Mini 1000: The Brave and the Beautiful (Game Over)

[bv310]

There's a textbook for AtE? Cooooool.

Anyway, I'm going to reread as soon as possible. Probably by tonight or tomorrow.

Are you really surprised? I mean there has got to be a textbook for lurking / active-lurking. It's in your library, right?

Nah, I'm a natural talent.

[Robocopter87]

Wow, thats all you have to say bv310? Thats it?

Just jump in and say something sarcastic.

[Iecerint]

Ythan, could you please articulate the evidence against Millar for a lynch?

[bv310]

Okay, so I've caught up the little amount I've missed. I fully support giving SpyreX his shot, at least for today, and in that vein, I'd like to

Unvote. Vote: Millar

[Robocopter87]

Thats it. Thats all he says. Then votes.

[Iecerint]

Yeah. I agree.

[ReaperCharlie]

The Brave and the Beautiful - Vote Count 1.12

millar13 [3] - Muffin, MagnaofIllusion, bv310
Furcolow [2] - Ythan, Robocopter87
Shotty to the Body [1] - Furcolow
Netopalis [1] - Shotty to the Body
Ythan [1] - Iecerint

Not Voting [4] - Kdub, millar13, Netopalis, SpyreX

Accounting for damage from the Zergling Rush, it is now 5 to lynch.

The deadline is Thursday July 22 at 5:30pm PST.

[MagnaofIllusion]

@Spyrex

- Would it critically damage your plan to have Muffin replace Robocopter on a millar lynch? If not I'm seeing that as a viable option.

@Ythan and Kdub

- Still willing to lynch millar?

[millar13]

So i post my case and its ignored anyway lol.

plus BV vote on me without reason, is just another wagon roll.

[Muffin]

CASE ON STTB

My view of the game actually starts all the way from the "Random Voting Stage" although my view might not be seen as actually be accucrate or entirely on the ball.

Sup sexy ladies.

Vote Iecerint

For a first post, this can't even be judged. Totallly neutral a good way to enter into the fray (if in fact there are ladies present)

If it can't be judged, then why did you include it?

Hey, folks. Woo! A few names I've played with before - in particular, shout-outs to Ythan, bv310 and SK.

Normally you might not look at this, but this could be a perfect tactic. By Neto seeming to not realize that STTB is in the game; you already have instilled a beleif system that neither man has prior knowledge of the other being in the game. Its all very circumstantial though.

Is your case against Neto or against Shotty? Here you seem to be pointing the finger at Neto and pretending it's evidence against shotty.

I'm going to withhold information from this town by not answering Neto's questions.

Next, he is already distancing himself from Neto. Strange, without any reason for this to occur (unless they discussed this in a "scum-topic"

I don't really see this as distancing. Distancing IMO is when two people attack each other. Refusing to answer Neto's questions could be a legitimate tactic to end the silly random voting/random question stage. Also IIRC Robo refused to answer the questions too so why aren't you jumping on that?

MoI, you don't know how much I cried over Furcolows play in that game. I wasn't even alive when he was there.

Newbie926

If you wanna know what I'm talking about read day two.

That game was ugly, on the other hand I ID'd the scum team on my first post.

Referencing game so early; i never like that. Almost acting as a marker for what I have done; so surely I wouldn't be scum etc.

Again, who is your case against? It was Robo who brought up the game, but somehow you attempt to spin it to make shotty look bad.

Guilty people are paranoid, innocents have nothing to fear.

Unvote vote robo

That is bullsh*t totally; innocents don't want to be lynched. Especially if they have a power role, as are high valued to anytown.

While I agree that it was hypocritical of Shotty to vote Robo for refusing to answer the questions after refusing to do so himself, I do think that Robo was acting overly paranoid at this point of the thread. Plus this is the part of the thread that Millar supposedly read to catch up because he "didnt get his role pm". And yet if you read onward fromt his point he votes Robo as the scummiest player in the thread, not shotty.

Shotty To The Body is then "MISSING IN ACTION" for quite a while, during the Zerg Rush (and it must be added that he had a vote on Robocopter) so it is very possible he had a part to play in this.
At this period he was supporting the Robo lynch.

What I find more interesting is that you were PRESENT during the Zerg Rush, and you were ALSO supporting the Robo lynch

Scum fear death and lynches far more than town do. Fail argument. Not to mention town controls the lynch, not scum. Oh and scum have PRs too.

I'm going to go ahead and jump on this. To me, this looks like Shotty trying to throw fuel on Robo's fire in order to get him closer to that lynch so that he can use the ability. I think that may be our best lead right now, although Furcolow isn't far behind.

Vote: Shotty to the Body

I haven't reread yet to find this dayaction, but how is voting someone for terrible arguments scummy? What a joke. Of course I was trying to get votes on him when he's behaving like a scum-bag. You had to go back REALLY far to find someone to throw this terrible argument against too, what was that page 3 or 4 or something?

Neto votes STTB; and then STTB responds straight away (almost like a co-ordinated plan backstage. Scum vs. Scum is a common theme in game, and can be planned.

I'm confused what you think about this is scummy. Is it the timing? Is it the fact that shotty responded to robo at all? I'm just not seeing scummy here.

My top single suspect up to this point is Millar. I think his vote for Robotown was the most bizarre, and I think his play in the aftermath makes little sense.

My second-tier is Neto-S2B as a scumpair. First, Neto weakly attacks S2B out of nowhere. Then, S2B calls him out for "distancing" with me. In light of other things that have happened, these seems like an unusual place for one's focus. It's also an odd choice of words. For example, Neto and I hadn't attacked one another at all, so saying that we're distancing from one another is totally bogus. It reads like "Let's distance!" "LOL OK!" to me.

I'll be in rural Kentucky this weekend visiting family. I may not have regular access to the computer.

V/LA until Monday

.

It's a false argument between you two. He attacked me already, why would I have to tell him to distance? I pretty much agree with your Millar read, but I'm not moving my vote atm.

Thats seems like an attempt of making us look slightly connected; in the most subtle of degrees.

Who is "us"? Shotty is agreeing that you are the scummiest player in the thread, so who is he trying to link with you?

Pages and pages of STTB not even commenting'; is he actively lurking or just avoiding the game to reduce heat. Post a VLA or your giving off bad signals.

I agree, active lurking is bad.

V/LA till tuesday

Finally posts one; but its almost like...what? Why not before; (or were you just lurking away just like you did when you put through the Zerg Rush)

You're reaching.

I think along with active lurking, as well as the points I have STTB looks quite scummy.

Not as scummy as you. This "case" is pretty weak

[Shotty to the Body]

Sorry, it took me longer to catch up from vacation then I thought, the game I'm modding had some other things I had to deal with, but that's almost squared away so I'm re-reading. Spyre what happened to your magical plan? I saw you talk about it but never spell it out, or have you not done that at all yet?

[Robocopter87]

Hey muffin, I'm the one with red in quotes!

[SpyreX]

@Spyrex - Would it critically damage your plan to have Muffin replace Robocopter on a millar lynch? If not I'm seeing that as a viable option.

@Ythan and Kdub - Still willing to lynch millar?

Sorry I've been absentish.

IF that is what it takes to get today done it can happen.

However, I am on the record right here right now as millar is going to be a town flip. I'd still much, MUCH prefer Shotty.

[Iecerint]

Millar looks town to me, too. Killing one of Shotty, Furco would be best. Ythan and bv are at the next tier.

[ReaperCharlie]

I just want to put a quick plug in for Gears of War Mafia, which Shotty to the Body is modding. We've got a serious level of inactivity and lurkage, and we need some replacements badly. If anyone is interested, please PM Shotty.

[Muffin]

Millar looks town to me, too. Killing one of Shotty, Furco would be best. Ythan and bv are at the next tier.

Vote it up, then, guys. Let's make it happen.

[Robocopter87]

Which one arewe killing? Shotty, or Furc?

[Ythan]

Ythan, could you please articulate the evidence against Millar for a lynch?

Could you please articulate the evidence against me for a lynch?

[MagnaofIllusion]

MOD - I'll be LA from now til Monday for my usual weekend family duties.

[Kdub]

@Ythan and Kdub

- Still willing to lynch millar?

Yeah, I'm down with this. millar > Shotty > Furcolow for today's lynch. I will only vote Shotty or Fur if it is clear that there is not enough support for millar.

[Iecerint]

@ Y, you're not even in my top tier, so, ye know, I see little reason to go above-and-beyond calling for your lynch when there may be better suspects.

The short version is that I don't think you're scumhunting and I think you've slipped a few times (e.g. complaining about some abilities being more a priori feasible pregame)

The not scumhunting ties into your desire to lynch Millar even though I don't remember you ever really articulating why you think he's scum. One simple explanation is that you don't think he's scum, but still want to lynch him. Your deflection is consistent with that.

@ Muffin -- I'm humoring SX for the time being. That's (part of) why I'm still on Y. I'm assuming he'll let us lynch someone who isn't millar if it comes to it, though.

[Furcolow]

i am good, and if you all don't trust me what the fuck ever

[Robocopter87]

AtE^^^

[Furcolow]

look ive had it up to here with this shit. go ahead and mislynch me. i really don't give two shits.

if you all do a) i'm doing a
if you all do b) i'm doing b

i'm going to react you all.
if you all lynch me, i'm going to laugh at how bad the town played letting people like shotty, millar, or ythan run free and be scummy
if you all dont lynch me, i'm going to see what powers shotty, millar, or ythan has

[Furcolow]

robo you piss me off with your little one liners and inability to actually make a case on someone. ythan, bv310, same way. this town is so bad i'm ready to replace out, because mafia have surely beaten us if we don't come together. iecerint is being stupid with conspiracy theories and tunneling on me whenever he was away during half the shit he's tunneling on. i can't remember a single thing kdub has done to help us out. magnaofillusion is about the only one who has done anything worthwhile, but i know his analysis has been wrong when it has come to me. i wouldn't even care to be mislynched in this game, really, the more that i think about it. i would regret not being able to use my cool 2 powers i have, but there will always be another game in which i am a blue role for the town. the last time i was a blue role for the town, believe it or not, i used my ability to stop 2/4 cult recruitments so i know for a fact i am good at helping the town at night, but you guys obviously don't know me. just go ahead and lynch me