Harry Potter Mafia - Over!

[ReaperCharlie]

I used investigate on jmj3000 last night, he is pro town. dam# i totally thought he was scum too... i just had that ITCH. i almost investigated ooba, allllmost, because i know how tricky he can be (has anyone ever played with him before? omfg), but figured i'd tentatively trust him this game until proven otherwise.

kmd brings up an interesting point about ooba's interactions with espeonage, i'll have to read more about that later.. i'm at work and can't post much atm, i'll get in a better re-read of the entire topic in the next few days, now that we have ooba's connections to analyze.


ALSO: I think the mafia tried to kill me last night, because I received a mod PM stating that I was 'weakened' and that I 'might not survive another direct attack'. soooo.... somebody else might have tried to kill ooba? ...maybe we have an SK running around too, i dont know. (though I don't know who it'd be, flavor-wise).

[dramonic]

I'm finally up to date (kinda)!

So... I honestly don't think I've encountered a game where the doc succeeded this early. What's the standard procedure when that happens? =S

Also, the Sudo x Farside debate was sooo town

[MehPlusRawr]

Oh come on, I was pretty sure Sudo was town.

Is there any way you could have written that which would have made it sound even more scummy?

Something like "Hi guys I knew 100% that Sudo was town. Not because I'm mafia. Just sayin'."

[ReaperCharlie]

hindsight is 20/20; it's easy to say that Sudo was town NOW.
do you have anything to say about anyone ELSE'S actions yesterday?

And um........ doc? who said anything about a doc?



igmeoy

[ReaperCharlie]

(that was @ dramonic)

[dramonic]

Did you even read the flavour for the kill?

[ReaperCharlie]

Yes. This?

You all wake up to pecking of the owl deliverring the Daily Prophet. Yawning, you put a knut in his pouch, grab a cup of coffee, and lazily scan the front cover.

"Man killed in savage attack"
There was a terrible murder last night, as Peter Pettigrew was found dead. His body has been scratched and torn all over, and it is unknown what could have done this damage. The sudden re-appearance of this man confirms that he was indeed the one who killed all those Muggles 15 years ago, though the location of the body suggests he was still trying to find his old Master.

Shaken somewhat, you Apparate to the meeting spot for the day's talks. To your great surprise, Peter Pettigrew - known to some as Wormtail - was the one you had designated ooba.

ooba, Peter Pettigrew (Death Eater Mafia Traitor), killed Night 1.

[ReaperCharlie]

I read it more than three times looking for it, and trying to find out how you extrapolated a doc from anything in there.

Nothing

about a doctor in there.

[dramonic]

I extrapolated that death eaters wouldnt kill by scratching and tearing <<

[ReaperCharlie]

hmmmm... well...

if you're town: that seems like quite a stretch... which relies

completely

on flavor.
if you're scum: that seems like a pretty bad slip. I'm inclined to think it's this, so...

vote: dramonic

[dramonic]

Erm, Reaper, the death eaters are WIZARDS. Why would their victim die from being scratched :S

[MehPlusRawr]

Wait, the Mafia can kill their traitors?

[FakeGod]

Good to see that a Death Eater has been killed during the night.

I'm going to assume that "His body has been scratched and torn all over" wasn't caused by a "Abracadebra". My guess is that vicious werewolf guy from Harry Potter, (I think his name was Fenrir Greyback?) is probably SK, and he killed ooba, while RC was attacked by the Death Eaters (mafia), hence he was "weakened".

However, Dramonic, I didn't see anything in there about a Doc either. I'm pretty sure that was a total scumslip. You somehow already knew that RC has been shot during the night, and that he survived. Therefore, you just assumed a doc saved him.

Vote: Dramonic

@MPR: Mafia probably doesn't know who the traitors are.

[dramonic]

Where the hell did I ever imply the existence of RC being targetted? 0_o
Don't put words in my mouth. All I said is that I was assuming the doc was successful during the night. Aren't you a hysterical little one.

[Kmd4390]

Actually, Dramonic has a point as much as I hate flavor arguements. I have a theory that would explain Ooba's death and probably confirm that Reap is telling the truth and was targeted by scum for a kill. Going into it would be anti-town though. Basically, I have a guess flavorwise and rolewise at who killed Ooba.

[FakeGod]

@Kmd: ummm.....I already guessed out loud that Fenrir killed ooba.....

@dramonic: Well if the doc was successful, who did the doc save?

[Kmd4390]

Fake, I was thinking Lupin. Which I didn't really want to say because now I'm all but telling scum that I'm not Lupin. I could see him as a protown vig. Either way, the kill was probably vig or SK, meaning Reap claiming to have been "weakened" could have been the scum's kill attempt, meaning Reap is more than likely non-mafia.

With Ooba flipping "Death Eater" specifically, there's no way Dumbledore is scum anyway.

[Kmd4390]

Also thinking about Espeon's Patronus claim. If it's a true claim, he's not a Death Eater either. Could be a lyncher with Sudo as a target, but I'd expect him to have been removed from the game if that were the case. Chances are Espeon saw a dementor claim and thought of the idea to fakeclaim patronus.

[FakeGod]

@Kmd: .........oops sorry. Should've kept quiet. May I speculate further or would it be pro-scum to do so?

[Kmd4390]

To do what?

[dramonic]

<_<
>_>

I really should have read the day's post before commenting on the night. I didn't even know RC had been targetted =_=;

[FakeGod]

@Kmd: speculating further about Werewolves role/powers? (because we all know that if you're bitten by a WW, there's a chance that you turn into one.....).

@Dramonic: what? ummm you lost me...

[Kmd4390]

Ooba is dead, so it doesn't matter. The only important thing is that he was likely killed by someone other than scum. Probably SK because what vig in their right mind would have killed Ooba?

[FakeGod]

Right, and I think if SK then Fenrir, and if vig then Lupin.

So we shouldn't rely on this "vig" person/animal because he's probably SK.

[Espeonage]

Vote: MPR

btw Dram is town. That didn't feel like a scum slip to me.