than scum. His over-analysis and crazy post amounts read as town more than scum to me.

BC seems a bit touchy and reactive, especially over a minor point in 174. Will check meta to see if this is normal. Scummy read

Mallow's 183 is obviously bad and scummy given the lack of content. Scummy read

People need to stop referencing their own metas as a defense. Only other players can comment on how another player's meta applies to a certain game.

Oh. Well when you put it like that, it seems like he's voting him just over theory discussion, which I wasn't under the impression was the case.

Scott. Clarify.

I guess its partly due to theory, but its more of the over-reacting to wagons early. Quick-lynches are so rare and trying to curtail the best method for getting reactions from players is scummy to me. I don't think it's theory, its factual. My vote stays.

[CallMeLiam]

Vote Count

Tazaro

- 3 - jasonT1981, d3x, XScorpion

BloodCovenent

- 1 - Coach Travis

Coach Travis

- 3 - mallowgeno, Scott Brosius, BloodCovenent

Not Voting

- 5 - xRECKONERx, Zang, Starbuck, Ghostwriter, Tazaro

Seven votes lynches

Starbuck has been prodded, Tazaro is being replaced for discussing ongoing games in another thread.

[XScorpion]

Oh fun.
I'll keep my vote around till the replacement does something useful. If he does, my eyes are on Reckoner and mallow.

[Starbuck]

Hey, a PM or something announcing the beginning of the game would have been freaking awesome.

[CallMeLiam]

A PM went out on Monday to anyone that hadn't posted over the weekend.

[Coach Travis]

Nice to see Starbuck around, interested to hear from him. But now the real interesting thing will be seeing how Taz's replacement acts, because Taz was acting suspicious, I personally wrote it off as just him being overly hyper, didn't really find him scummy, but I'm interested to see how the replacement will act, with the situation as it is.

Also, while I still disagree with Scott, I don't find him scummy, because he at least has a good enough explanation, and isn't accusing me of something I never did. Still think he's town. His case against me is totally fair, no matter how much I disagree with it.

[jasonT1981]

very interested in hearing from Starbuck, however unlike Xscorpian I am gonna

unvote:Taz/replacement

to give the replacet sometime to catch up and give his thoughts

[BloodCovenent]

Hey, a PM or something announcing the beginning of the game would have been freaking awesome.

hahahahahah!
+1

[BloodCovenent]

BC seems a bit touchy and reactive, especially over a minor point in 174. Will check meta to see if this is normal. Scummy read

What in post 174 is an overreaction?

[mallowgeno]

Sorry guys that I haven't been on lately. I'm looking back at when I said I fosed XScorpion and I am wondering what I was thinking. I'm sorry if you think me useless. I'm ISOing Coach and I'll see if I can add anything.

[mallowgeno]

After ISOing him I think I'm going to change my vote. He has some valid points and after reading some of what I missed, I think Tarazo is scum.

vote Tarazo

[Scott Brosius]

BC seems a bit touchy and reactive, especially over a minor point in 174. Will check meta to see if this is normal. Scummy read

What in post 174 is an overreaction?

The phrasing of the defense about defamation, yet not really addressing what was "defamed".

[Zang]

I'm

V/LA until Saturday

[jasonT1981]

After ISOing him I think I'm going to change my vote. He has some valid points and after reading some of what I missed, I think Tarazo is scum.

vote Tarazo

Should you not at least be giving the replacement time to catch up and form an opinion? I am actually quite suspicious of you, you have said very little... come in and jumped on the popular wagon without giving anything to actually support your suspicions apart from saying you 'ISOd' Taz. Almost as if you have not read fully and not seen he is in the process of being replaced. Your vote reaks of a vote for the sake of voting on the popular wagon rather than a proper, thought out, rational vote.

FOS:Mallow

[jasonT1981]

Hey, a PM or something announcing the beginning of the game would have been freaking awesome.

A PM went out on Monday to anyone that hadn't posted over the weekend.

Lurkerscum caught out! haha

[XScorpion]

unvote
Vote: Mallowgeno

That was just...I have no words to explain it. Not even Taz is that bad.

[mallowgeno]

hmm well if I get lynched I would definately go after XScorpion.

[XScorpion]

Why?
Are you going to bother actually, I dunno, commenting on the game state, or are you just gonna keep throwing out random and unfounded accusations?
At this point, the only way I could see unvoting you is if a) you get replaced, b) someone else does something so unbelievably scummy it's ridiculous (e.g. claiming scum) or c) You bother to make a post like I did when I first entered the game, discussing your views on who is scummy and what for and what you think of everything that's happened in this game [This is the option I would prefer you to choose].

[Coach Travis]

Yeah, I have to agree with the case against Mallow:He's been totally unhelpful, lurking like crazy, and then to return and make a vote against someone who's being replaced, and who I feel could easily be an over excited townie, is very suspicious. I think for now I'll

Unvote

,

Vote:Mallowgeno

, since the BC thing was really just personal, and while I still don't particularly like him, Mallow seems worse right now.

This means Mallow, BC and xRECKONERx are currently at the top of my suspicions list, while right now I feel Scott, Jason, and Taz are town. There's still some people I'm not totally sure of yet, I'll go through some more later and see if I can get more reads.

[Scott Brosius]

hmm well if I get lynched I would definately go after XScorpion.

If you get lynched? You are this reactive to ONE vote?

Unvote, Vote: mallowgeno

[CallMeLiam]

Vote Count

LynchMePls

- 2 - d3x, , mallowgeno

Coach Travis

- 1 - BloodCovenent

mallowgeno

- 3 - XScorpion, Coach Travis, Scott Brosius

Not Voting

- 5 - xRECKONERx, Zang, Starbuck, Ghostwriter, LynchMePls, jasonT1981

Seven votes lynches

LynchMePls has now replaced Tazaro.

[jasonT1981]

LynchMePls, welcome... though with Taz behaviour so far... your name is kinda fitting lol

[BloodCovenent]

BC seems a bit touchy and reactive, especially over a minor point in 174. Will check meta to see if this is normal. Scummy read

What in post 174 is an overreaction?

The phrasing of the defense about defamation, yet not really addressing what was "defamed".

He called me a liar. then shortly after Zang called me a liar.