Harry Potter Mafia - Over!

[ooba]

@hasdgfas

- Can we have an exact deadline? Sens has mentioned its three-weeks max on the OP

- Can I get prods on all the inactives? To make life easier for you - those who have not posted in the last 48 hours or so:
Nobody Special
MacavityLock mb53
Seraphim

- Umm; Can we also get possible replacements on Fuzzylighting, IH, Mysterious Mystery Man (Last posts: May 29)?

[Espeonage]

Actually, looking at my role PM. The way the win condition is stated, my role and the Dementor's 'job' (in books) I am liking that role claim being pro town even more.

[ooba]

Actually, looking at my role PM. The way the win condition is stated, my role and the Dementor's 'job' (in books) I am liking that role claim being pro town even more.

So would you like to change your answer to my question?

[Espeonage]

If you had the towns win condition coupled with what the dementors are supposed to do then it would look pro-town to you as well.

Unless Sens was going for a late series veiw of Dementors, as in when they were in Voldemorts power. However I am under the impression that wasn't what is the case here.

We are delving into mod WIFOM so I think that we are at a stalemate on the issue. You either agree or you don't.

[ooba]

Are ye searching for anything?

[Espeonage]

No. I assumed you wanted me to back up what I was trying to say.

[ooba]

Hmm. Posted that before this post of yours came up. I'll wait for the others to answer my questions.

[ReaperCharlie]

Did you ask anyone anything besides Sudo_Nym?

[ooba]

Did you ask anyone anything besides Sudo_Nym?

Kmd, FG.

[SensFan]

Back from V/LA.

Furcolow replaces Mysterious Mystery Man.
I'll extrend the deadline to exactly 3 days from this post, due to the replacement.
Votre Count coming shortly.

[SensFan]

Vote Count

Sudo_Nym - 5 (farside22, Seraphim, rajrhcpfreak, ooba, ReaperCharlie)
ReaperCharlie - 4 (fuzzylightning, Espeonage, MacavityLock, KMD4390)
furcolow - 1 (MehPlusRawr)
Nobody Special - 1 (IH)
Seraphim - 1 (furcolow)
rajrhcpfreak - 1 (Sudo_Nym)

Not Voting - 3 (FakeGod, jmj3000, Nobody Special)

9 to lynch

[Espeonage]

Unvote

It was a long time since that vote and I like both the claims made.

[ReaperCharlie]

Welcome back, SensFan.

[ooba]

Back from V/LA.

Furcolow replaces Mysterious Mystery Man.
I'll extrend the deadline to exactly 3 days from this post, due to the replacement.
Votre Count coming shortly.

With two days gone in the move, can we take it that it's 5 days from your post?

[SensFan]

3 days from this post. (and 4 minutes back, at the top of the hour, for the sake of my sanity).

[SensFan]

For the duration of this game (or until further notice), I will be accepting either of the following:

Code: Select all

[b]Vote: Sens[/b]
[vote]Sens[/vote]

Vote: Sens

VOTE: Sens

[ReaperCharlie]

Esp: Wait, you actually believe Sudo's claim? A dementor would not be a jailkeeper, and even if it's the only thing that fits flavor-wise, I still can't see that as being a pro-town role. When was the last time you watched Prisoner of Azkaban or read Deathly Hallows? Please tell me you know that they are almost exclusively trying to kill good guys and help bad guys throughout the series from Book 3 on.

This thread needs moar Sudo_Nym wagon.

[MacavityLock]

Back from V/LA and catching up. Deadline pushed to Saturday -> Happy ML.

[Espeonage]

Esp: Wait, you actually believe Sudo's claim? A dementor would not be a jailkeeper, and even if it's the only thing that fits flavor-wise, I still can't see that as being a pro-town role. When was the last time you watched Prisoner of Azkaban or read Deathly Hallows? Please tell me you know that they are almost exclusively trying to kill good guys and help bad guys throughout the series from Book 3 on.

This thread needs moar Sudo_Nym wagon.

Umbridge for all intensive purposes is "good" and has command over dementors. That happened Order of the Phoenix so there is a notable exception.

So taking the context of the game it could swing either way.

[ReaperCharlie]

Yeah well Fudge and Scrimgeour are also "good", but were they (or Dolores Umbridge)

actually

good?

.....

[ooba]

Esp: Wait, you actually believe Sudo's claim? A dementor would not be a jailkeeper, and even if it's the only thing that fits flavor-wise, I still can't see that as being a pro-town role. When was the last time you watched Prisoner of Azkaban or read Deathly Hallows? Please tell me you know that they are almost exclusively trying to kill good guys and help bad guys throughout the series from Book 3 on.

This thread needs moar Sudo_Nym wagon.

I can see Umbridge with her detentions always fitting as a JK role. Dementors are not a role I'd put in the "good" category..
But then we have to really think about what good means ..

This game cannot move forward until people come back and
i) Post their thoughts on the claims
ii) Reply to questions

[ooba]

ebwop: always = also

[FakeGod]

Dementor, huh?

Inherently evil, soul-sucking creatures who are quick to join He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named's side?

I don't buy this "pro-town" claim.

Vote: Sudo_Nym

@ooba: what's a JK role?

Guys I don't think we should discuss/speculate on what roles certain characters might be. It gives info to scum.

[ooba]

JK = Jailkeeper. What Sudo claimed.

FakeGod, does AC mean anything to you in this game. Be honest.

[ReaperCharlie]

JK = Jailkeeper. What Sudo claimed.

FakeGod, does AC mean anything to you in this game. Be honest.

lol, what's AC