Harry Potter Mafia - Over!

[Sudo_Nym]

Reap, I really don't think FakeGod is scum.

Why not?

@ReaperCharlie:

Maybe it's too early for me, but a quick search of your ISO shows no question directed at me. Just a lot of statements

about

me. Care to make it easy on a tired and overworked man?

Read my 191 about your 181. There might even be other questions, I can't be arsed to look them up right now though, so...

And maybe your 'quick search' was too quick, cause I found that after about 10 seconds of glancing through.

Also: If you're not going to take the time to make a worthwhile post, don't even bother.

Sorry, that you made a backhand comment in the middle of a large post about a variety of people, and I managed to overlook it. And second, you've been hounding me for a long time to answer questions, but never once actually say what question I've managed to not answer, and then bitch that my request for your question is the worthless post. You could have resolved this a lot sooner, but then what do I know?

yes, sudo, I;m still kinda waiting for a reply to my question. this goes for fakegod as well.

@ 181: why are you comparing myself and you, then calling me obvscum, and then NOT voting for me? huh???

first of all, we aren't playing similarly at all. you were trying to rip people a new one for prolonging RVS while I was happily enjoying a prolonged RVS, thanks in part to yours truly.

secondly, please point to what makes me obvscum (without parroting kmd's "he hasn't posted content yet!" argument, like everyone else seems to be doing). can you?

thirdly, even though you're that wrong about me, you seem to be convinced that I'm scum. but you go ahead and don't vote for me... this doesn't sit well with me.

boop... boop.... booopppp.... *points scumdar at sudo* Beepbeepbeepbeepbeep!!!!

And the biggest reason I overlooked it is because I assumed it was pointed at FG, and I don't think I can be blamed for that. You're calling me out for calling you obvscum, and then blasting me for not voting you. Except I never called you obvscum; I don't think I've ever refered to anyone as obvscum in any game I've ever played. I didn't vote you because I wanted to see you under pressure, and you were. If I truly thought you were obvscum, I would have voted for you. I was content with a bandwagon and seeing what shakes loose. Though this has brought me some grief, I stand by it as the correct decision nonetheless.

Anything else, Mr. Charles?

[Kmd4390]

Reap, I really don't think FakeGod is scum.

Why not?

I mentioned this in post 225. I like the points he is making and he comes off as a newbtownie who is beginning to grasp the game. He's asking questions where he needs to and is skeptical at the right times. Nothing reads as scummy in his posts. A little more activity and input might be nice from him, but I don't have any serious issues with Fake.

[MehPlusRawr]

Bah, I need to reread. Sorry for being inactive, guys. <_<

[ReaperCharlie]

I never called you obvscum; I don't think I've ever refered to anyone as obvscum in any game I've ever played.

I guess I misinterpreted this:

Sudo any reason for ignoring RC's comments?

Any particular reason why my comments are necessary?

RC is obvious

, and has been commented on at length already, by a variety of people. He even has a number of votes.

What did you mean by that statement, then?

[ReaperCharlie]

Bah, I need to reread. Sorry for being inactive, guys. <_<

A curse upon you!

*Crucio!*: MPR

[Sudo_Nym]

Sudo any reason for ignoring RC's comments?

Any particular reason why my comments are necessary?

RC is obvious

, and has been commented on at length already, by a variety of people. He even has a number of votes.

What did you mean by that statement, then?[/quote]

I meant that the case about you was obvious, and was being picked up on. You were under some pressure for it, if you'll recall. I never assume that one piece of evidence, however obvious, is enough to call a person scummy, however. That's why the word "scummy" never appears in that post. I wanted to see how you responded to the pressure before I declared one way or the other, and you did okay, so I never voted. Not to say I'm convinced of your innocence, but there you have it.

[jmj3000]

Ok, I have reread, but I want some specific things to comment on, because right now all I have is a jumbled mess of information, and I need something to focus on so I can pick the information out thats pertinant.

[ReaperCharlie]

Any particular reason why my comments are necessary?

RC is obvious

, and has been commented on at length already, by a variety of people. He even has a number of votes.

What did you mean by that statement, then?

I meant that the case about you was obvious, and was being picked up on. You were under some pressure for it, if you'll recall. I never assume that one piece of evidence, however obvious, is enough to call a person scummy, however. That's why the word "scummy" never appears in that post. I wanted to see how you responded to the pressure before I declared one way or the other, and you did okay, so I never voted. Not to say I'm convinced of your innocence, but there you have it.

Oh.

Well, ok...

[FakeGod]

Sorry for the inactivity... -_-

@jmj: how about the miller claim discussion? That's pretty specific and non-RVS...

@RC: You think I'm scum? ehm ok... do you have a case I can respond to or are you just bandwagoning farside? >.>

[ReaperCharlie]

No. I don't follow people. I just think you're playing pretty scummily.

You are adding nothing to the game, posting "I will catch up soon!" every few days, and then coming back just to post "Sorry for the inactivity" and another sentence or two.

Oh, wait.... Case in point!

[Kmd4390]

jmj, how about opinions on other players? Just post something of value. If you go away for the first 11 pages of a game, it's usually not a good idea to just say "Hi, I read the game. Ask me questions."

------------------

Reap, that's not a fair representation of FakeGod's play. 3 of his 13 posts can be represented the way you want to represent his entire game. 2 are fluff and 1 is a jokevote. He has added something to the game in 7 posts (8 if you count the joke vote). That's more than half of his posts which is more than can be said about Jmj, fuzzylightning, and MPR and about the same as Espeonage and Sera. I feel like IH should be included too with a total of 4 posts including none in over a week. rajkdsfjdklsa hasn't given us much either now that I look at him in ISO.

Reap, why do I get the feeling you are just picking on the newbie by going after FakeGod?

[ReaperCharlie]

Um? Your defense of FG is noted, kmd. *narrows eyes*

And, let's see.... maybe I am "picking on the newbie" since he was the one who'd posted right above me with utter crap, right about when I figured it was high time for me to lay a serious vote down. Therefore, I noticed him, ISO'd him, and voted him.

I wasn't satisfied with his play then, and I'm not satisfied with his play now, so my vote stays. If he doesn't prove that he's actually trying to contribute to the game, why should I move my vote?

Yes, others have contributed less, yes (fuzzy, jmj, mpr, raj). I mentioned them a few pages ago in my mass-ISO findings post. But do you expect me to hop votes between all the non-contributors? If you think they're more worth of a vote than FG is, then why aren't you voting for them?

I see you're still voting for me, is that because of your original reasons?

I don't like jmj's first post. Day 1 has started and all he talks about is the theme. Adds nothing to the game. Not even a random vote or confirm or anything. Kind of like Reap's "lmao" post a little later. Then Reap goes on about useless stuff in his next post. If his next few posts don't have real substance, I'll probably vote him in this post with jmj as a close second suspect.

Reap's long post looks like a lame attempt at "content".

Or are you just scum picking on other people's reasons for voting other people, and hoping you're not getting called out for your own vote, which is passé now anyway?

FoS: kmd

[ReaperCharlie]

@ fuzzy/jmj/mpr/raj:

Post, please.

[FakeGod]

You know, I don't mind that you're voting me, but your reasoning didn't make sense to me.

The reason you gave behind your vote was seemingly fine. It's true that I'm neither the most frequent poster or posts longest posts (and therefore, not a great contributor either). However, with your logic, there are other players, as yourself mentioned, who have posted/contributed even less than I did.

And then you said that it doesn't make sense to vote-hop between all the suspicious characters. If that's the case, wouldn't it make sense from your point of view to vote the least frequent/least contributing player in the game? But then, you said yourself that there are others who have contributed less than I did. (?)

I do not see a legitimate reasoning here, other than you are not satisfied with my playing style. :/

[farside22]

kmd: what do you find about raj that says town?

Nothing stands out.

Was just curious if you had a case or not.

He's not scum hunting. He jumps on bw and has said little to nothing at all since the game started. That is why I find Raj scummy.

[farside22]

Sudo any reason for ignoring RC's comments?

Any particular reason why my comments are necessary?

RC is obvious

, and has been commented on at length already, by a variety of people. He even has a number of votes.

What did you mean by that statement, then?

I meant that the case about you was obvious, and was being picked up on. You were under some pressure for it, if you'll recall. I never assume that one piece of evidence, however obvious, is enough to call a person scummy, however. That's why the word "scummy" never appears in that post. I wanted to see how you responded to the pressure before I declared one way or the other, and you did okay, so I never voted. Not to say I'm convinced of your innocence, but there you have it.

This sounds like such bull shit comments to me. I swear why is this guy not having a wagon on him?

[FakeGod]

Anyone know the latest vote count?

@farside: how come everyone thinks you're town? (raises eyebrow)

[Kmd4390]

Reap, what is wrong with defending my biggest town read?

If you honestly ISO'd him, you'd see that he's making real points and asking real questions.

You are twisting "learning the game" to mean "not trying to play". That's not cool.

Yes, I'd vote any one of the lurkers you name before I'd vote Fake. Why am I not voting them? Mac is scummier.

Also, lies. I'm not voting you. I'd be almost as willing to vote you as Mac though. Reasons can be found throughout my post history.

Or are you just scum picking on other people's reasons for voting other people, and hoping you're not getting called out for your own vote, which is passé now anyway?

This makes no sense. If I don't like someone's reasoning, I'm gonna jump on it.

-----------------

See, FakeGod basically sums it up, Reap. If you want to vote him, tell us why he is the worst offender of what it is that makes him scum. If not contributing is the point you are voting based on, yet you admit there are worse offenders, your vote is basically bullshit.

CALLING IT NOW. IF REAP IS SCUM, ONE OF fuzzy/jmj/mpr/rajjkfdaa IS SCUM TOO.

--------------

Farside, k.

[Kmd4390]

Anyone know the latest vote count?

Last vote count came before I replaced in. Page 5 I think?

[ReaperCharlie]

Yeah, mod's been gone a week. wtf?

[ReaperCharlie]

My bad. I thought you were still voting for me. I didn't see that you had unvoted. My apologies (<-- omfg scum slip catch phrase!!)

FG is seriously your biggest town read? Granted, I haven't been around as long as a lot of people, but even I can tell that there are a lot more pro-town people than FG.

I don't see someone of your personality to be a newbie lover. I just think you're trying to buddy up to him.

And yes, Mac is scummy. But I am believing his miller claim for now, which means obviously I don't wanna vote for him.

------------

And I didn't say FG was the worst offender:

And, let's see.... maybe I am "picking on the newbie" since he was the one who'd posted right above me with utter crap, right about when I figured it was high time for me to lay a serious vote down. Therefore, I noticed him, ISO'd him, and voted him.

I said he's the

first one I noticed

when I decided to vote seriously. What's wrong with that?

------------

And please tell me: What connection do you see between me and any one of the people you just listed? At all?

------------

farside: who do you think is more likely to be scum based on their current activity level and past performance: raj or Sudo?

Do you think they are scum together? Why or why not?

[Kmd4390]

A lot of newbies are easier to read than experienced players. FakeGod is one of those players. There is nothing fake (pun intended) about his posts. They are all so genuine and innocent. There is nothing scummy about him.

No, I'm not a newbie lover. Or hater. Everyone has the same odds of being scum as everyone else. Experience has nothing to do with that.

If Mac is scummy, why does the fact that he claimed miller excuse his play?

And I didn't say FG was the worst offender:

EXACTLY. And yet you are voting him. And the point you have against him is one that there are worse offenders for.

---------------

The "connection" is that you call them worse offenders of what you are voting someone else for.

[Kmd4390]

Unvote, Vote Reap

Was leaning Mac for a little while, but I just can't see these posts coming from town.

[MacavityLock]

I meant that the case about you was obvious, and was being picked up on. You were under some pressure for it, if you'll recall. I never assume that one piece of evidence, however obvious, is enough to call a person scummy, however. That's why the word "scummy" never appears in that post. I wanted to see how you responded to the pressure before I declared one way or the other, and you did okay, so I never voted. Not to say I'm convinced of your innocence, but there you have it.

This sounds like such bull shit comments to me. I swear why is this guy not having a wagon on him?

This is the first time that the sudo case grabbed me. These are weasel words from sudo.

Yes, I'd vote any one of the lurkers you name before I'd vote Fake. Why am I not voting them? Mac is scummier.

Unless I'm missing something, your case on me thus far is "He claimed Miller, made sure people knew he was a Miller, and wants to die." How is that a case? (Yes, I know you've moved your vote off of me.)

Lots of people need to stop lurking.

[farside22]

Anyone know the latest vote count?

@farside: how come everyone thinks you're town? (raises eyebrow)

Most people have played with me before and know my meta. You want links?