Harry Potter Mafia - Over!

[SpyreX]

Vote: Esp

I feel like I'm missing something important, but not enough to dissuade this fo now

[Furcolow]

I'm starting to wonder if Furcolow would be a better lynch than Espeon.

I'm starting to wonder if Kmd would be a better lynch than Dramonic

Dude, your OMGUS is showing. And in public no less.

some omgus are town

[Kmd4390]

I'm starting to wonder if Furcolow would be a better lynch than Espeon.

I'm starting to wonder if Kmd would be a better lynch than Dramonic

Dude, your OMGUS is showing. And in public no less.

some omgus are town

Why do you think I'm voting Esp over you?

I'm still wavering back and forth on your alignment. If OMGUS was a 100% foolproof scumtell, I'd be voting you.

[Furcolow]

if you voted me, i wouldn't care. i'd still be able to talk in thread and help the town.

[ReaperCharlie]

And, of course, if he's actually "lynchproof" that needs to be tested.

And potentially waste our lynch for the day? You seem more interested in getting a confirmed townie than lynching a scumbag. Since we already lynched town Day 1, I don't think that's wise. The traitor being killed last night WAS good, but we're still not in AWE-SAW shape yet.

My tendency is to think that Esp is just some kind of scum who also has one-shot lynch immunity, and is trying to gambit and use his one-shot unlynchable in the only smart way I can think of using it: by pretending it's a town ability, and using it to convince the town that he's with them. At least, that's what I'd do if I were scum with that kind of ability.

So it doesn't make sense to lynch him cause even if he's telling the truth about being unlynchable, it doesn't prove he's town, and doing so would still waste our lynch for the day (exactly the kind of thing scum wants -- barring a mislynch, but if the attention is on him already, maybe this is all he's got left up his sleeve. it makes sense if you think about it).

And then, of course, there's the off chance he's a jester...
*/me tenses up and waits for tomatoes to be thrown at him*

[Furcolow]

feels like reapercharlie is trying to save a scum-buddy to me with a chainsaw

\\

[ReaperCharlie]

No. It just makes sense, and I think dram is the better lynch.

[ReaperCharlie]

feels like reapercharlie is trying to save a scum-buddy to me with a chainsaw

\\

also, chainsaw means I'd be attacking his attacker, NOT just explaining why it's a bad idea to lynch him and expect it to clear him.

[Furcolow]

he COULD be a jester, right? then he'd

want

to get lynched

[ReaperCharlie]

he COULD be a jester, right? then he'd

want

to get lynched

>.>
<.<

*cough*

And then, of course, there's the off chance he's a jester...
*/me tenses up and waits for tomatoes to be thrown at him*

*throws a tomato at Furcolow*

[Furcolow]

oh, i didnt see that little text. i thought it was illegal to change text size

[Furcolow]

how do you kill a jester then? day vig?

[Furcolow]

hehehehe hahahaha I ARE HARRY POTTER LOL

[SpyreX]

No - "lynchproof" is one of those claims that HAS to be tested.

Not to mention lynchproof = counterclaiming a jailer.

And its hella bedtime.

GOD paranoia: What role would make sense to be lynchproof unless "something happened" in Harry Potter?

[Furcolow]

VOLDEMORT?

[Kmd4390]

Jester speculation (Peeves? lol) is bad.

If he's a jester, lynch him anyway. If lynching him ends the game in a jester win and everyone else loses, the game was poorly designed, especially in a Large. I can't see Sens doing that.

[Furcolow]

that's true.

[ReaperCharlie]

No - "lynchproof" is one of those claims that HAS to be tested.

even if it wastes a lynch? -_-

if enough others agree then yeah fine lets lynch him, but, i still

don't

think it's productive, as it trades us NOT ACTUALLY confirming a townie, for a scumkill (or possibly two) tonight. and he wouldn't even be confirmed town.

that just doesnt seem worth it

Not to mention lynchproof = counterclaiming a jailer.

what's this mean?

GOD paranoia: What role would make sense to be lynchproof unless "something happened" in Harry Potter?

unless what happened?

Jester speculation (Peeves? lol) is bad.

hehehe I could see that. but like you said, i doubt it'd end the game.

hehehehe hahahaha I ARE HARRY POTTER LOL

LOL

the things you did with that post restriction were so epic. i was rolling, like the whole game. HAHA

[MehPlusRawr]

hehehehe hahahaha I ARE HARRY POTTER LOL

Er, what?

[FakeGod]

Paraphrasing my PM. I'm Prongs the patronus. As a patronus I can't be killed in the conventional way. If I am killed I get to keep posting in the thread.

Ok here is what I propose. We try to lynch me today while we can still afford a mislynch in the case I misunderstood what can't be killed by normal means means. The it should count as no lynch. I am then confirmed in my role and we can move on to lynching scum.

Is it me, or did Esp say if he's killed he can still talk/vote in the first quote, and says something different (something about his lynch counting as a no lynch) in the second quote?

Unvote, Vote: Espeonage

[Espeonage]

As far as I interpret my role I am hard to kill and I can keep talking in thread after I die. I will lose my vote though.

[FakeGod]

Waaaait, so are you saying that your lynch count as no lynch, and even if you're somehow killed by some other means, you can still talk?

[Espeonage]

ok I don't know if I'm unlynchable. I think I might be though. I am able to talk in thread once I am dead but I have nothing else so that means no vote once I die.

[dramonic]

As far as I interpret my role I am hard to kill and I can keep talking in thread after I die. I will lose my vote though.

Will you still count for the sake of players to lynch?

[Espeonage]

Once I die, no.