Just because I have removed my vote doesn't mean I think he isn't scum, im going to see how his replacement handles things and then decide if I should vote for him. I also have a few minor suspicouns but nothing really voteworthy at the moment.Magna wrote:Now that easjo is being replaced you have removed your vote. Do you have any suspicions at this point or are you just content to hang out?
First of all, he did vote me. With his only reason being that:TheSkeward wrote:I appreciate his support and I'm glad we appear to be thinking along the same wavelengths (I've gotten that feeling since the game began). At the same time, I'm unsure of his alignment and don't trust him more than anyone else (besides those I think are scum, namely CMAR and NS).SpyreX wrote:Maybe the new blood will interject some life. That'd be nice.
I'm now fairly confident that Darox and TheSkeward aren't scum together though - that whole "SpyreX, this is obviously what he meant." and then TS coming in and saying he was wrong sure doesn't click for a scum team.
TS: Thoughts on Darox answering for you?
Unvote; Vote: CryMeARiver
Yeah, yeah, flipflopping, votehopping, wagonstopping. The reasons for this are twofold.
1) Nobody Special actually wasn't voting CMAR. Part of the reason I find NS scum is his opportunism, but discovering that it goes as far as comments and not as far as votes makes him less scummy.
2) CMAR and I had an exchange after I convinced Darox to switch over, where he went from hostile to buddyish, as I made a couple of jokes (posted his avatar, and commented that he was missing my animal magnetism). Since then, he's stopped attacking me. Although I won't claim that judging his reaction was all part of my master plan, the way he changed behavior so quickly definitely rang my bells. It could be town gratitude, but I'm not convinced.
Neither of these on their own would get me to switch back, but both together will. Note that I'm still fine with a NS lynch.
No where else does he show that he suspects me. It's a clear bandwagon, followed by:Nobody Special wrote:Yes, CMAR, I suspect you are total scum. Hence, my vote.
Seriously?...I do agree, though, that CMAR is just being VI.
Another bandwagon vote with no reasoning. Most of the wagon on me is ridiculous bandwagoning because people want a quicklynch, as seen here:Skeward wrote:Unvote; Vote: CryMeARiver
I still think Nobody Special is scummier, but CMAR is a good lynch as well.
I'm already dead to him.Skeward wrote:CMAR: I would like your final reads, please. Tell us who you think is town and who you think is scum. Reasoning is optional and appreciated.
Skeward wrote:Unvote; Vote: Nobody Special
Skeward wrote:Hey Spry. Switch to NS please?
But no, now he must vote me because he just wants to get a townie lynched quick hence his waffling. Seriously, ISO the guy, half of his posts are filler. The one that made me crack up:Skeward wrote:Hey cruelty. CMAR lynch isn't happening today. NS is where it's at. Switch?
You should seriously start evaluating your cases on me. I still don't see anything.Skeward wrote:testing, 1, 2, 3.
Conclusions:Page 1
Skeward #11 - Seems like a town-tell to me.
Page 2
Magna #50 - I don't see the logic behind this.
Page 3
Scummy Josh play but he's already dead soo...
Page 4
CMAR #79 - Soft claim request at pg 4. Do not like.
Spyrex #88 - Argh, Lame excuse + WIFOM extravaganza. Not really a tell, but it's anti town.
Skeward #90 - is awesome. Moar town points.
Page 5
Slaine #100 - Hesitation to move vote to scum. Added bonus is he's voting for Spyrex obvscumwagon .
Slaine #110 - This seems all sorts of forced. What kind of silly question is that?
Darox #117 & #121 - What the hell is this? If anything this looks like a ruse. A weird one that doesn't make sense.
Page 6
Spyrex #139 - Good posting.
Ooba #148 - Massclaim attempt? Not sure. Fishy though.
Page 7
Zang #167 - Defending previously unconfirmed scum now are we?
Magna #172 - Wait, what? Why would you point out a possible breadcrumb attempt?
Page 8
Slaine #176 - Still refusing to take a stance.
Darox #180 & #193 - Could possibly be a soft defense for Josh. Not sure though.
Page 9
ooba #200 - Has a town scent, but I don't see why scum won't do this too though.
Yos #217 - votes Slaine who is my top scum read currently.
ooba #218 - The SpyreX FOS could be misled townie, or scum defending Josh. Not sure. Without the knowledge that Josh was scum, I see some town doing this. However, I definitely don't think scum would be this brave to openly defend a scum partner. That's WIFOM though. I like the vote though. Slight town.
Zang #220 - Lame. Although the subsequent Josh interaction gives him some town points. cruelty is right about his VIness though.
Page 10
Darox #227 - Nice try scum.
Slaine #229 - Fence sitting.
Page 11
Spyrex #263 & #271 - Awesome posts. I heart SpyreX already.
Page 12
Darox #290 - More of the same Josh defense. Actually, I don't think scum would openly defend a scummy player like this. Josh keeps digging his own grave. If anything, All the points made by SpyreX are good. I'm thinking there would be a bus somewhere here.
Page 13
ooba #304 - Hmm...Scum would be more willing to do a bus at this point IMO. Plus he's FoSing obvtown SpyreX and scum Josh. Looks like misled townie. But not sure.
Yos #302 - Yos death due to ooba speculation.
SpyreX #315 - I don't get why suspecting both sides is scummy.
NS #320 - Is all kinds of forced. Trying to fit in, reliving the useless scum innkeeper ruse ie. let's go back to talking about useless things and wasting time!, Very skeptical of Josh but no vote ie awkward bus tension, flings some dirt on obvtown who's pushing scum, 'more tonight' comment ie: 'Let town cook on the bullshit info I'm spreading'. I regret that we have but one lynch a day.
Page 14
NS #336 - Glad we're done with the awkward pre-bus tension. Also, still at page 7 an
Zang #338 and #349 - Wow. uh. First time I've seen self-hammering without self-hammering. The timing is incredibly weird. There is a lot of time before Zang's fake/wrong L-1 (1:38am here...but I'm at a diff timezone) and Josh' self hammer (12:17pm). Then Zang hammers at 9:57pm. Doesn't seem like an attempt to secure a bus but that's what they want me to think..I think... Hmm... This is an awesome bus if it is one though.
Page 15
Oh fuck me. I did not know what a traitor was until I saw the official lynch. Josh's traitor flip just did to my reads what my ex-girlfriend did to my heart. Broke it into itsy bitsy pieces and left me empty. God fucking damnit. Now this reread just lost half of it's worth in the scumhunt arena. Excuse me while I smash my head against the wall.
CMAR #356 -Suspecting my top scum read. Not sure what I think atm.
Skeward #361 - I almost forgot this guy was in the game.
NS #368 - obvious scum post looking for an easy lynch.
Page 16
ooba #382 - Good catch. Scum points for CMAR
Darox #398 - Good catch. More of the above
Page 17
CMAR #410 - That doesn't really count if Josh was the traitor as explained in the wiki.
ooba #422 - is awesome and town.
Skeward #423 - Argh. What the fuck. Flip flop with no explanation? Terrible play. Although the fact that he finds my top scum read scummy is good.
Page 18
CMAR #435 - Flailing scum.
CMAR #449 - ............I HATE YOU(not personally). Why oh why did you have to mention my entire case on my scum read before I had the chance to post it. Arghhhhhh. I now think you are town and you've screwed up my reads...AGAIN. Just like my second ex-girlfriend. I hope and pray that my third ex-girlfriend does not show up in this game. Ugh. Anyway, this means that only one of them is scum.
Page 19
Darox #450 - Do not like. It's a pretty impressive case actually. Although Darox has been thickheaded throughout the game anyway so I'm not sure what I think of this.
Skeward #458 - He seems to have reached the same conclusion I have. Not really a tell, but I really liked his early vote on Josh + the first post I mentioned in this reread.
SpyreX #469 - Well, this is not awesome. I hate fluctuating reads. Why are you being hardheaded on a weak 'Josh didn't mention CMAR' case over CMAR's awesome #449?
Page 20
NS #491 - Right, call the guy who made a pretty awesome case against you a VI.
Spyrex - Your NS defense is duly noted. We know who to go after once he flips.
Call me Vas, ;D A little less active than I used to be due to IRL. Hoping to be back up to speed soon-ish!
Not sure if you realized this, but Josh was Isolated Traitor - scum probably didn't even know about him. It's hard to get scum reads based off of connections thru him.VasudeVa wrote:OMGFG ULTRA REREAD MEGAPOSTConclusions:Page 1
Skeward #11 - Seems like a town-tell to me.
Page 2
Magna #50 - I don't see the logic behind this.
Page 3
Scummy Josh play but he's already dead soo...
Page 4
CMAR #79 - Soft claim request at pg 4. Do not like.
Spyrex #88 - Argh, Lame excuse + WIFOM extravaganza. Not really a tell, but it's anti town.
Skeward #90 - is awesome. Moar town points.
Page 5
Slaine #100 - Hesitation to move vote to scum. Added bonus is he's voting for Spyrex obvscumwagon .
Slaine #110 - This seems all sorts of forced. What kind of silly question is that?
Darox #117 & #121 - What the hell is this? If anything this looks like a ruse. A weird one that doesn't make sense.
Page 6
Spyrex #139 - Good posting.
Ooba #148 - Massclaim attempt? Not sure. Fishy though.
Page 7
Zang #167 - Defending previously unconfirmed scum now are we?
Magna #172 - Wait, what? Why would you point out a possible breadcrumb attempt?
Page 8
Slaine #176 - Still refusing to take a stance.
Darox #180 & #193 - Could possibly be a soft defense for Josh. Not sure though.
Page 9
ooba #200 - Has a town scent, but I don't see why scum won't do this too though.
Yos #217 - votes Slaine who is my top scum read currently.
ooba #218 - The SpyreX FOS could be misled townie, or scum defending Josh. Not sure. Without the knowledge that Josh was scum, I see some town doing this. However, I definitely don't think scum would be this brave to openly defend a scum partner. That's WIFOM though. I like the vote though. Slight town.
Zang #220 - Lame. Although the subsequent Josh interaction gives him some town points. cruelty is right about his VIness though.
Page 10
Darox #227 - Nice try scum.
Slaine #229 - Fence sitting.
Page 11
Spyrex #263 & #271 - Awesome posts. I heart SpyreX already.
Page 12
Darox #290 - More of the same Josh defense. Actually, I don't think scum would openly defend a scummy player like this. Josh keeps digging his own grave. If anything, All the points made by SpyreX are good. I'm thinking there would be a bus somewhere here.
Page 13
ooba #304 - Hmm...Scum would be more willing to do a bus at this point IMO. Plus he's FoSing obvtown SpyreX and scum Josh. Looks like misled townie. But not sure.
Yos #302 - Yos death due to ooba speculation.
SpyreX #315 - I don't get why suspecting both sides is scummy.
NS #320 - Is all kinds of forced. Trying to fit in, reliving the useless scum innkeeper ruse ie. let's go back to talking about useless things and wasting time!, Very skeptical of Josh but no vote ie awkward bus tension, flings some dirt on obvtown who's pushing scum, 'more tonight' comment ie: 'Let town cook on the bullshit info I'm spreading'. I regret that we have but one lynch a day.
Page 14
NS #336 - Glad we're done with the awkward pre-bus tension. Also, still at page 7 an
Zang #338 and #349 - Wow. uh. First time I've seen self-hammering without self-hammering. The timing is incredibly weird. There is a lot of time before Zang's fake/wrong L-1 (1:38am here...but I'm at a diff timezone) and Josh' self hammer (12:17pm). Then Zang hammers at 9:57pm. Doesn't seem like an attempt to secure a bus but that's what they want me to think..I think... Hmm... This is an awesome bus if it is one though.
Page 15
Oh fuck me. I did not know what a traitor was until I saw the official lynch. Josh's traitor flip just did to my reads what my ex-girlfriend did to my heart. Broke it into itsy bitsy pieces and left me empty. God fucking damnit. Now this reread just lost half of it's worth in the scumhunt arena. Excuse me while I smash my head against the wall.
CMAR #356 -Suspecting my top scum read. Not sure what I think atm.
Skeward #361 - I almost forgot this guy was in the game.
NS #368 - obvious scum post looking for an easy lynch.
Page 16
ooba #382 - Good catch. Scum points for CMAR
Darox #398 - Good catch. More of the above
Page 17
CMAR #410 - That doesn't really count if Josh was the traitor as explained in the wiki.
ooba #422 - is awesome and town.
Skeward #423 - Argh. What the fuck. Flip flop with no explanation? Terrible play. Although the fact that he finds my top scum read scummy is good.
Page 18
CMAR #435 - Flailing scum.
CMAR #449 - ............I HATE YOU(not personally). Why oh why did you have to mention my entire case on my scum read before I had the chance to post it. Arghhhhhh. I now think you are town and you've screwed up my reads...AGAIN. Just like my second ex-girlfriend. I hope and pray that my third ex-girlfriend does not show up in this game. Ugh. Anyway, this means that only one of them is scum.
Page 19
Darox #450 - Do not like. It's a pretty impressive case actually. Although Darox has been thickheaded throughout the game anyway so I'm not sure what I think of this.
Skeward #458 - He seems to have reached the same conclusion I have. Not really a tell, but I really liked his early vote on Josh + the first post I mentioned in this reread.
SpyreX #469 - Well, this is not awesome. I hate fluctuating reads. Why are you being hardheaded on a weak 'Josh didn't mention CMAR' case over CMAR's awesome #449?
Page 20
NS #491 - Right, call the guy who made a pretty awesome case against you a VI.
Spyrex - Your NS defense is duly noted. We know who to go after once he flips.
One of NS/CMAR is scum.
NS Scum seems to lead to Spyrex and/or Darox scum. If CMAR is scum...I'm not sure yet.
Ooba is town
Skeward is probtown
Zang is null
cruelty is null
Magna is null
I personally want the NS lynch today because there are some major connections between him and Spyrex/Darox. CMAR doesn't seem to have much connections and the communal hate on him seem to indicate that his wagon is a scumwagon. Although his overall scumminess throughout the game does not save him from my lynch list.
I seem to have replaced into a extreme lurker spot. If my town reads ever found my predecessor's lurkiness malicious, feel free to ask. I think I can explain why she lurked like a mofo but I don't think I should yet.
Well, looks like you did realize itCryMeARiver wrote:Not sure if you realized this, but Josh was Isolated Traitor - scum probably didn't even know about him. It's hard to get scum reads based off of connections thru him.VasudeVa wrote:OMGFG ULTRA REREAD MEGAPOSTConclusions:Page 1
Skeward #11 - Seems like a town-tell to me.
Page 2
Magna #50 - I don't see the logic behind this.
Page 3
Scummy Josh play but he's already dead soo...
Page 4
CMAR #79 - Soft claim request at pg 4. Do not like.
Spyrex #88 - Argh, Lame excuse + WIFOM extravaganza. Not really a tell, but it's anti town.
Skeward #90 - is awesome. Moar town points.
Page 5
Slaine #100 - Hesitation to move vote to scum. Added bonus is he's voting for Spyrex obvscumwagon .
Slaine #110 - This seems all sorts of forced. What kind of silly question is that?
Darox #117 & #121 - What the hell is this? If anything this looks like a ruse. A weird one that doesn't make sense.
Page 6
Spyrex #139 - Good posting.
Ooba #148 - Massclaim attempt? Not sure. Fishy though.
Page 7
Zang #167 - Defending previously unconfirmed scum now are we?
Magna #172 - Wait, what? Why would you point out a possible breadcrumb attempt?
Page 8
Slaine #176 - Still refusing to take a stance.
Darox #180 & #193 - Could possibly be a soft defense for Josh. Not sure though.
Page 9
ooba #200 - Has a town scent, but I don't see why scum won't do this too though.
Yos #217 - votes Slaine who is my top scum read currently.
ooba #218 - The SpyreX FOS could be misled townie, or scum defending Josh. Not sure. Without the knowledge that Josh was scum, I see some town doing this. However, I definitely don't think scum would be this brave to openly defend a scum partner. That's WIFOM though. I like the vote though. Slight town.
Zang #220 - Lame. Although the subsequent Josh interaction gives him some town points. cruelty is right about his VIness though.
Page 10
Darox #227 - Nice try scum.
Slaine #229 - Fence sitting.
Page 11
Spyrex #263 & #271 - Awesome posts. I heart SpyreX already.
Page 12
Darox #290 - More of the same Josh defense. Actually, I don't think scum would openly defend a scummy player like this. Josh keeps digging his own grave. If anything, All the points made by SpyreX are good. I'm thinking there would be a bus somewhere here.
Page 13
ooba #304 - Hmm...Scum would be more willing to do a bus at this point IMO. Plus he's FoSing obvtown SpyreX and scum Josh. Looks like misled townie. But not sure.
Yos #302 - Yos death due to ooba speculation.
SpyreX #315 - I don't get why suspecting both sides is scummy.
NS #320 - Is all kinds of forced. Trying to fit in, reliving the useless scum innkeeper ruse ie. let's go back to talking about useless things and wasting time!, Very skeptical of Josh but no vote ie awkward bus tension, flings some dirt on obvtown who's pushing scum, 'more tonight' comment ie: 'Let town cook on the bullshit info I'm spreading'. I regret that we have but one lynch a day.
Page 14
NS #336 - Glad we're done with the awkward pre-bus tension. Also, still at page 7 an
Zang #338 and #349 - Wow. uh. First time I've seen self-hammering without self-hammering. The timing is incredibly weird. There is a lot of time before Zang's fake/wrong L-1 (1:38am here...but I'm at a diff timezone) and Josh' self hammer (12:17pm). Then Zang hammers at 9:57pm. Doesn't seem like an attempt to secure a bus but that's what they want me to think..I think... Hmm... This is an awesome bus if it is one though.
Page 15
Oh fuck me. I did not know what a traitor was until I saw the official lynch. Josh's traitor flip just did to my reads what my ex-girlfriend did to my heart. Broke it into itsy bitsy pieces and left me empty. God fucking damnit. Now this reread just lost half of it's worth in the scumhunt arena. Excuse me while I smash my head against the wall.
CMAR #356 -Suspecting my top scum read. Not sure what I think atm.
Skeward #361 - I almost forgot this guy was in the game.
NS #368 - obvious scum post looking for an easy lynch.
Page 16
ooba #382 - Good catch. Scum points for CMAR
Darox #398 - Good catch. More of the above
Page 17
CMAR #410 - That doesn't really count if Josh was the traitor as explained in the wiki.
ooba #422 - is awesome and town.
Skeward #423 - Argh. What the fuck. Flip flop with no explanation? Terrible play. Although the fact that he finds my top scum read scummy is good.
Page 18
CMAR #435 - Flailing scum.
CMAR #449 - ............I HATE YOU(not personally). Why oh why did you have to mention my entire case on my scum read before I had the chance to post it. Arghhhhhh. I now think you are town and you've screwed up my reads...AGAIN. Just like my second ex-girlfriend. I hope and pray that my third ex-girlfriend does not show up in this game. Ugh. Anyway, this means that only one of them is scum.
Page 19
Darox #450 - Do not like. It's a pretty impressive case actually. Although Darox has been thickheaded throughout the game anyway so I'm not sure what I think of this.
Skeward #458 - He seems to have reached the same conclusion I have. Not really a tell, but I really liked his early vote on Josh + the first post I mentioned in this reread.
SpyreX #469 - Well, this is not awesome. I hate fluctuating reads. Why are you being hardheaded on a weak 'Josh didn't mention CMAR' case over CMAR's awesome #449?
Page 20
NS #491 - Right, call the guy who made a pretty awesome case against you a VI.
Spyrex - Your NS defense is duly noted. We know who to go after once he flips.
One of NS/CMAR is scum.
NS Scum seems to lead to Spyrex and/or Darox scum. If CMAR is scum...I'm not sure yet.
Ooba is town
Skeward is probtown
Zang is null
cruelty is null
Magna is null
I personally want the NS lynch today because there are some major connections between him and Spyrex/Darox. CMAR doesn't seem to have much connections and the communal hate on him seem to indicate that his wagon is a scumwagon. Although his overall scumminess throughout the game does not save him from my lynch list.
I seem to have replaced into a extreme lurker spot. If my town reads ever found my predecessor's lurkiness malicious, feel free to ask. I think I can explain why she lurked like a mofo but I don't think I should yet.
I don't get this.VasudeVa wrote:NS Scum seems to lead to Spyrex and/or Darox scum.
I personally want the NS lynch today because there are some major connections between him and Spyrex/Darox.
You shouldn't do that, that's bad.VasudeVa wrote:I seem to have replaced into a extreme lurker spot. If my town reads ever found my predecessor's lurkiness malicious, feel free to ask. I think I can explain why she lurked like a mofo but I don't think I should yet.
If you are town, I am slightly disappointed ..NS in Post 0 wrote:I shall be reading and RUTHLESSLY SCUMHUNTING starting..... Now.
I was trying to be sarcastic there.Vas wrote:Ooba #148 - Massclaim attempt? Not sure. Fishy though.
Call me Vas, ;D A little less active than I used to be due to IRL. Hoping to be back up to speed soon-ish!
it's unreasonable to not be thrilled about lynching someone other than your strongest scumread?ooba wrote: - cruelty, does not comment about NS over the last four pages. His only post states that "He would only vote NS grudingly". Surprise, surprise ..
It's the NS defense at #450 that links you to him. CMAR posted a solid case against him. The post was huge, in depth and looked like it took a lot of effort which gives me town vibes. I'll grant you that CMAR isn't exactly the paragon of townieness without that post, but NS defense is NS defense.Darox wrote:No really.
Why are you linking me as NS scumbuddy? Why are you saying I'm defending him?
Calling me nosey doesn't let you act like you're right when you are not.
Call me Vas, ;D A little less active than I used to be due to IRL. Hoping to be back up to speed soon-ish!
Thank you God! Someone with some sense
Those. were. exactly. my. thoughts.VasudeVa wrote:Oh wait. You were against voting for NS after CMAR post..then Skeward posted the exact same thing CMAR posted(although shorter) then you voted...?
......................I do not comprehend.
Vs.TheSkeward wrote:In essence: he seems to think everyone is scum. As soon as anyone is under any kind of pressure at all, he jumps onto them as though he's always been there. Furthermore, whenever he perceives any kind of pressure on himself (above, in the response to Darox, and also in the back-and-forths with CMAR), he responds with venomous ad-hom.
He only very briefly gets close to what Skeward is talking about in the last quote, and manages to drop the ball in pushing home the one real point.CryMeARiver (Summarized by me) wrote:Slaine Hayes has done nothing and said nothing. No opinions, no scumhunting.(Attacks Slaine for something he didn't actually do in the process. Does it again slightly later.)
NS(Starts with a brilliant statement where he twists a neutral statement and portrays it as a negative one)doesn't give a huge bold type quote list of reasons why he feels Josh is scummy. Cry is too stupid to work them out for himself and feels upset by this.
Targeting the lurker.
Being lazy and letting others scumhunt for him.
Not providing reasons for votes.
Bandwagoning.
Given you have not mentioned Sprex once today I feel the need to ask – is he still scum in your eyes? Or was, as you put it at ISO 26 “totally random you guys”. If so why were you random voting well out of RVS?Darox wrote:Spyrex is scum, Ooba is town, Josh is VI.
Is cruelty still scum? Beyond NS (and I still assume CMAR) who do you find most suspicious?Darox wrote:Cruelty needs to stop being scum.
Does the explanation have nothing to do with in-game but rely solely on easjo meta? Because otherwise the only other explanation you could offer is role-based. Given you specifically pointed out soft-claim / claim requests as something you didn’t like out of CMAR, myself, ooba I really would like to know if you are inviting requests for some variety of claim yourself. That would seem to be inconsistent. Note that I want nothing of a claim from you just information as to were your explanation comes from.VasudeVa wrote:I seem to have replaced into a extreme lurker spot. If my town reads ever found my predecessor's lurkiness malicious, feel free to ask. I think I can explain why she lurked like a mofo but I don't think I should yet.
You don’t necessarily have to vote to act on your suspicions. You could work up some questions for those who are triggering your scum radar. In reviewing your ISO you really haven’t advanced any siginificant arguments or questions at players.Zang wrote:Just because I have removed my vote doesn't mean I think he isn't scum, im going to see how his replacement handles things and then decide if I should vote for him. I also have a few minor suspicouns but nothing really voteworthy at the moment.
This was two days before the lynch was made. What changed about your suspicion or lack thereof for Darox that you make no mention of him after night?Zang wrote:I disagree, Darox is the worst of the active lurkers. He still hadn't said why he thinks you (Ooba) are scum.ooba wrote:easjo
- Easily the worst amongst the lurkers
- Active lurking: Has time to answer what a kiwi is, but not the questions posed to him on his previous analysis
- Hasn't taken a stance (Disregarding the previous post)
Did you read through the Josh ISO yourself? He voted for Darox, ooba, Sprex, cruelty, ooba, Sprex and finally himself. The majority of his day Josh spent responding and reacting as opposed to actively questioning anyone. He was definitely on the defensive. Isn't just a reasonable an argument that he had little interaction with CMAR because CMAR didn't question / attack him? If so and you consider that the Mafia didn't know Josh's identity its poor logic to link him to Josh in this manner.Cruelty wrote:if he never mentioned you, then it seems to me to be a reasonable conclusion that you're either so townie that he thought he had no chance of getting you lynched, or he didn't want you lynched.
So you thought that one post was dubious enough to receive a vote but not actually discuss it? And you dropped a vote right out of Day 2 when you had no real reason to be suspicious?cruelty wrote:i thought magna's post was dubious but given i had no real reason to be suspicious of him at the time, it didn't seem worth getting into.