Harry Potter Mafia - Over!

[FakeGod]

@RC: that was a really awesome case on Dram, I was like whoa this guy knows what he's talking about.

Then I see !?!?!?!?!?! Vote: Esp.....

Apparently, Esp's vote on the guy you want lynched just collapsed your awesome case on Dram? Show more conviction, Dumbledore!

If Esp's bussing Dram, so be it. I believe Dram lynch is the best lynch we could do today.

btw, I can't get make head nor tail of Furc.

[Nobody Special]

Oh NS,

you

never got above, like, 3 or 4 votes on me.
It's 6 to lynch ^_^;

Thank you for confirming yourself as scum.

[dramonic]

I beg your pardon?

[Nobody Special]

"You" as in You=town. Separating the groups. Scum admission if I ever saw one. Mark my words.

[dramonic]

You as in you=people supporting my lynch.

Pronouns are fickle things, arent they?

[SpyreX]

RC:

A, B, and C are all solid. Yes. However, I still don't think its a slip because of:

D.) Ohh, there was one kill last night. It was torn to shreds. There was no wizard kill. Looks like a doc got lucky.

The issue everyone is having is the last bit which could be:
Looks like a doc got lucky
Looks like a RB got lucky
Looks like we have a BP
Looks like they both wanted him dead
Etc.

Replacing in to one kill I assumed that -something- happened last night to deflect at least a kill.

Thats why I dont like this wagon.

[Furcolow]

why the hell is dramonic alive
he is going to flip red mark my words

[Furcolow]

"btw, I can't get make head nor tail of Furc."
don't worry about me
even if i am near lynch i am going to prove myself pro-town, so i am completely not worried about this at all

[Furcolow]

RC:

A, B, and C are all solid. Yes. However, I still don't think its a slip because of:

D.) Ohh, there was one kill last night. It was torn to shreds. There was no wizard kill. Looks like a doc got lucky.

The issue everyone is having is the last bit which could be:
Looks like a doc got lucky
Looks like a RB got lucky
Looks like we have a BP
Looks like they both wanted him dead
Etc.

Replacing in to one kill I assumed that -something- happened last night to deflect at least a kill.

Thats why I dont like this wagon.

regardless of what "deflected" the kill, most people didn't see it, and his "congratulations" was more of "an unintentional admission of guilt".

Furthermore, as NS just showed, he is STILL making slipups.

[farside22]

Okay I finally got an hour to sit down and read. My brain went to mush at page 22.


Ns post filler post
Calls IH opportunist, when question later doesn't have a reason or rhyme for this comment.
mb53 by page 5 this guy strikes me as floating scum.
Espy wishy wash I don't like his taking a step back here when I ask him why he thinks Sudo is town
NS seriously scummy stuff Backtracking and making things up is the first thing I think of reading post like this.
Ns avoiding he avoid answering the purpose of his vote or why he found IH opportunist still

Oh, I see what Nobody Special was looking at. I don't agree with it, but I can see where he is coming from. Not scummy on his part at all.

What dod you see here?

I got a rather low-key, non-reaction from IH. I would think that bad-scum would freak just a little at that accusation; therefore the reaction serves (in my mind) to push IH a little towards town.

I'm neither happy nor unhappy with the reaction itself; I'm just happy that I got one. (I detest being ignored.)

I don't get this.
mb53 is so scum based on this post concern Thinking too much about what is best and showing concern about it.

Esp still being scummy vote and reasoning on RC was pretty craptabulous.

ML replaces mb and claims miller. I really don't like his vote on RC. It's a crappy post coming from him too.

Knowing ooba is a traitor and based on his catch up post one of these 4 is probable scum

Scum potentials: {MMM,RC,Sudo,Espeonage}

Raj votes for RC for no reason stated

Read on FG as of page 10 he ask lots of questions but I see no real scum hunting from him.

kmd's vote on RC on page 10 makes no sense. I didn't see a reason he thought RC scum any more at this point.

Rereading this again

Ok.

-Started out posting non-content
-When called on non-content, you posted the "lame attempt" post just to appear to be posting content.
-misrepped my callout of the above
-laughed off my case and joke voted well after everyone was done with the RVS
-When I made real points, but also included jokes, you chose to respond to the jokes and ignore the points
-I forget who it was, but you called someone out for using only the scumtell of lack of activity when at the time, you were doing the exact same thing
-Then there's the whole FakeGod thing where you call him on lurking and vote him while admitting there are worse offenders of the exact same thing.
-When I point out the above point, you say call it a chainsaw defense of FakeGod
-The glasses on your avatar diasappear too quickly

Couldn't you say that what you said earlier about RC could fit under Raj? In regards to non content and lame attempt at posting? So I'm thinking this is really hypocritical

FG seriously? there is 16 players total in the game you have one scum suspect that even you gave a hard time for claiming miller without a cause and you don't think a newb knows better about claiming miller early?

So calling FG scum at this point.

KMD: Ooba flipped death eather mafia traitor. I don't believe just because the words death eater (which was a group in the book) changes much with a traitor role. :'/

@RC: Dramonic is correct in his thought process on the death. I agree that someone being scratched and torn as desribed would not come from a death eater group. Did you get a note what hit you that "weakened" you?

Right, and I think if SK then Fenrir, and if vig then Lupin.

So we shouldn't rely on this "vig" person/animal because he's probably SK.

@FG: Scum are more concerned with a SK then town. I'm really watching you.


Furcolow why are you voting for MPR?

Paraphrasing my PM. I'm Prongs the patronus. As a patronus I can't be killed in the conventional way. If I am killed I get to keep posting in the thread.

so when we kill you, you can confirm this. awesome.

unvote
##vote espeonage

Seriously? This is the only case and comment you have this game?


Things I noted: Ooba flipping scum traitor if he was signally I noted a few people he ignored that I find highly questionable (1) Nobody Special and Raj. He's scum and they are easy people to make comment about him. Those 2 and FG. I don't like seeing traitor's ignore players that are easy lynches or people that made comments that should be quetioned.

My top suspects as of now are NS, Raj and FG.

vote: Nobody Special

On a side note with Drama. First I can get where he would think someone was saved if you look at the kill. I don't know if it was a scum slip or not. I don't know why he assumes doctor save. That is the thing I would question more about a the lack of kill there is a number of reason's it didn't go through. I have a heavy eye on Dramonic as well.
Dramo: Why assume doctor save first with a lack of death eater kill?

[Furcolow]

"Furcolow why are you voting for MPR?

Furcolow wrote:

Espeonage wrote:Paraphrasing my PM. I'm Prongs the patronus. As a patronus I can't be killed in the conventional way. If I am killed I get to keep posting in the thread.



so when we kill you, you can confirm this. awesome.

unvote
##vote espeonage




Seriously? This is the only case and comment you have this game?"


um, have you even bloody read the last 2 pages? this comment is proof you don't read the thread.

[Furcolow]

Also

1- Esp, his claim is clearly bogus, too bad for him.
2- Furcolow, have you looked at his play today?

policy police
whee oo whee oo whee oo
lets lynch someone because he doesn't post like we want him to!

grow up.

you want a post? i'll give you one. the majority of your shit-posts are one liners. Anything else champ?
How about the fact you've said something was town on town without probably?

I'm finally up to date (kinda)!

So... I honestly don't think I've encountered a game where the doc succeeded this early. What's the standard procedure when that happens? =S

Also, the Sudo x Farside debate was sooo town

like i would say that their arguing was probably town on town, but farside might be mafia. you say it WAS town on town.

so you are admitting someone is a townie without saying "IF" (+10)

but that's not it. next is this gem:

Where the hell did I ever imply the existence of RC being targetted? 0_o
Don't put words in my mouth. All I said is that I was assuming the doc was successful during the night. Aren't you a hysterical little one.

meant this gem^

Congratulate the doctor on successful protection: Is scum (+20)

unvote
vote: dramonic

get out of our game scum


btw, my #2 lynch would be espeonage if i didn't have a little bit more information than you all. I believe him.
i had been fairly suspicious of RC, though i am not now. i was suspicious when i read farside, but idk.

i feel like we need to lynch dramonic tho so who cares about my #2? we will worry about that when he flips

*edited for it to have been like i intended*

this is me re-posting only one of my 3-4 huge, good posts. the reason i am posting these posts is to prove that farside22 doesn't read the thread. when she said "is this your only case on someone" when i was voting MPR or Espeonage who I have decided are town by this point ( i was fishing back then early on )..... i did that shit like 5-6 pages ago. Farside really either 1) reads slowly 2) doesnt read the thread or 3) likes to mess with people to get information...

perhaps i'm hard to read, but i'm town, so whatever. i believe she is trying to discredit me because she is scum and she is trying to offer up lynch candidates so that she can save dramonic who is likely her scum buddy.

[FakeGod]

There is nothing in my pm that says you win when all scum are dead or all parties XX are dead.

Well, this is weird. My win condition could conceivably be paraphrased as "win when scum are dead". Reaper, can you check your role PM please?

Forgot to mention this from awhile back. My PM could also be paraphrased as "win when scum are dead", and I've been meaning to ask, but we're trying to get Sudo by the deadline at the time (and I didn't want to derail wagon), and kinda forgot about it until farside posted.

I believe all townsfolks would have the same win con. farside, explain yourself.

@furc: I'm not calling you evil or anything. Just bizarre. And if Dram flips scum, then I think I know what your character (good not evil) might be.

[rajrhcpfreak]

unvote
vote: Furcolow

this needed to be done.

[Kmd4390]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Dramonic

This game is going to get very fun very quickly.

^This just may have been the scummiest post all game.

"You" as in You=town. Separating the groups. Scum admission if I ever saw one. Mark my words.

Um. Massive stretch here.

why the hell is dramonic alive
he is going to flip red mark my words

even if i am near lynch i am going to prove myself pro-town, so i am completely not worried about this at all

If you have role-related info on Dramonic, you should probably share that with the rest of the class. I don't get a scum vibe off of him at all.

What dod you see here?

I'm trying to remember back that far, but I think this was when Nobody Special said that MMM had extra knowledge. I think he meant MMM calling this a bastard game, which would imply that his role was bastardly.

Couldn't you say that what you said earlier about RC could fit under Raj? In regards to non content and lame attempt at posting? So I'm thinking this is really hypocritical

I dunno. Rajjkhfdjksghafjkgadfhngjkls hasn't really stood out to me one way or the other this game. I should probably get around to doing an ISO read of him or something.

KMD: Ooba flipped death eather mafia traitor. I don't believe just because the words death eater (which was a group in the book) changes much with a traitor role. :'/

Yeah, the words were switched around a little. Sens fixed it.

[SpyreX]

regardless of what "deflected" the kill, most people didn't see it, and his "congratulations" was more of "an unintentional admission of guilt".

Furthermore, as NS just showed, he is STILL making slipups.

I didn't need to "see" something to know that 1 kill in this setup sure as hell didn't make sense and then, upon reading the flavor, what kill missing seemed pretty obvious.

And that YOU = the town = I am scum = wooosh.

[MacavityLock]

Mac, you are misrepping Fake. He thought he saw a contradiction and felt it was cleared up, so he switched back to Dramonic.

Fine, I can see that. But I still think he was backed off of Esp wagon way too easily. It doesn't feel right.

farside, why wouldn't you look at these as well?

I wager that

at least

2 out of {RC, Kmd, Sudo, Esp, MMM} are scum.

I reverse my opinion on Kmd. Kmd, FG get added to the town list.
Town: {Mac, Kmd, FG}
Scum: {RC, Sudo, Esp, MMM}

RC you should full claim now. Not just the role name but abilities as well.

These, plus the one you quoted, reads to me like KMD and either Esp or

MMM

furc are scum. My problem is that both Esp and furc read kind of town to me, Esp more than furc.

Ah, but here's the kicker:

One question for FG and Kmd: Are you AC and AC?

AC&AC = Alecto and Amycus Carrow, Death Eaters teaching at Hogwarts in 7.

Let's lynch FG and KMD in quick succession, shall we?

[Kmd4390]

I think he meant alignment confirmed. Probably thought FakeGod and I were masons.

[MacavityLock]

I think he meant alignment confirmed. Probably thought FakeGod and I were masons.

BS. If he meant that, there's no way he would have repeated the AC acronym. Sorry scum, you going down.

[Nobody Special]

I got a rather low-key, non-reaction from IH. I would think that bad-scum would freak just a little at that accusation; therefore the reaction serves (in my mind) to push IH a little towards town.

I'm neither happy nor unhappy with the reaction itself; I'm just happy that I got one. (I detest being ignored.)

I don't get this.

What's to get? It was early D1, RVS, I wanted a reaction, I got one. Seriously. What's not to get?

And that YOU = the town = I am scum = wooosh.

Defending your scumpal?

[SpyreX]

The AC and AC doesn't make sense? I mean if the argument is he flat out gave up a huge chunk of the scumteam welll

[SpyreX]

The roll isn't at that ML, its at NS's amazing right above

[ReaperCharlie]

Maybe it's just me: I'm suspicious of SpyreX.

[Nobody Special]

I'm ALWAYS suspicious of SpyreX.

Always.

[Espeonage]

AC & AC.

I take it ooba didn't expect to die and wanted to give scum an indication that he was in-fact a traitor. I wouldn't be surprised if ML was right about the Carrows.