NY 114: Mafia vs. Werewolves (Game Over)

[LimMePls]

SSBF: You are misrepping Faraday I think. Go back and look, he votes SGR before nhammen says he targetted SGR. Faraday then makes a post congratulating himself for voting correctly.

This is one of the reasons I find nhammen scummy. He claims to have RB'd one of the people getting suspicion early in D2 before he announces who he RB'd. Seemed really convenient.

[nhammen]

Then when nhammen said he role blocked SGRaaize, Faraday deciding to move his vote to SGRaaize, which is him basically bandwagoning.

WRONG! Faraday was already voting SGR, when I had claimed. If you ISOed him, you should have seen this.

This is one of the reasons I find nhammen scummy. He claims to have RB'd one of the people getting suspicion early in D2 before he announces who he RB'd. Seemed really convenient.

Didn't he have 1 vote on him at the time? I don't think 1 vote makes a wagon. Also, why would I go after a "convenient" target? I have already explained my reason for my choice. If you want to say this is scummy, you have to show why.

[Parama]

Bwahah keep up the misrep SSBF. I'm lovin' it, only makes you more obvious.

[Timeater]

Actually Leaf, I've considered you scummy since like page 6.

My request is pretty simple, I don't see the harm in posting their top three suspects. Why the resistance? Why so scared? Just do it.

For those who haven't yet, please post your top three suspects.

[vezopiraka]

1st: Foilist13
2nd: SSBF
3rd: nhammen

[Nachomamma8]

Hello, reading up now. I'll be done by Sunday or so, hopefully.

[MichelSableheart]

Askbob's last post was made more then 48 hours ago, so he will be prodded.

Everybody else either posted in the last 48 hours, announced Limited Access, replaced in within the last 48 hours, or is in the process of being replaced.

[Timeater]

V/LA till monday

[Dr. Robotnik]

Sorry guys, couldn't post yesterday. Out of the past few pages of argueing, I'm not seeing a person who really comes across as "scummyist"

[LimMePls]

Sorry guys, couldn't post yesterday. Out of the past few pages of argueing, I'm not seeing a person who really comes across as "scummyist"

So what you are saying is you're pretty much worthless? Can you even be bothered to reply to Timeater's "top 3 suspects" question? It would literally take a three line post.

[Leafsnail]

Actually Leaf, I've considered you scummy since like page 6.

My request is pretty simple, I don't see the harm in posting their top three suspects. Why the resistance? Why so scared? Just do it.

For those who haven't yet, please post your top three suspects.

I did post my top 3 suspects... which you'd know if you actually read my posts.

You said something about me in ISO post 10, but you seemed to accept my answer in ISO post 11 (yeah, it was just a misunderstanding on my behalf). You then say nothing about me until post 35, but this doesn't seem particularly aggressive. Perhaps 36 was, but you don't actually accuse me... then you ignore me apart from one question until post 43, where you vote me. So no, I don't accept that you've considered me scummy since page 6.

[Midnight's Sorrow]

@midnight, you have been trashing other players' cases. Can you provide a game in which you have been doing this as Town?

You'll always see me attack peoples cases. For that is what gets people lynched at the end of the day. But that game and the one I finished when I first came here are the only games I have completed.

I personally hate meta, but if that is what you need then here ya go:

Newbie 936

[Nikanor]

Oh hey, that game looks familiar.

Hi everyone. I'm reading up now, but don't expect me to be done today. Or even tomorrow.

[Pomegranate]

Wgere

is

Sevis? According to his iso, he hasn't posted since the 25th of May. Huh?

[foilist13]

He's getting replaced Pom.

I don't see any questions directed at me, but if I missed you please tell me.

Top 3 Suspects

1) Parama
2) Leafsnail
3) The lurkers.[/b]

[Nikanor]

What the heck. This IS a Large game, right? Why is this game 12th on my watched topics list? YOU KNOW YOU CAN TALK WHEN I'M CATCHING UP, RIGHT?

[foilist13]

Why do you think there have been so many replacements? Everyone is either V/LA, lurking, or catching up.

[Socrates]

Oh god I'm getting flashbacks

8 months ago, but damn if I can't draw some parallels. I'm getting cold feet on this Foilist wagon.

HOLD ME PARAMA, WHISPER SWEET REASURING WORDS AND TELL ME THAT WHAT I AM DOING IS RIGHT.

Top three scum suspects:

1. Foilist (for now)
2. Nhammen
3. You/Serial

I need to review what LMP is saying about MS and some other things.

What the heck. This IS a Large game, right? Why is this game 12th on my watched topics list? YOU KNOW YOU CAN TALK WHEN I'M CATCHING UP, RIGHT?

Do what I do and don't read day 1. It's the strategy of champions!

[Nikanor]

Socrates, your post just seems like a bunch of WIFOM and OMGUS.

HOLD ME PARAMA, WHISPER SWEET REASURING WORDS AND TELL ME THAT WHAT I AM DOING IS RIGHT.

This looks like misrep. That's not what Parama is doing.
And before you say it, yes. I am doing ad homonym on "whisper sweet reassuring words" and "tell me that what I am doing is right" (ad homonym actually means "attacking same name" in latin, in case you didn't know.)

1. Foilist (for now)
2. Nhammen

So if foilist gets lynched you're happy to lynch nhammen? That's just blatently lining up your lynches.

3. You/Serial

Obviously a false dichotomy.

Do what I do and don't read day 1. It's the strategy of champions!

Clearly an opportunistic way to get me to not read the thread.

Now I'm going to sit back and watch as you get all overdefensive. (Yes, I was bored. Day one is boring so far).

[Socrates]

I laughed pretty hard.

And yes, I know about the typo, I don't remember why I didn't fix it but there IS a reason!

[Socrates]

@Socrates Start with post 896 and read the next few pages. Note that we had considerable discussion about Sevis on D1 and not once did MS ever even hint that he thought Sevis might be scummy. Then, after Vi NK he immediately leaps on Sevis. When I point this out, rather than offer any sort of credible defense, he instead tries to make the issue about me "dropping" Sevis. His attack on Sevis was weaksauce. Add 951, where he claims the whole wagon on him is only bandwagoning, adding yet another complete misrepresentation to his already considerable list of them.

For that matter, just ISO MS. The whole thing is scummy.

Ehhhh... It reminds me of SPS on day 2 of L4D mafia, which just finished today. For the record, Amished WAS scum.

I'll obviously need to look at MS more closely and I haven't reviewed his day 1 play yet, but I am curious to see how you feel about the link I provided.

[Nikanor]

Starting with this post, Vi votes for LMP, then vez quickly follows up with a vote of LMP. He goes from voting

for

someone to voting

with

someone. And if he had some sort of secret magical information that LMP is mafia, why was he not voting on that before?
Whoo multiple-use day role cop!

Edit after looking at Seraphim's claim: Or not....
Edit after looking at Seraphim's edited claim: Or so!

I am too confused. And you are too scummy.

Vote; daniel94581.

Pom confused! Pom smash with brick!

That's really all that catches my eye for now. And I'm going to leave off at lucky page number 13.

[MichelSableheart]

Eighth vote count of day 2.

animorpherv1 (0):
askbob (2):

Super Smash Bros. Fan, nhammen

Dr. Robotnik (0):
Dry-fit (0):
Faraday (0):
foilist13 (4):

Parama, Socrates, Leafsnail, vezopiraka

Leafsnail (1):

Timeater

Lowell (0):
LynchMePls (0):
Midnight's Sorrow (0):
Nachomamma8 (0):
nhammen (3):

SerialClergyman, Dry-fit, LynchMePls

Nikanor (0):
Parama (2):

Unsight, foilist13

Pomegranate (0):
SerialClergyman (0):
Sevis (2):

Midnight's Sorrow, Pomegranate

Socrates (4):

Faraday, askbob, animorpherv1, Lowell

Super Smash Bros. Fan (0):
Timeater (1):

Dr. Robotnik

Unsight (0):
vezopiraka (0):

Not Voting (3):

Sevis, Nikanor, Nachomamma8

With 22 players alive, it takes 12 votes to lynch someone.

---

Still looking for replacements for Sevis and animorpherv.

Faraday has announced limited access.

Timeater has announced limited access till monday.

Everyone else posted within the last 48 hours.

[Leafsnail]

Wow, great stuff.

Noone comment on foilist's scumlist before timeater does.

[Parama]

Top 3 Suspects

1) Parama
2) Leafsnail
3) The lurkers.

Are you some kinda scummy idiot?
Top 2 scumlist: The two people pushing a foilist case
Then you're too lazy to even come up with a third. *headdesk*

1. Foilist (for now)
2. Nhammen

So if foilist gets lynched you're happy to lynch nhammen? That's just blatently lining up your lynches.

Nikanor-fail alert!
We're all posting our top 3 scumspects. It's not a request, it's an order. But obviously you don't mind reaching for reasons even before reading the thread. <____<

SORRY LEAFSNAIL I COMMENTED ON FOILIST'S LIST WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO ABOUT IT?