Open 226: Big Love - Game over! Town wins!

[chihuahua0]

...but is he noobscum or are you policy voting again?

Oh yeah, one key difference: he's not a noob.

I don't mean newbie.

I scanned the whole thread and the bottom line is: he's a lurker. Before the "I LIKE TO LURK WITH MY LOVER" post on page 7, most of his posts were inrevalent. Besides a random vote in the beginning (which is still in place) a random comment, a post directed to the mod, and maybe a few other posts, he hadn't said much. He hadn't accuse anybody, and he hardly answered any of our questions. I therefore declare him as the co-VI (if I am a VI) and a lurker.

So it is a policy vote. But also I think he might be a lurking scum trying to avert attention from himself. However, his matter of posting just made it worst.

Millar, please talk in your defense.

[chihuahua0]

And now for my first ever post-by-post analysis! Brought to you by the letters L, W, N, M, and Ch!

Post #4: Conform post. Nothing interesting here.

Confirm/ with or without love lol

Post #53: Random vote. Still in place

Vote: yabba

Post #108: Random post.

ARGHHHHHHHHHHHH OH MY GOSH IM SO IN LOVE WITH YOU GIRL NA NA N NA NA NA NA NA NA OH MY GOD SO MANY WAYS TO LOVE YOU

Post #113: Rebuttal to pervious comments from Robocopter87, youngminii, and Muthaa. Muthaa askes if the pervious post was to claim lover.

ARGHHHHHHHHHHHH OH MY GOSH IM SO IN LOVE WITH YOU GIRL NA NA N NA NA NA NA NA NA OH MY GOD SO MANY WAYS TO LOVE YOU

Post #121: Comment to mod.

MOD: Xite has only played with me in current games; so technically isn't the breaking the rules if she is bringing them up

Post #162: Claims to be a lover and says he’s lurking.

I LUVE TO LURK WITH MY LOVER!

Post #185: See below analysis.

CUPID'S LOVE HEARTKILL : SHATTERED VIEWPOINT

Post #189: Claims that Shattered Viewpoint isn’t a lover. Claims love with Robocopter87.

Its called a joke; or rather an assumption that Shattered doesn't in fact have any lovers lol. Unlike some of us; ay robocopter my love!

Post #191: Explains why he claimed.

Because 1) I was bored
2) I reckon we should claim our lovers; even if i dont know if your scum or not but i know you are am ine....we talked pre-game

Post #193: Explains again.

TACTIC my friend!

Post #195: Still claiming love.

Play along? Are you denying, your my love?

Post #198: I can’t read this.

Ooops lol....my mistake....i was going to out my lover and then after your response actually checked my role and your that my lover; must have thought of u and marathon.

SCUM!

Post #209: Says that yabbaguy is distancing:

irony of yabbaguy trying to distance from me lol...no i actually read my role pm

Post: #215: Talks about Treacherous Lover.

MAFIA HAVE LOVERS WHO ARE TOWN DUMB DUMB!

Conclusion: Robocopter85 might be millar13’s lover. Millar13 is a VI. Millar13 is a lurker. Millar13 might be Treacherous Lover. He’s too nooby (or scummy) to live.

[Mr.Sandman]

Yabbaguy, answer my question in #213 please

[ZeroFang]

Unvote; Vote Millar13

For not posting content, confusing us, and randomly posting. We have few leads and a VI. Even if he's a townie (which I highly doubt), I'm happy with his lynch. Perhaps it'll up the quality of this thread a bit.

[yabbaguy]

@mr.sandman: I unvoted because I felt posts like this at least try to poke holes in theories. I also think that his general behavior towards millar, while extremely naive, reflects potential Town motives, if obscured by the inherent imperfections of being a newbie and not having any concrete sense for how to deal with extreme irrationality.

Perhaps chihuahua could very easily be contriving the case on millar though, naive or not, it's easy to pounce on someone who is or claims/appears to be of less-than-perfect intelligence in real life or in this game. Not discounting that. I need to have yet another look.

@chihuahua: Are you familiar with millar in any way (in other words: have you seen him play games, interact with the site, etc.)?

Also... noob != newb? Wuh?

[Mr.Sandman]

@mr.sandman: I unvoted because I felt posts like this at least try to poke holes in theories. I also think that his general behavior towards millar, while extremely naive, reflects potential Town motives, if obscured by the inherent imperfections of being a newbie and not having any concrete sense for how to deal with extreme irrationality.

Perhaps chihuahua could very easily be contriving the case on millar though, naive or not, it's easy to pounce on someone who is or claims/appears to be of less-than-perfect intelligence in real life or in this game. Not discounting that. I need to have yet another look.

@chihuahua: Are you familiar with millar in any way (in other words: have you seen him play games, interact with the site, etc.)?

Also... noob != newb? Wuh?

I see. To me, there didn't look like a massive shift in the way chihuahua was playing until after the post I asked you about. I'm still not entirely convinced.

However, for now

UNVOTE

VOTE: millar

Until he starts acting like he's scum hunting at least

[Pittbunny]

Also... noob != newb? Wuh?

Minor technicality. Newb = new to game, noob = should not play the game.

I'm going to say that millar wagon is far too easy for today. Find scum elsewhere.

[millar13]

MOD: Request Replacement

[yabbaguy]

millar, you've done it now, and I don't think anyone really wants you back, but that's REALLY poor sportsmanship to quit whilst a wagon's being formed on you.

[Shattered Viewpoint]

ITT, chihuahua proves his idiocy.

Also, millar is a tool.

Also also, Pitt's just making stuff up now.

@Mod: votecount, please?

Thanks, ever so.

[millar13]

MOD: i'll stay
Vote: millar

lynch me instead
idc tbh

[Pittbunny]

...

Now you're just being a poor player. Play to your win condition or not at all, man. =/

[Robocopter87]

Good thing he was lying about being my Lover.

UNVOTE: Chihuahua
VOTE: Millar13

[millar13]

Im scum lol....who approached this game all wrong. soz

[Robocopter87]

Well, are you the treacherous Lover?

[millar13]

no...im just a plain vanilla townie your friggin' idiots.

[millar13]

EBWOP: people like Mr. Sandman are the clear scum....people just needed a lesson in


"IT NEVER THAT EASY"

boneheads

[Robocopter87]

Millar, you can reclaim yourself.

Just give a few reasons. Start analyzing and

communicating

results with us. So we can get where your coming from. You're never any use to us if you just start blabbering on about being someones lover.

Please, so we can all have a little common sense and some peace of mind.
UNVOTE: Millar

For now, to see if he complies. If he does not, he is of no use to us and a burden. One of the many reasons village idiots are so detrimental is that in LyLo people can't focus and choose scum because the VI is screaming "IM SO SCUMMY" and just gets in the way. We can't have that.

[millar13]

Burden Smurden

[Pittbunny]

You are pressing it. Take a deep breath, get some water, and try again. Seriously.

[Robocopter87]

Burden Smurden?

Dude, your just being a jerk. Its a game. Chill out. why join a game if your going to act like this?

[Sanxion]

...

Mod: If requested by enough people, can we replace Millar?

[Pittbunny]

Mafuyu doesn't think it should be the call of the playerbase to ever replace someone. Just let the mod handle it if the case worsens past the point of playability.

[Pittbunny]

Oh look I did it again SV.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

...

Mod: If requested by enough people, can we replace Millar?

I've never seen it happen before, so I would honestly say I'd have to consult on that. He did withdraw his own request for replacement. You do, however, have a method of removing him from the game if you all, y'know, lynch him. That option is always on the table.

Vote Count #6

• chihuahua0 (don_johnson, smashbro_of_the_SSS) 2 (L-8)
  millar13 (chihuahua0, ZeroFang, Mr.Sandman, millar13) 4 (l-6)
  Muthaa (Sanxion, Xite91, chihuahua0) 3 (L-7)
  Robocopter87 (Muthaa, Shattered Viewpoint) 2 (L-8)
  Xite91 (youngminii) 1 (L-9)
  yabbaguy (Wacka Alpaca) 1 (L-9)

Not voting: Fidelis, Guthrie, PaltryExcuse, Pittbunny, Reverse Simplicity, Robocopter87, yabbaguy

With 19 alive, 10 votes are required for a lynch.

V/LA: don_johnson (Thursday, July 8th), smashbro_of_the_SSS (Friday, July 9th)

Deadline is Wednesday, July 21st at 8pm UK time.

Activity Check!

Guthrie has not picked up his prod. I am seeking replacement.

Pittbunny has responded to the prod.

Muthaa, Reverse Simplicity and youngminii made their most recent posts on Friday. Given the holiday weekend, they'll br prodded if they haven't posted by some arbitrary point on the evening of the 7th, UK time.