KMD wrote:Setting up lynches isn't scummy.
On this we disagree. I see very few credible situations where Town has motivation to plan multiple Days worth of lynches without carefully inspecting the impact of each lynch and each Night.
KMD wrote:Did you not see my post about softclaims being bad regardless of alignment? Let me put it this way. Why do we not massclain to start games?
Because it tells scum who to kill.
If andrius is town, he was a NK target as soon as he softclaimed. If he's scum, we want to see his claim anyway. Back to if he's town, what more danger does a fullclaim put him in than a softclaim? It makes no difference whatsoever. A claim does nothing more than provide the town with more info about andrius.
It’s obviously not a good plan to mass-claim at game’s start. Why bother to include that as a supporting point to your argument?
I’ve bolded the portion of exactly why I think going to a full-claim from a soft-claim is an even worse move. If Andrius is indeed town with a soft-claim there is at least some potential doubt as to whether he might be a worthy Nightkill target that Scum are going to have to mull over. Pushing him to a full claim simply eliminates that doubt.
It gives Town more information if you believe the claim. If you don’t? Then Town has gained nothing, but Scum potentially have gained some knowledge.
Reaper wrote:I don't know much about his scum meta Magna. But I've seen him play town a few times before and this is no different.
Then the Meta is frankly worthless. It’s only truly useful if you have some differential behaviour by which to analyze whether he is playing to one particular side.
I personally
HATE
player who are Scummy / Anti-Town regardless of alignment. It only serves their personal “I want to play longer, not more effectively” agenda and doesn’t help Town.
@Andrius
– I don’t see why you are hesitant to give up your name. Unless it directly links you with another already established claim I don’t see it as compromising your Partner.
@Rajr re 1043
– The WIFOM regarding whether scum would or would not do something isn’t really helpful.
Nobody wrote:Hi, I just got prodded. How did you guys post four pages without me?
Obviously we showed up when the thread opened and posted content. Day 3 started on Monday. Judging by your post trail since then you’ve had plenty of time to actually read the goings on and comment here. Seriously you have 3 pages of posts from Monday til you responded to the prod. Now the determination whether you are lurking scum or just lurking bad town needs to be made.
MOD - I'll be LA from today at 4pm EDT until Monday morning for normal family weekend duties.
"I am a leaf on the wind ... watch how I soar!"
Pretty much Geriatric game restricted at this point ... unless there are players I REALLY want to play with.