Newbie 947 (Game over Scum wins!)

[Haylen]

Oh that sucks, i thought I did one already. You WERE leading the town, I didnt say you are now. YES I DO REMEMBER THAT GAME, I GOT A LOAD OF SHIT CAUSE I UNVOTED 24 HOURS BEFORE DEADLINE.

[jmurph3]

@everyone else: Can you please place your vote on someone? I would prefer to see some actual discussion, rather then a deadline scramble for a lynch

Unfortunately, for me, my vote comes down, at the moment, to a policy lynch. No one has posted enough today for me to get a scummy vibe, so I have to base it on lurking, whether actively or inactively. Personally, I don't like to do this. I would much rather vote based on a scum vibe because even if wrong, it can give town something to go off of, whereas saying, "we killed this player because of lurking" typically ends up with town no better than where we started.

Therefore, I am most inclined towards voting Jerbs, Tyrope, or Haylen. Though of the three Haylen has posted the most recently, I do not find her posts relevant or really content-filled, thus not being very helpful to town and potentially as harmful as not posting at all. I'm not sure whether to let Tyrope get replaced for being inactive (which I see as likely to happen at this point) is better, or if we should lynch him before that happens...Jerbs has also not posted much of use recently, and has been offline for a long length of time before that.

Of the three, since those seem the only viable choices to me at the moment, I would probably go with Haylen. She claims real life issues are her problem, and replacing into too many games, but I feel like she still could have contributed more, especially with the way D2 has progressed thus far. For these reasons, and well acknowledging that if (and this is a big if) new information is revealed before the deadline, I will most likely change my vote, I will say:

Vote: Haylen

.

[bemyally]

Because Michel would like me to vote, I will. I don't have ANY evidence to go off of on anyone, so based on my last unhelpful case:

Vote Michel

[Zachrulez]

2nd vote count of day 2:

Haylen - 2 (J.R, Jmurph3)
Tyrope - 1 (MichelSableheart)
MichelSableheart - 1 (bemyally)

Not voting: (Tyrope, Jerbs, Haylen)

With 7 alive it's 4 to lynch

If I made any mistakes, politely point them out as soon as you see them.

DL is June 15th at 3pm CST

[J.R]

I am fully aware that mb voted Haylen and I didn't unvote. For now, the only one I can give a vote is Haylen for the reasons I've stated earlier.

[MichelSableheart]

@mod: you prodded Tyrope last monday. What's the status of that prod?

@mod: also, could you prod Jerbs, please?

@Haylen: if you read that line, and remember that game (where I believe I explained pretty solidly why a No Lynch is a bad idea), then why aren't you voting now?

@jmurph: allthough I can understand where you are coming from regarding day 2 as not giving us any information, I do have to wonder if day 1 influences your decission in any way.

[jmurph3]

@jmurph: allthough I can understand where you are coming from regarding day 2 as not giving us any information, I do have to wonder if day 1 influences your decission in any way.

Hmmm, not really, as least not consciously for me. I mean, my number 1 suspect was, obviously misguided on my part, Wacka. I don't think I had any major suspicions on anyone else, though feel free to correct me if I'm wrong on that. As with D2, there just wasn't that much information brought out on D1. I was suspicious of Haylen from the get-go just because of the way that she came out and laid out all her scum tells/non-scum tells, but I think that's the only relevant thing that happened in regard to this.

@Michel: do you seem to think that D1 is influencing me?

[Zachrulez]

@mod: you prodded Tyrope last monday. What's the status of that prod?

He's failed to post in thread in the allotted time. I will post a notice in the newbie thread requesting a replacement when I get the time later.

[Zachrulez]

Jerbs has been prodded.

[bemyally]

Crap it's Friday and the last time I posted was Tuesday :/
Sorry.. I'm still here though, just nothing to add.

I feel like we're missing people besides Jerbs. Unless there's only 5 of us left?

[Haylen]

@Haylen: if you read that line, and remember that game (where I believe I explained pretty solidly why a No Lynch is a bad idea), then why aren't you voting now?

Ok,

Vote Michel

I dont feel I have more information to go on than I did on Day One Yes, I'm voting you because you still look like you're trying to lead the town >.>

[Jerbs]

sorry i was stuck doing finals

I agree we are missing more people
Happy birthday jmurph3!

Why are we voting Michel? How is trying to lead the town a scumtell?

[bemyally]

Oh, I'm just voting Michel because I have nothing else better to do.
And JR and Jmurph wanted me to name him. You can't exactly name who you suspect without voting him, especially at the stage where absolutely NOTHING is happening. To me, he isn't even that scummy. He's more of a town going into neutral but so far I'm getting town off everyone else. I am always open to reconsidering my vote when and if any new leads come up.

[Zachrulez]

The King of Eggs replaces Tyrope effective immediately.

[The King of Eggs]

Hey there I'm replacing tyrope. I hope we can have a good game

[The King of Eggs]

Well it seems that Mitch is the bandwagon of the day. However I can't see any particular scummyness. So why are we placing him at L-1?

[The King of Eggs]

Hmm not much activity in this game, is there?

[MichelSableheart]

@Michel: do you seem to think that D1 is influencing me?

I was a bit surpised it didn't, actually. Even though you were wrong on your top suspect day 1, I would still guess that you could get information from there.

@TKE: This game isn't very active, no. As far as I can see, I'm currently at L-2 because Bemyally has a gut scumread on me and Haylen feels I have been leading the town on day 1. I haven't got a reply from her yet on my request to show where I did so.

I don't really feel the Haylen bandwagon. I agree that she isn't very active, but if we're going to lynch a player for lurking, Jerbs is probably the better choice. At least Haylen is giving some opinion on the game and giving a reason for her inactivity.

I would like to again draw attention to Xc0m's behaviour early day 1. Both his vote for demongob and his vote for Bemyally felt like he was trying to push the easy bandwagons rather then actually believing them to be scum.

[The King of Eggs]

@TKE: This game isn't very active, no. As far as I can see, I'm currently at L-2 because Bemyally has a gut scumread on me and Haylen feels I have been leading the town on day 1. I haven't got a reply from her yet on my request to show where I did so.

true my mistake. L-2 though means that unless one or more of the people voting for you are scum. Then you are effectivly lynched. And I may be a n00b. But I can see that there isn't nearly enough material for a lynch at this point

[bemyally]

Welcome, King of Eggs!
Yes, imo there is no one worth lynching right now. Michel did say that it's best we get our votes in anyway, hence my vote. Personally if the game were moving a bit faster I would hold my vote off Michel but it seems like we need all we can get. I don't like how all Haylen says is 'Michel is trying to lead town.' Can we have more examples and supporting evidence rather than that statement?

I'm going to say that this is my first game, but do so many people seriously replace in and out of mafiascum games as much as in this one? I'm starting to get confused on who is who.

[The King of Eggs]

Ok I've now finished Reading this thread. As a complete entity. And iso. The only person in this game that seems even slightly sus to me is bemyally

therefore

~Vote: Bemyally~

[MichelSableheart]

May I ask what arouses your suspicion?

[The King of Eggs]

Welcome, I don't like how all Haylen says is 'Michel is trying to lead town.' Can we have more examples and supporting evidence rather than that statement?

now this I must agree with. As for replacing. I know what u mean. It's confusing at the best of times. But I shouldn't complain. If Tyrope hadn't replaced out then I would not be playing .

[The King of Eggs]

It may just be the parraniod in me. But something about the wording of his posts. It doesn't play out right. It's to planned. To edited. But as I said it's very small. In any other game I would ignore it. Call it nerves. [shrugs]. But in a game with nothing else to go on. It seems enough for a simple vote. I am fully open to critic however. Feel free to point out other candidates. Know however I am unconvincable unless I see truth. It's the best part of having extreme parraniod thoughts

[The King of Eggs]

Hmm. A small burst of activity. Then nothing. I am getting the impression that mafiascum is far slow in place than the other places I've played. Come on guys. Don't let the mafia lurk and blend in at the same time due to everyone being inactive!!!