kyle99 wrote:The problem is with that situation you brought up is your assuming that both me and MoB would be mislynches. Assuming that a lynch could be a mislynch and wondering which mislynch would be less worse is bad and anti-town. Vote on who's scum and nothing else.
Dude, I don't even know if I should call this intentional misinterpretation on your part
Nowhere did I say that I think both of you are mislynches. I - very clearly - stated what would (or rather could) happen when one of you flips town. I don't KNOW if either one of you is one or the other because while we can debate/speculate/argue as long as we want but just like Beanman said a couple of posts ago we can only be certain after the hammer as fallen and the victim either has claimed afterwards or the flavor has been revealed. And to say wondering if a lynch is a mislynch is anti-town is total bull. Everybody should be wondering (and a lot of people have done so in this thread) what happens if your lynch doesn't flip scum. It makes you think twice whther to vote/hammer and it gives you a lot to work with the next day to determine what went wrong and who acted suspiciously.
And your second part is also wrong. I - again very clealry - stated that I'm not unvoting you because I think you're the better mislynch but rather because you haven't done anything to prove me your innocence.
I may try to give an ISO on kyle....but not right now. There's other things to address right now.
Beanman wrote:You seem to have all the answers figured out. Well once again I've caught you in a fallacy. As to your question, you thought wrong... Last game I was in, scum team was the IC and SE. They basically starting day 2, started building these really strong cases against each other. Day 3 one of them got lynched, but because they were targeting each other, no one thought, "they could be scum partners." And scum ended up winning. Smart players use these tactics, because people like you naively assume they just won't for some reason.
Am I saying Kyle and Adrien are scum buddies? No, as I have stated I do not know who scum is, it is however my goal to find out.
Why put off tommorrow what you can do today, and that's scumhunt. I can't wait to hear your case on kyle, because I bet I have a much more evidence on you, than you do on him... But I'm gonna let you present your case on kyle, before I present my case on you.
No, I do not think I have it all figured out. I try to be as successful in scumhunting just like you do. And I may and will be wrong (probably more often than not in my first game) at one time or the other . But what good would it do if I was always like "They maybe scum, maybe not", "This might have been rather suspicious", etc. I'm just posting what reflects my current opinions. I don't wanna say every other sentence "I can't guarantee it, but this is how I see it". After all this is a game based on opinions and you shouldn't say so all the time.
You're pretty quick when it comes to catching fallacies. Let me explain especially the part that you bolded. I can't guarantee it, but this is how I see it. If kyle flips scum I really believe Adrien is town. Yes, I'm aware that mafia's most powerful weapon is deceit. And I know, that bussing is one of the most common things for mafia to do. But if we apply this scenario here what do we have:
It starts off with
#57 by yabba where he - in my opionion - gives a valid vote on kyle as a (somewhat) friendly reminder to start posting content. Then after the first Mob fiasco ensues you vote for kyle and then Adrien goes all out on kyle and never backs down especially after I put him at L-1. He could've done something like you did and point out the shrapnels of content kyle posted and unvote without looking too suspicious. But he practically begged people to hammer on kyle. And I really don't know if scum would be willing to sacrifice (after seven pages, no less) their partner when there's absolutely no need to. If they do end up as scum team, that was one hell of a gutsy move and I will tip my hat to Adrien (given they win this thing of course). But as of right now until no new information arises I stand by my point.
Oh yeah, and I don't like how you throw suspicion towards anybody on the kyle wagon. I do believe you're town at the moment and we're all here trying to scumhunt as best as we can. But you're acting like everybody on the kyle wagon is scummy and voting not out of valid reasons but rather only for the sake of there being a wagon while all the time kyle is super obvious town to you. I just don't see it yet. Like I said I try to present a case on kyle tomorrow (maybe even tonight, but don't count on it).