Scummies 2010 Nominations

[Haylen]

Nominate Haylen for Paperback Writer for this game

Even though it wasn't finished because the town kept lynching too fast, it is a good read flavor-wise.

Hey! I'm working on finishing it! ^_^

[SaintKerrigan]

Nominate Haylen for Paperback Writer for this game

Even though it wasn't finished because the town kept lynching too fast, it is a good read flavor-wise.

Hey! I'm working on finishing it! ^_^

This is why I don't completely script my stories. Then I can (hopefully) adapt to unexpected circumstances.

[Haylen]

That was the problem, SK, I real life and lynches happened. My story wasn't scripted, I was making the whole thing up as I went along, then about halfway through the game I developed a plot.

[SaintKerrigan]

Well, I do get some sort of idea of how I want the game to end, depending on how things go, and I make sure I lead my stories in that general direction.

[Sotty7]

I'd like to

nominate yabbaguy for best IC

He has been in a couple of my newbie games recently and really helps the new players settle in regardless of his alignment. But he also does a great game break down for everyone once it is over. Examples, Newbie 953 and Newbie 971. I was impressed.

[Kdub]

Nth LynchMePls for best new player

[Time Traveler]

Placeholder? I don't remember that being an award.

but seriously thanks for the honor you guys. It wasn't actually made during the game since i can't actually be in the game so I don't think you need to hold place for it since its not meant to actually be apart of the mafia game. But as long as it also doesn't matter that the joke was kinda outside a game i am glad to have the nomination for whatever catagory Max/yawtag/anyone thinks it all should go under.

Whether I win or not I must thank Kison as he helped me with the avy and in a way approved of the jokes idea. I let him see an early version of that skit as a reward for his work on the avy but I still want to thank him again as he did like the skit so that kinda advanced my desire to show everyone else the joke aswell. A way of being a mild test subject he was so yay I definatly want to thank him for how well that went. And if I do win I certainly plan to thank him again during the awards ceremony

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 81#2140281

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 24&t=14505

The Series Continues!!

[curiouskarmadog]

forgot I could edit, see below.

[curiouskarmadog]

Nominating Faraday for, Most Cunning Manipulation - "The Don Corleone" Award for Karma Mafia

we got an investigation on him and he claimed SK (with specifics) that not only saved his ass from a lynch, but won the game for his scum team...good show...Shanba also deserves some love for this nomination too, but it was faraday who deserves the actual nod.

going to have to chagne this Nom, according to faraday the actual claim (that in my opinion won it for scum) was due to javert,

so changing it to

Nominating Faraday/Javert for, Best Performance Scum Group
Award

for Karma Mafia

I personally dont think the entire scum team deserves it, just these two in particular.

[dybeck]

Nominating Faraday for, Most Cunning Manipulation - "The Don Corleone" Award for Karma Mafia

we got an investigation on him and he claimed SK (with specifics) that not only saved his ass from a lynch, but won the game for his scum team...good show...Shanba also deserves some love for this nomination too, but it was faraday who deserves the actual nod.

going to have to chagne this Nom, according to faraday the actual claim (that in my opinion won it for scum) was due to javert,

so changing it to

Nominating Faraday/Javert for, Best Performance Scum Group
Award

for Karma Mafia

I personally dont think the entire scum team deserves it, just these two in particular.

I'd like to unnominate both of the above - they both screamed scum to me - and I fingered them both long before game over. But Shanba, from the same game, made a fantastic claim that saved him from an almost-certain lynch, and went a long way to winning the game for scum. I'd like to nominate him for best role-claim, if such an award exists. Might be a bit strong to nominate him for best scum performance though, since he was only a replacement for a fraction of the game.

[mith]

Remember that nominations for the first half of the year close at the end of this week.

We are also still looking judges, so if you would like to volunteer for that send me a PM.

[Haylen]

Did we have that rule last year? :/ I don't remember it...although tbh, I only knew about the scummies from December 09 onwards >.<

[mith]

The half year split is new for this year. We're attempting to reduce the workload for the judges.

[curiouskarmadog]

I'd like to unnominate both of the above - they both screamed scum to me -

really?! unnominate? Faraday(Shanba did replace him for a time) also had a claim that saved his ass and was crafted in such a way that made him almost impossible for the town to lynch. It was crafted by javert...who cares if you might or might not had them pegged, you died. They out manuvered you. that being said, the only real arguement you have to unnominate this, was that the town was full of blind sheep. Again, mafia, picked off the better players first.

[yabbaguy]

Hoopla isn't nommed for Best Third Party, but for Best Role Claim.

[dybeck]

I'd like to unnominate both of the above - they both screamed scum to me -

really?! unnominate? Faraday(Shanba did replace him for a time) also had a claim that saved his ass and was crafted in such a way that made him almost impossible for the town to lynch. It was crafted by javert...who cares if you might or might not had them pegged, you died. They out manuvered you. that being said, the only real arguement you have to unnominate this, was that the town was full of blind sheep. Again, mafia, picked off the better players first.

I agree. The game was lost by the worst town performance I have ever seen.

[animorpherv1]

IMO, if you can still get the entire town to foloow you, then that's a feat.

[Sotty7]

Nominate I am Innocent for most outstanding new player.

Pretty much fooled me in this game. I even spent some time reading his meta here, and here. Very impressive player, new to the site this year.

[Equinox]

Nominate I am Innocent for most outstanding new player.

Pretty much fooled me in this game. I even spent some time reading his meta here, and here. Very impressive player, new to the site this year.

Seconded.

[Kise]

Nominate ReaperCharlie for Most Outstanding New Player

He was good at directing town in Knights' Werewolf-Wisburg game, and he also had a perfect win as mafia in my mini theme, Square Enix II. I'm pretty sure he joined the site in October.

[Mitsuru Kirijo]

Seconded.

A great scum partner while I was part of Square-Enix II, with a great game style.

[yabbaguy]

Third I am Innocent nom

[gandalf5166]

Nth SpyreX for funniest player

, simply because I don't think I should win an award like that for one post. Also, I discovered that it wasn't actually my WC to insult every post. It was a post restriction, it was just such a daunting task that my mind interpreted it as a WC.

[mith]

Last day for first-half nominations!

[SpyreX]

Third ReaperCharlie