Mini 963: Furry Mafia (Game over!)

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE COUNT

DocPotter (1): Espeonage
FakeGod (2): Fugitive, InflatablePie
Not voting (6): Brandi, DocPotter, FakeGod, Fate, NavyCherub, Parama

With

9

players alive, it takes

5

players to lynch.

[FakeGod]

Yay! Roleblocker down!

This game is my favorite out of the three games I'm in right now.

<3

I will now examine how we voted in the end and compare it to the night's results.

[NavyCherub]

Guys, Pie is scum. I'll tell you why in a little bit, but I thought it would be good to post this so you know I'm here.

[Fugitive]

Yay! Roleblocker down!

This game is my favorite out of the three games I'm in right now.

<3

I will now examine how we voted in the end and compare it to the night's results.

Good luck, Zang posted, what? Like 15 times total...

Guys, Pie is scum. I'll tell you why in a little bit, but I thought it would be good to post this so you know I'm here.

Interesting. I'm getting a neutral read on Pie so I'm eager for your evidence.

[FakeGod]

At the end of the day 1.

Antiximo (1): Fugitive
broomhead (7): Parama, Fate, Brandi, NavyCherub, InflatablePie, FakeGod, Espeonage
Espeonage (2): DocPotter, broomhead
Not voting (2): Zang, Antiximo

and on this chart, we are now aware of some of the roles. I'm going to try to reason out what happened.

[InflatablePie]

>I say Navy's a good lynch
>Navy calls me scum

Interesting.

[Brandi]

To be honest I did not expect Anti to be helpful at all this game, and what do you know, he was more than helpful. Good job Antiximo <3

As for Esp claiming to have protected Zang... I suppose that could be legit.
Zang RoleBlocks Esp...
Esp Protects Zang...
Esp's protect fails and he doesn't die because he was roleblocked.
Anti explodes Zang.

There is also the chance that Esp is lying scum and didn't protect anyone- Zang popping up as a roleblocker seems a bit convenient.

Though now that the mafia RB'er is dead, Esp can't be blocked again so either tomorrow he will turn up dead or with an innocent to throw at us.

At this point I'm not sure who is scum. I'll have to read through again shortly.

[Antiximo]

you think i trolled this thread for no reason brandi? lol

anyways go town

[NavyCherub]

What if Espeon was driven or something? I'm not sure if that's how driving works, but I hope you guys get what I mean.

That Pie thing is coming...sooooooon.

[FakeGod]

At the end of the day 1.

Antiximo

(1): Fugitive

broomhead

(7): Parama, Fate, Brandi, NavyCherub, InflatablePie, FakeGod, Espeonage
Espeonage (2): DocPotter,

broomhead

Not voting (2):

Zang

,

Antiximo

Colored it in to make it easier to interpret.
Blue is town, red is mafia, and green is bomb.

[Brandi]

you think i trolled this thread for no reason brandi? lol

anyways go town

Sure.


There are two ways to interpret the vote count, one is assuming Esp is scum, and the other is assuming Esp is town.

We know for a fact that at least one scum was NOT on the broomhead wagon... probably as a means to keep suspicion off when broomhead flipped town.


Of the people not on the broomhead lynch... the likeliness that there wasn't scum on the wagon at all is very very little. BUT If I had to choose one likely scum out of Fugitive and DocPotter, I'd say Doc.

Fugitive does make me a bit uneasy, especially with how much he protested the broomhead lynch. Broomhead may have flipped town, but he was scummy as hell, and Fugi's "town read" on him didn't make much sense. It's almost like he opposed the lynch solely because he knew for a fact broomhead was town rather than actually having evidence to support such.

Even still Docpotter has contributed little to....nothing this whole game, and seems to have a scum motive for the things that he does "contribute." It's mostly a gut feeling, though there are some reasonings as to why I feel he is scummy as well.


ISO'ing Doc... He has made a total of 14 posts all game. 12 posts total D1. Excluding broomhead, who can no longer post today... that is the least amount of posts than anyone else has made all game. That in itself is not a scumtell, no- but my point is lack of contribution which is not helpful to the town.

As for his D2 post...

Espe, why target Zang?

I don't like this question- it seems like something that would be more helpful to scum than town. If esp explained why he protected Zang(Who just so happens to have been scum) last night... that could help scum to figure out who he is going to protect tomorrow.

If it is somehow more beneficial to town than scum to know what the Doc Target is going to be then by all means explain...


Anyhoo- still no vote for now. I'm interested in hearing this Pie case as Pie has come off fairly town to me all game- though I have yet to re-read every player just yet.

also @Cherub, I don't know what you mean by "driven."

[Parama]

Vote count is pretty unhelpful tbh. Only 2 people not on the broom wagon are still alive.

Espe, why target Zang?

I don't like this question- it seems like something that would be more helpful to scum than town. If esp explained why he protected Zang(Who just so happens to have been scum) last night... that could help scum to figure out who he is going to protect tomorrow.

To be fair I asked this same question and giving reasons for a doc protect is generally a good idea.

also @Cherub, I don't know what you mean by "driven."

Mafia busdriver I'm assuming, but I don't like this suggestion at all. What's the point of arguing against the roleblocker theory? Seems like an attempt to confuse the town.

Anyways, on the votes on the broom wagon, Nvay's stands out as being 100% bandwagon, and I don't like the way FakeGod voted and then 2 posts later commented on how he liked my case. Seems like scum forgetting to give reasons in their vote post so they have to quickly make them up later.
Still going to withhold my vote for now but I think a FakeGod lynch is probably the bets today... hell, he's not that close to a lynch anyways, might as well

vote: FakeGod

.

[FakeGod]

Vote count is pretty unhelpful tbh. Only 2 people not on the broom wagon are still alive.

Yeah, I also realized that Zang and Anti both didn't vote. Not much info there.
But I agree with Brandi, I think it's fairly safe to assume that there's at least one scum on the Broom wagon.

[FakeGod]

Because of Parama's insistence on keeping his position as the first one on the wagon, I believe he is town.
However, I will refrain from making cases/speculations against other players in the wagon until I've heard Navy's story.

[DocPotter]

You know FakeGod, those last few posts of yours are attrocious. Posting nothing posts, followed by a nothing post and a scummy assumption.

Odds are extreemly good that any surviving scum was on the Broom wagon, which makes me really suspicious of you. In fact I think it's safe to assume that all remaining scum were on that wagon.

Scummy posts, scum tells.
Looks like I was wrong on you D1

Vote FakeGod

[Fate]

broomhead (7): Parama, Fate, Brandi, NavyCherub, InflatablePie, FakeGod, Espeonage

Meh. I'm waiting, Navy.

Vote: Inflatable Pie

Leave that there for now.

I'm still pretty sure about FakeGod.

I think one of the remaining two scum are voting him right now

FoS: Peeps

[Parama]

Odds are extreemly good that any surviving scum was on the Broom wagon, which makes me really suspicious of you. In fact I think it's safe to assume that all remaining scum were on that wagon.

So you're going to say that Fugi is almost certainly town?
Also, we're lynching way too fast. SLOW DOWN PEOPLE. We have as much time as we need, there's no reason to quicklynch.

[Fate]

Which is why FakeGod is town, don't you see it nub?

[Parama]

Oh.
OOOOOOOOH.

unvote

I probably should've unvoted as soon as Doc put him at L-1 anyways.

[Espeonage]

Unvote, Vote: Navy Cherub

[Parama]

Mmk so I'm going to vote between Fugi and Nvay, not sure which I want to choose for the better lynch yet, probably need to reread.

FoS: Fugitive, NvayCherub

until I decide who's more likely scum.

[InflatablePie]

Which is why FakeGod is town, don't you see it nub?

I feel like I'm missing something major here. Explain?

[Fugitive]

Unvote

[Fate]

This game is below some of my others that are in night?

Lolwut?

Come out come out Navy...

[Parama]

Mmk quick comparison to decide on my vote.

Fugitive: Has been tunneling on FakeGod pretty much all game (which seems like something I would do <_<). Sets up a scumlink between FakeGod and Pie early on. He has a good case against FG and not as much on Pie, so the vote make sense. Some weird plan - "intentionally acting scummy" - which may be the worst excuse I've ever heard. Seems very reluctant to vote Espe, and jumps off as soon as he claims. Nothing but opposition to the Broom lynch though this is null more than scummy. Never really explains his Anti vote though I will admit Anti did a pretty stupid thing at the end of D1. Back to tunneling FG D2, though recent unvote has no explanation or visible motive.

Nvay: Starts by saying that he has no doubts that FG is scum... um, that's a little too strong of terminology for a FIRST POST. But then his following posts back up his suspicions with good reasons and put valid pressure on FG. Lots of stuff here, but also doesn't do much scumhunting besides FG-related posts. Slips under the radar once pressure turns to Espe - earlier had made a buddyesque comment on Espe's play. When broom wagon forms, doesn't even seem to care about the reasons, just wants to make sure he isn't hammering before his bandwagon vote. Eagerly awaiting the reasoning on Pie btw. What happened to FG since D1? You haven't mentioned him in a while.

Fugi read... starts off townish but gets iffy later on, the more recent posts look pretty bad IMO.
Nvay starts off looking really town, disappears for a while, comes back looking super-scummy.

I like both Fugi's and Nvay's early points on FG but now that it has been made clear that FakeGod is likely town there's less to be taken from. Going off more recent posts of the two, I'm going to

vote: NvayCherub

because his recent posts are scummier than Fugi's (Fugi still needs to explain why he so quickly jumped off the FG wagon after a day's worth of tunneling though).