Gears of War Mafia (Over!)

[Fate]

Hint:
It involves DGB's gender and lynching her.

[ReaperCharlie]

k since this game is stagnating rrreeeaaalllyyyy bad, I have questions for these 4 people:

Jack, Fate, xReck, and DGB.

Out of the other three listed, who do you want to lynch most, and why? And on down the list. And if not, why not.

For example:

1. Jack. He's being worthless to the town and skating by, possibly scum hoping to sacrifice a partner day 1 to aggressive play and then ride that thunder to a bunch of mislynches the rest of the game, picking off the people who disagree with him at night. Also, a lynch on Jack will tell us more than a lynch on anyone else will.
2. Reck. He keeps changing his mind, hopping wagons wherever he thinks the town wants him to be, catering to our every whim and tickling our fancy like a good little scum-sheep. Often contradicts himself blatantly, and seems to try to lay low and deflect attention in the aftermath.
3. Fate. He seems to want to control the town a bit too much and doesn't want any of the lynches except DGB to go through, even though there is substantial evidence against others in the game. Also, he buddies up to Reck a lot, which is odd considering how scummy Reck is.
4. DGB. She's all over the place, and a lot of the things she says are conflicting, though not quite as much as Reck's. She's polarized herself from Reck, whether on accident or on purpose. The entire Reck vs DGB thing could be a complete sham. But she's just not as good a lynch as the other three.

There's a shining example of what you should be doing.

And if you're not voting for your number 1 suspect, you should immediately do so.

I also propose an alliance between myself, BloodCovenant, and kunkstar7.

@mod: I also highly recommend some prods for anyone who hasn't posted in the last 24 hours, and replacing those who haven't been posting, like maybe Slicey, who's posted FOUR times, or MPR, who's only posted ELEVEN times. This game has stagnated to the point of only the same 4 people talking, which is only about half the game. And it's becoming un-fun and starting to suck more than I like to say. I've never replaced out of a game before, but I'm seriously considering replacing out of this one. FFS, in the entire two game days (THREE WEEKS in real time) that my mason topic was open, neither my mason partner or his replacement made a single post.

[Jack]

I posted about 50 times catching scum-dgb and now I'm waiting for her to be lynched. Why do you think dgb is town reaper?

Where did kise and sens disagree with me?

[Shotty to the Body]

Sajin replaces Slicey effective immediately, vote count incoming.

[Shotty to the Body]

Votecount

Jack (3): kunkstar7, ReaperCharlie, xRECKONERx
DGB (2): Fate, Jack
Fate (1): Karma

Not Voting (4): Sajin, MehPlusRawr, BloodCovenent, DGB

6 to lynch.

Looking for an MPR replacement.

[Fate]

1. JACK IS SCUMHUNTING CAN YOU FUCKIN READ?
2. RECK IS PROBSCUM BUT WE CAN GET TO HIM LATER
3. IF I BUDDY UP TO RECK MAYBE HE WON'T KILL ME, JESUS. PLUS I NEED HIS VOTE TO LYNCH DGB
4. SCUM SCUM SCUM SCUM DGB SCUM SCUM

Reck you said one of DGB and I were scum, ITS TIME TO CASH THAT FUCKIN CHECK STOP BACKTRACKING.

Also RC if you read the dead QT of Wisborg Asylum you'd see how ridiculous you look when you try to make a fail alliance and lead town into the shitter.

[BloodCovenent]

Back. Reaper... there is no way in hell i am getting into bed with you.

go go wagon dgb >.>

[Fate]

BC HAS RESISTED THE BRAINWASHING OF DUMBTOWN

YAAAAAAAAAAY BC

[Jack]

And it's becoming un-fun and starting to suck more than I like to say. I've never replaced out of a game before, but I'm seriously considering replacing out of this one. FFS, in the entire two game days (THREE WEEKS in real time) that my mason topic was open, neither my mason partner or his replacement made a single post.

Ouch, that sucks reaper. Mason is a great role, too bad we didn't end up being masons, we would have had a lot of fun chatting together. Please don't replace out though, I think I speak for everyone when I say you'd be sorely missed.

*vote dgb vote dgb vote dgb*

[Fate]

I THINK YOU SPEAK FOR YOUR GOD DAMN SELF WHEN YOU SAY HE WILL BE MISSED.

SOMEONE PM SPYREX/HOOPLA/AWESOMESAUCE TO REPLACE REAPER PLEASE.

[Fate]

oh wait I c wut u did thar Jack.

Hope it works

[ReaperCharlie]

1. JACK IS SCUMHUNTING CAN YOU FUCKIN READ?
2. RECK IS PROBSCUM BUT WE CAN GET TO HIM LATER
3. IF I BUDDY UP TO RECK MAYBE HE WON'T KILL ME, JESUS. PLUS I NEED HIS VOTE TO LYNCH DGB
4. SCUM SCUM SCUM SCUM DGB SCUM SCUM

Reck you said one of DGB and I were scum, ITS TIME TO CASH THAT FUCKIN CHECK STOP BACKTRACKING.

Also RC if you read the dead QT of Wisborg Asylum you'd see how ridiculous you look when you try to make a fail alliance and lead town into the shitter.

yea, except we won with 9 townies to 1 scum; and I even nailed the scum on the final day w/o a dream.
one out of 10, and I nailed him dead to rights. tell me I'm not awesome. just try and tell me.

[Fate]

You're not awesome.

That set-up was horribly in favor of town with two sane UBERMEGA role-cops etc.

I mean yeah, SOMETIMES when it gets down to having 6 innocents, a priest, and whatever else the hell there was you can find scum y simple process of elimination. I mean you're not retarded Reaper, if I've said that I take it back, you're just wrong. A lot. Especially about me.

[ReaperCharlie]

Actually, I'm not gonna re-reread and type up everything. Plus, I've got dinner soon, so this'll have to be relatively succinct compared to what I made it sound like in my last post. Sorry to disappoint anyone lol... and if you want reasons for my reads on anyone, please let me know, and I'll do my best to explain it to you. Also, a lot of this is based on CMAR being scum, so if you have a problem with my reads: go back yourself and re-read the thread. Then, we can compare notes.

Town Reads

-

SensFan

(because of silverbullet. this slot

is

town. No two ways about it)
-

Jack

(tunneled CMAR, second-guessed himself, and then helped get CMAR lynched)
-

Karma

(not scum w/CMAR. re-read if you can't tell right away)
-

kunkstar7

(also not scum w/CMAR. this one's harder to pick up on though)

Mixed Reads

-

BloodCovenent

(page 6, he says he's suspicious of CMAR, Jack, Karma. by now, it's blatantly obvious that neither Karma or Jack are scum with CMAR. But... his focus on me and vote for me on page 10 gives me them good town-vibes, even though I'm not scum. He appears to be actually scumhunting. Also one of his posts on page 18 makes me feel better about him. I wouldn't put him right in the town pile though yet)
-

DrippingGoofball

(I don't know if she's actually reading the game, or just skimming the previous page or two before writing a post and voting someone new each time. A lot of her late-D1 posts look like CMAR-bussing and Jack-buddying. I'm not getting good feelings about her, but I somehow suspect she's town anyway)
-

Socrates

(I have a totally mixed read on Socrates. some posts flat out convince me that he's scum, but some convince me that he's town.. so... yeah. but he's one of my leaning-scum reads so he's at the bottom of this list, closest to scum)

Scum Reads

-

Fate

- #1 scum suspect. (early on it appears like he's going for an easy mislynch on silverbullet, which originally set off my scumdar because this is fate's scum meta. Looking back, my scumdar started beeping up a storm at CMAR saying Fate was town... no hesitation. just like that. Another reason is when he's ordering me to vote for Karma. He doesn't say 'vote for Karma,' he says 'get your vote off CMAR'. Major scum points for that. Also, it's pretty clear he was revving up his chainsaw defense until I DID pretend to 'see the light' and I switched votes to CMAR. It is interesting to note that he completely backs off me from that point on. Also, on page 9, check out Soc's post that says 'Heyheyhey, I call shenanigans!' And to top it all off, he's been buddying up to me hardcore since I unvoted CMAR, which is the polar opposite of what he's done to me in other games, regardless of who I'm voting).
-

xRECKONERx

(top of page 11 I call him lazy. which is true. I've never seen him NOT be lazy. IMMEDIATELY following, he posts one of the ONLY content posts I've EVER seen him post... every SINGLE time I've seen him play town he's been lazy, antagonistic, and happy-go-lucky with his votes. which is pretty much how his play has been this game, except for that post. that made me think a lot, to another game where we were scum together... in that game, he posted more content and less fluff/idiocy, and that immediately came to mind when I thought of this post. shortly afterwards he claimed VT -- who would ever think a scum would do that? WIFOMspiral... and since then has posted precious little in the way of actual content again, probably because one of his scumbuddies told him 'WTF? don't do that again, idiot! It's obvious you aren't playing to your town meta!'... and magically, now reck has reverted back to playing like his town meta, which is sheeping after just about everyone, voting just about everyone, omgusing, buddying, and in general trying to play like fate. which is funny, because they're actually scum buddies this game. but I wanna lynch fate first.

(

cue:

Fate, chainsaw defending Reck, saying: oooh!!! reaper has inside info that reck's scumbuddy supposedly

talked

to him! reaper must be scum because he's got inside info on whether or not scum can daytalk!!! omfg! vote: RC)

Null Reads

-

Slicey

(lurking hardcore)
-

MehPlusRawr

(also lurking a lot)
-

Kise

(ALSO also lurking... luckily, he was the NK. scum did us a favor)

Thoughts:

-I'm surprised that Jack didn't get NK'd last night.
-I'm guessing there are 4 scum, probably because it's 14 players and not 12. What other reason would there be for 4 scum?
-There weren't 2 NK's last night... so... maybe there's no third-party, or maybe the doctor protected Jack (who I was pretty sure was going to die). Maybe if there's an SK, they killed the dude that died, and Jack's death was blocked by the doc.
-I think I know who the doc is, not gonna say.
-That'd be funny if Jack was JACK from the game. lol

F*CK it. I am going with my gut. If Jack is gambiting that good then he deserves to win.

Unvote; Vote: Reck

[ReaperCharlie]

Also, I'd like to hear some speculation about an SK-type role.

[DrippingGoofball]

BC HAS RESISTED THE BRAINWASHING OF DUMBTOWN

YAAAAAAAAAAY BC

So, you know RC and xRECK are town. Interesting.

[ReaperCharlie]

I'm confirmed (i.e. not counter-claimed), and BC is givin' off them townie vibes somewhat. It's not a hard conclusion to come to.

But I don't see anywhere where Fate said BC was town. He only said I was town. How do you extrapolate that, DGB?

And please answer my #1126, thanks!

[ReaperCharlie]

Why do you think dgb is town reaper?

I don't, necessarily. I just think she's not the best lynch for today.

Where did kise and sens disagree with me?

Is this question directed at me?

[ReaperCharlie]

Where did kise and sens disagree with me?

Is this question directed at me?

Oh I see. nvm. Yeah this was more of speculation... Also why I switched my vote to Reck.

[DrippingGoofball]

But I don't see anywhere where Fate said BC was town. He only said I was town. How do you extrapolate that, DGB?

Not quite - Fate is congratulating BC for not letting himself be influenced by dumb townies. Dumb townies. So. The players that BC isn't sheeping are dumb townies. Not scum. Dumb townies. And Fate may actually know, for having the scum listed in his role PM.

And please answer my #1126, thanks!

I'm doing that right now in another FF window.

[xRECKONERx]

I know that RC is town (duh mason duh). I

think

Fate is town. I've been over this. Actually, though, Fate, I have a question for you:

Why would locust-DGB give me a locust investigation tool?

[Fate]

I already said Reck that I sadly think you told DGB about what you got N1, and she used it in her fakeclaim to out the town inventor.

Sowwy Reck

[Fate]

The way BC claimed is town, are you fucking serious DGB?

You ALWAYS call peopel TOWN

and TOWN
THSI

and TOWN THAT.

Remember when you called sorasscum TOWN?

And now you're trying to twist that into a "HE KNOWS WHO TOWN IS HE IS SCUM" tell.

Oh lord DGB this strategy is NOT workin out for you. You should've bussed your buddies D1

[xRECKONERx]

Well, seeing as how I

know

my alignment, and your argument for scum-DGB is totally dependent on me being scum, I will not be joining you. But I

will

unvote

until we get some goddamn replacements and prods up in this bitch.

[Fate]

Ok then.

DGBscum
ReckTown:

DGB gave you an inspection thing to role-confirm herself as scum inventor, she plans on killing you tonight.

Happy>???