Gears of War Mafia (Over!)

[ReaperCharlie]

Reck, answer my questions.

[xRECKONERx]

Weak, Fate. Weak.

EDIT: What questions.

[ReaperCharlie]

May I direct your attention to #1126. Your name was bolded. Do you even read the thread before you post?

[xRECKONERx]

Yeah, I just usually skip your posts.

[Fate]

^

[xRECKONERx]

Oh, wait. Jack. I did read that post I just didn't realize it was multiple choice and not just 'here's why I hate these people'.

[DrippingGoofball]

k since this game is stagnating rrreeeaaalllyyyy bad, I have questions for these 4 people:

Jack, Fate, xReck, and DGB.

Sure. I can humor that.

1.

ReaperCharlie

> town. Even if he weren't a mason, he'd be town. He is very responsive to situational changes, doesn't fear to offend, seems to be working towards a town wincon.
3.

xRECKONERx

Amish_Charney

> town. His story is bad enough to sound honest. If he were scum not having sent an investigation power to the mod, he could easily make something up and cover his own keister - he'd know who the townies are, he could just declare one to be town and be over with. But he didn't do that, so he's got to be town.
4.

BloodCovenent

> conditional/scummy. He's just tunneling Fate. He's sucking up and sheeping him like crazy. On the other hand, since I'm specifically a stranded inventor, I could see, despite his uber-scummy play, how there could be a COG inventor as well, since they seem to be two different factions. He could also be scum Inventor. What bugs me is his refusal to consider that there may be a second inventor. I can understand skepticism, that would be a townie reaction, but outright refusal sounds scummy.
5.

Slicey

> non-entity.
6.

Jack

> town. tough call. I am biased because he wants to lynch me, and I know he's wrong, but if I'm going to be a big girl and not let emotions get in the way, I have to say that from a townie perspective, his reasoning isn't flawed - it's just not his fault, or not my fault, that second-guessing the setup leads to incorrect conclusion. I don't consider it completely impossible that he mega-bus'ed a weak team mate on Day 1. But. Likelihood of this happening isn't, rationally speaking, that high. So. Thinking about it, and reluctantly putting my personal feelings aside, town.
8.

MehPlusRawr

> Just iso'd his contribution. It's like a prod & VLA party. I'd lynch him.
10.

Karma

> Just iso'd him as well. Active lurking. Trying not to step on toes. SCUM.
11.

Fate

> scum. :hate: the language, the insults, the pushing people around, the tunneling, the unpleasantness, it's just unbearable. I can't possibly iso him his hateful rants of allcaps. I don't care what his alignment is. I want him dead. So. I'm thinking, if I were scum, I'd hate him just as much. And I'd night kill him. As would any self-respecting scumbag. Any self-respecting scumbag would gun down town Fate. Unless, of course, Fate is a team mate.
13.

kunkstar7

> town. Maybe not a super strong town read because he's not a heavy poster.

This was a good exercise, because I was definitely letting my emotions dictate my thoughts. Upon reconsideration, I'd be most willing to lynch is Fate. In second place, actually, would be Karma.

[DrippingGoofball]

Gah, EBWOP, I meant to color Jack in green.

[Sajin]

Alright so I am replacing Slicey.

Would anyone care to summarize the important events?

Am reading up atm.

[xRECKONERx]

The important events are that I received a one-shot scum investigation N1 and N2, only I

forgot

I had it N2 and didn't use it. DGB claims to have given me one of them, and BC claims to have given me the other. ReaperCharlie is the second mason (since one is dead already).

[Fate]

"Karma is scummy as hell active lurking and doing scummy things."
"Fate is scummy by way of AD HOM and the fact that if he were town scum would have fuckin killed him just because he's easy to hate."
"MPR has offered nothing to this game though he appears to be active on site."

???

"I want to lynch Fate"

[BloodCovenent]

Alright so I am replacing Slicey.

Would anyone care to summarize the important events?

Am reading up atm.

read the GD thread for yourself and don't take our opinions of the events as any reason to trust us.

[Fate]

Sajin:

D1-
A shit ton of people were quickwagonned.
Jack was tunneling CMAR and no one was listening.
Jack fakeclaimed Neighbor with CMAR and called him scum with Socrates.
DGB pushes for Socrates lynch over CMAR because CMAR would just be a scum neighbor
CMAR is lynched without DGB's help, CMAR is scum.

D2-
People mull around, no real wagon are popular. I try to get DGB lynched
Jack comes out with his decision that Socrates should be lynched
Socrates is quicklynched by a doublevoter who is likely not town aligned, he was a watcher with results but did not claim.

D3-
Jack reveals his fakeclaim neighbor gambit
DGB is wagonned and claims inventor given Reck an inspect N2.
BC counter-claims Inventor and FULL claims inventor giving BC an inspect N1.
Reck did not use an inspect N2.
DGB full claims copying BC's claim
Reaper claims mason for no reason and tunnels Reck and Fate as a team.
A massclaim is proposed.
Jack claims Dominic Santiago, Vanilla.
No one else claims.
MPR hasn't posted anything of value.
You replace Slicey and hopefully good things will happen.

[xRECKONERx]

"No one else claims."

I did.

[BloodCovenent]

3.

xRECKONERx

Amish_Charney

> town. His story is bad enough to sound honest. If he were scum not having sent an investigation power to the mod, he could easily make something up and cover his own keister - he'd know who the townies are, he could just declare one to be town and be over with. But he didn't do that, so he's got to be town.

11.

Fate

> scum. :hate:

the language, the insults,

the pushing people around, the tunneling, the unpleasantness,

it's just unbearable.

I can't possibly iso him his hateful rants of allcaps.

I don't care what his alignment is. I want him dead.

So. I'm thinking, if I were scum, I'd hate him just as much. And I'd night kill him. As would any self-respecting scumbag. Any self-respecting scumbag would gun down town Fate. Unless, of course, Fate is a team mate.
This was a good exercise, because I was definitely letting my emotions dictate my thoughts. Upon reconsideration, I'd be most willing to lynch is Fate. In second place, actually, would be Karma.

EXCEPT WE WERE THE FIRST TWO ON THE WAGON

DEAR

FUCKING

CHRIST

Edited for clarity and content-control. ~Shotty

EXCEPT WE WERE THE FIRST TWO ON THE FUCKING GODDAMN MOTHERFUCKING CUNT-ASS TITTY-SHITTING WAGON

Since the mod showed up, and neglected to modkill you, I will request replacement.

MOD PLEASE REPLACE ME.

Because the

exact same

rules you apply to fate cannot apply to Reck.

[Fate]

You claimed D1 Reck shhhhhhhh

[Fate]

Hey BC what do we call it when someone who reads two people exhibiting the same behavior differently?























SCUM BUDDY DEFENSE

[BloodCovenent]

Oh, Fate, i think that Soc did claim to have watched Reck. He either saw reck TAKE my ability, or USE another ability.

I was gonna say tunneling.

[xRECKONERx]

Don't lump me in with that shit.

Anyway, this game is pointless until other people besides Fate/me/BC/DGB start contributing. MPR? Kunk? Karma?

[DrippingGoofball]

Because the

exact same

rules you apply to fate cannot apply to Reck.

xRECK had the good sense to tune it off.

Fate is still carrying on.

[Sajin]

Alright so I am replacing Slicey.

Would anyone care to summarize the important events?

Am reading up atm.

read the GD thread for yourself and don't take our opinions of the events as any reason to trust us.

I am reading the thread for myself.

But: 1- This is to ensure I do not miss anything.

2- Finding out what others feel is "important" or "not important" can lead to better reads.

[BloodCovenent]

Oh, Fate, i think that Soc did claim to have watched Reck. He either saw reck TAKE my ability, or USE another ability.

I was gonna say tunneling.

I take it back. It wasn't soc. must have been someone else.

[BloodCovenent]

Man, I want to lynch RC soooo bad. Fucking mason role.

Wow, seriously, where the fuck ARE they?

'kay, so if you remove me, Fate, RC, DGB, and BC from the equation, we're now left with Slicey, Jack, MPR, Karma, or kunk for today's lynch. kunk's last post seems townish. This is FUCKING ridiculous that Slicey still hasn't been replaced yet. Jesus Christ.

GUYS WHY THE FUCK DID REAPER JUST... oh. Bravo. 10/10

I'm not sold on this DGB lynch AT ALL. DGB, who is scum?

I'm not sure. Did I miss something? The past 4-6 pages of this game have been a complete clusterfuck.

@DGB, that was just a few from his last page of ISO's.

[DrippingGoofball]

BC, it's not like I'm a virgin entering a convent and all hung up on f-bombs. I don't indulge in the practice, but it's so common I'd be reciting Hail Mary's 24/7 if I cared.

xRECK was really bad in his pissing contest with Fate, but Fate is carrying on with abusing the players in a way that completely sucks my enjoyment from the game. I can't say that xRECK is making his game a quagmire of hate. Fate is.

I don't care if YOU think they are equally bad. I don't. My criteria are obviously different from yours.

[Fate]

REGARDLESS of that obvious dissonance the scummier part of DGB's post is the fact she wants to policy lynch me D3 for "hate" instead of players she says are scummy. I have this effect on scum:

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 4#p2357114
^Scum claimed 1-shot vig who shot me because he didn't like playing with me and that I was unpleasant. One person fell for it, the rest didn't He was lynched and town won a perfect game of never mislynching. (Due in part to my N1 guilty and pushing of both scum D2).