Mini 237- Basic Mafia - Game over!

[vikingfan]

Yeah, and if viQLes doesn't post by tomorrow evening, I'll get a replacement for him as well.

[mikeburnfire]

Role Confirmed. Greetings everyone.

[vikingfan]

Any chance you can change the size of your sig, mike? It's making me have to scroll twice to read words that run the entire length of the screen.

Either that or else I can just turn off signatures...

[mikeburnfire]

I think that seems like a reasonable request.

[Stewie]

I second the signature decrease (specially annoying in 600x800) and also request some input on what we've been doing so far.

[vikingfan]

Thanks, mike.

viQLes has a little less than 24 hours to check in...

[Mr Stoofer]

Checking in.

With all the replacements and stalling and hanging around, there is nothing much to go on.

The d8p thing is more likely nothing, blown out of proportion, than a genuine scum tell.

Ill

unvote: Nightfall

and

vote: Sineish

for the d8p thing and for being the nearest thing we've got to a lurker (as opposed to a non-poster). Weak reasons, but I prefer my vote to have a slender basis than no basis at all.

[Falcone]

Nightfall may post a lot, but I don't see much content in his posts. Isn't that typical lurker-behaviour? So why unvote him and vote for Sineish, who has less posts than Nightfall, but more content? I don't think he deserves suspicion for the d8P thing. His question and FOS were reasonable in my opinion.

Unvote: Commodore Amazing
Vote: Mr. Stoofer

[Mr Stoofer]

That was predictable.

[Seol]

Ill

unvote: Nightfall

and

vote: Sineish

for the d8p thing and for being the nearest thing we've got to a lurker (as opposed to a non-poster). Weak reasons, but I prefer my vote to have a slender basis than no basis at all.

What about the d8P thing?

[Mr Stoofer]

"

The d8p thing

" refers to the debate/suspicion forming on d8p because of

this post

.

Sineish said of it: "

I can only conclude it's some subtle bluff to throw someone off

" (which I find a startling conclusion) and FOS-ed him. There was then big debate about d8p's post. I think you, Seol, were saying that d8p's post was suspicious although I confess I didn't really understand your post on the subject. But I believe it was just a simple comment.

So my vote on Sineish for "

the d8p thing

" was a vote for reading too much into d8p's post. Not very strong grounds, as I said, but I preferred it to my random vote. This game is moving slowly and this is the best I could do, since no-one seems to be volunteering to be bandwagonned.

[mikeburnfire]

Falcone makes an credable arguement, and Stoof's counterpost of "That was predictable." just enhances it.

FoS: Nightfall and Mr Stoofer

[Sineish]

Stoofer, the only other alternative that I could think of was that d8P really does have a power roll and didn't realise that his post was such a huge tell. If you have an alternate explanation for his post, please share.

As for the "that was predictable" comment, have you spotted some link between Falcone and me, or was it just a reaction to him voting for you?

S.

[Nightfall]

Why the FOS on me though?
I haven't posted that much so far, I agree, but as far as I can tell so far
this whole game has just been home to a misunderstanding and multiple
people being replaced or going to be replaced. I'm not sure who I find
scummy just yet.

[Commodore Amazing]

Not very strong grounds, as I said, but I preferred it to my random vote. This game is moving slowly and this is the best I could do, since no-one seems to be volunteering to be bandwagonned.

Mr Stoofer, I think your case against Sineish is very weak. I do not think it's enough reason to vote for you, though.

[vikingfan]

I'm posting in the replacement thread for a replacement for viQLes now...

[Seol]

Re Stoof - my post in the d8P debate was basically to say that I thought Sineish's post was reasonable, from where I was sitting his logic held. So, obviously, I don't think Sineish looks suspicious for that - but then, I'm not thinking you're particularly suspicious either.

I'm happy to see a bandwagon that isn't me, but I don't think ChocoCid deserves votes yet. Let's see if he can explain what he's talking about.

Mr Stoofer, I think your case against Sineish is very weak. I do not think it's enough reason to vote for you, though.

For someone who was quite happy to throw random votes around, ever since your voting's been mentioned, you've been very cagey with your vote.

It's a gut thing, really, but you're acting weird, almost

too

careful.

unvote, vote: Commodore Amazing

.

[Commodore Amazing]

Re Stoof - my post in the d8P debate was basically to say that I thought Sineish's post was reasonable, from where I was sitting his logic held. So, obviously, I don't think Sineish looks suspicious for that - but then, I'm not thinking you're particularly suspicious either.

I'm happy to see a bandwagon that isn't me, but I don't think ChocoCid deserves votes yet. Let's see if he can explain what he's talking about.

Mr Stoofer, I think your case against Sineish is very weak. I do not think it's enough reason to vote for you, though.

For someone who was quite happy to throw random votes around, ever since your voting's been mentioned, you've been very cagey with your vote.

It's a gut thing, really, but you're acting weird, almost

too

careful.

unvote, vote: Commodore Amazing

.

Seol, you're basically saying that neither Stoofer nor Sineish is really worth voting for... and then you vote for me for not voting for either of them.

I believe I was called out for moving my random vote, then I was called out for unvoting my vote on viQLes, and now I am being called out for not voting. Maybe I should just lurk.

[Nightfall]

Maybe I should just lurk.

Yes, come join me. I've got snacks and drinks...
But I have to admit, that after you had been throwing your
votes around rather loosely, it does seem kind of odd, that
you'd just stop doing it now.

[vikingfan]

Your latest vote count:

Vote Count:

ChocoCid- 1 (ibaesha)
Commodore Amazing- 1 (Seol)
Mr. Stoofer- 1 (Falcone)
Seol- 1 (Nightfall)
Sineish- 1 (Mr. Stoofer)
viQLes- 1 (Stewie)

Not voting (6): ChocoCid, Commodore Amazing, d8P, mikeburnfire, Sineish, viQLes

7 to lynch.

[ChocoCid]

Well this is going nowhere fast. I find myself agreeing with seol on pretty much everything he's said so far, and I really don't like that.

FOS: Seol for making too much sense. (and commodore amazing does have a point there.)

I don't really have anything much on anyone, and I don't think anyone will. however, maybe Viqles' replacement can help us out a bit.

[Mr Stoofer]

Stoofer, the only other alternative that I could think of was that d8P really does have a power roll and didn't realise that his post was such a huge tell. If you have an alternate explanation for his post, please share.

You said "I can

only conclude

it's some subtle bluff to throw someone off". But as you yourself say, there is an alternative. Your quickness to rule out that alternative struck me as odd.

As for the "that was predictable" comment, have you spotted some link between Falcone and me, or was it just a reaction to him voting for you?

The latter.

[vIQleS]

Hm, ok...


He bought the complete first season of "Sex in the City."

LIES....

(It was season 2)

[vIQleS]

/me is confused - have I been replaced yet?

I'm here anyway, i tried to read up to date, but it's late and i can't process anything.

If i'm still in the game i'll contribute something tomorrow (ish)

[Seol]

Seol, you're basically saying that neither Stoofer nor Sineish is really worth voting for... and then you vote for me for not voting for either of them.

It's not that you're not voting, so much as you've twice emphasised that you're

not

going to vote. I don't think either Sineish or Stoof are suspicious, really - not that they're suspicious but under vote threshold (which, btw, I don't have), which is how I read your comments on Chococid and Stoofer. But then, having a high vote threshold doesn't really tally with your eagerness in the random vote stage.

I believe I was called out for moving my random vote, then I was called out for unvoting my vote on viQLes, and now I am being called out for not voting. Maybe I should just lurk.

I didn't say there was anything

wrong

with your moving your vote, just that it seemed odd. The way you reacted to that

is

a little scummy, though - you seem too eager to please, to avoid suspicion rather than find those who are suspicious.

FOS: Seol for making too much sense.