This quote makes me pretty sure Adumbro is town. (I had a town read on CMAR before my activity dropped off but though that was a long time ago.)rajrhcpfreak wrote:AdumbroDeus, did i see that correctly? you cant be killed except for your passive ability. does that include lynches?
--
I would be very shocked if both ABR and Raj turned out to be a part of the mafia, as two mafia members with the power to recruit from outside the game would be very over powered. The only hang up I have with ABR is that I would expect the role of Loki to involve tricking a large number of people (telling a big lie or something like that) seeing as he is the Norse god of trickery and he would make perfect sense as a third party role. I don't know anything about Too Human though so it might be different in that specific flavor so any sort of Flavor analysis from me would be a waste of time. He's probably town.
(Also there is a nice symmetry to there being 1 town, 1 mafia, and 1 third party recruiter - ABR, Raj, and Tar respectively)
--
My town read on Chronopie is starting to fade now that he has stopped posting entirely as opposed to his active lurking earlier, though I myself am a good example that that doesn't really constitute a scum tell. I still think he's town. Which reminds me, I think we should worship the Egyptians tonight to test out his claimed revive ability.
--
I would be very surprised if Katy was scum independent of the player who is currently in Ort's player slot (Xite?) seeing as she claimed an innocent investigation on him immediately at the start of day 2 which I just don't see as a productive use of scum time (A scum could have easily justified not claiming at that time and would have been happy if the town would have continued wasting their time on that playerslot, so it only makes sense to do so in order to protect a scum buddy).
--
It is absolutely imperative that Snow_Bunny confirms that her kill is real by passing her item to another player. If it is real then the chances that she is scum are about Nil, while if she is bluffing scum this should out her. If she is uncomfortable with giving up control of the vig kill then she should publicly declare who she is giving it to and then ask them to immediately give it back after they confirm that it is real.
--
I like Dramonic as scum, though I am really struggling to articulate why. His role really screams scum to me from everything to the fact that it removes a player from posting in the game for a day (which I feel is bad no matter what their alignment is) to the fact that he uses them as a bulletproof shield. Also, his play during night two doesn't sit well with me at all.
vote:Dramonic
I wouldn't be surprised if he is the cult recruiter.
--
I am going to be honest, I don't actually read Darkstalker's posts, so I am going to have to lean on what other people are saying about him for now until I can get a better handle on this game. Ooba's case against him resonated with me a little though.
--
Ooba has been putting a lot of emphasis on the worship mechanic, which would be a minor scum tell if he did it to the exclusion of commenting on the game at large, but the he has been doing a lot of interrogating and has been very involved in the game from the very start. While people are always quick to point out the fact that "Effort being pro-town" is a fallacy, I still feel good about him at this time.
--
Iec has been a headache for me for pretty much this entire game, but I am starting to think that I was correct when I started to suspect a bit of my hate on him is due to confirmation bias with a liberal dose of playstyle clashing. That said, the last time I let him get away like that he flipped scum. Eh, hes back to neutral for now.
--
I had a strong town read on Parama day 1 for the same reasons that I always have a strong a strong town read on parama, but I can't find many examples of Parama independently scum hunting after day 1 and this worries me greatly. His interactions with Fate make me feel better though.
--
Xite makes me go ehhhhhh. I had reasoned earlier why I thought that that playerslot is likely town, but still... Ehhhhhh. Her voting record is absolutely terrible from my perspective (ABR, Nikanor, Fate, and then Raj after his lynch started to look inevitable.). Ortolan's rage quit was an alignment independent thing looking back and I really don't think much productive can be gleaned from that. Hopefully looking at interactions with the flipped scum will help a lot.
--
Some other town reads that I don't think need explaining: Fate, Nikanor, Faraday, M_O, Mina, Tar, DT
Lets see, that leaves:
TotallyNotMafia
VasudeVa
Darkstalker
Xite
Iec
Dramonic
as candidates for scum. The only ones I haven't already talked about are TNM and Vas. Both have claimed protective roles and both seem to have failed to utilize them well.
I'd look at them more in depth, but I am starting run out of energy for this. Later.
@M_O: Have you outlined in the thread anywhere why you are suspicious of Ooba? If not can I hear the reasoning?
