Lay of Leithian Mafia: Game Over!

[Jack]

Jumping on a soft claim seems a bit opportunistic. If I'm town and someone I really suspect soft claims I usually just demand full. It's way better than pushing a wagon up imo. And CKD is seeming fairly genuine, which they aren't acknowledging, it's just "soft claim blah blah 2scum4scum what a bad defense, let's wagon him".

If he's lying he's lynched what's the harm. If he's telling the truth we get rid of someone else we determine scummy who hammers.
Issue?

Don't talk to me about strategy farside.

Vote Count 4 - 04: Lynch

curiouskarmadog -

5

- Iecerint, Budja, SocioPath, Kmd4390, Papa Zito
Anon - 2 - SpyreX, Jack
Iecerint - 2 - curiouskarmadog, xvart
Cobalt - 1 - farside22

Not Voting (7): Starbuck, MehPlusRawr, Cyberbob, Anon, Cobalt, ooba, J-Scope

With 17 players alive it'll take 9 to lynch and 9 to no-Lynch.

[SpyreX]

The hell is 2scum4scum thats driving me nuts.

In general if someone goes "I AM A POWER ROLE OOO I'll SAY MORE IF I GET NEAR LYNCH" I just skip all the bs and get them where they'll fess up.

[Papa Zito]

Call it a super secret town tell.

Not this again.

[SpyreX]

HEY my super secret scum tell worked didn't it.

P.S. I am known to have other super secret scum tells.

P.S.S My vote reflects this.

[Jack]

Anon's scumbuddies don't want him to be lynched.

[Papa Zito]

SPS hasn't flipped yet!

My problem is I always want to lynch Anon, so I never know if he's really scum or not.

[SpyreX]

Then trust/blame me its all good.

SPS lied. I swear to god if we have TWO lemming lying towns welp G-to-the-G scum.

[Jack]

So when I talked about why Anon's scumbuddies didn't want him lynched, you answered as if I was talking to you, and gave a fence sitting opinion of him.

[Papa Zito]

I was talking to SpyreX, Jack. lolirony

ANYWAY FINE

unvote: CKD

vote: Anon

[SpyreX]

(Vig you've been doing the Good Work (TM) players with the letter C at the beginning of their name are Good Calls (TM))

This is what I like to see.

[SocioPath]

CIecerint is not a valid player name, Spy.

[SpyreX]

(Maybe the vig is a little dyslexic (ciecrint)).

(Sociopath is right and that is also fine).

(If SPS is actually town just shoot me and set me freeeee)

(I like parenthesis)

[Míriel Therindë]

Vote Count 4 - 05: Lynch

curiouskarmadog -

4

- Iecerint, Budja, SocioPath, Kmd4390
Anon - 3 - SpyreX, Jack, Papa Zito
Iecerint - 2 - curiouskarmadog, xvart
Cobalt - 1 - farside22

Not Voting (7): Starbuck, MehPlusRawr, Cyberbob, Anon, Cobalt, ooba, J-Scope

With 17 players alive it'll take 9 to lynch and 9 to no-Lynch.

Deadline should be Wednesday May 10th at 8:26 Eastern Time.

[Starbuck]

Vote: Anon

[Cyberbob]

Anon hasn't posted since the 30th. That's more grounds for a replacement than a lynch - something I wouldn't be opposed to for Cobalt, either come to think of it, though the posts that he

has

made have been far worse in terms of content than Anon's.

I don't think CKD is scum for the softclaim; there's no question that it was stupid as hell but at this point it looks like he'd almost be happy with dying because that would mean proving certain people wrong (which is anti-town as shit for a PR to do but scummy? IMO no).

I'm a bit stumped for just who actually might be scum at the moment, the waters are muddied as hell with all these competing wagons. SPS was probably scum given his entirely unneccessary lie; I'll give him a read to see whether there's anyone he came off as especially neutral on or didn't mention a whole lot (both of which being indications of a scumbuddy).

[curiouskarmadog]

at this point it looks like he'd almost be happy with dying because that would mean proving certain people wrong (which is anti-town as shit for a PR to do but scummy? IMO no).

for the record, that is not what I am doing...if you town and really are trying to figure it out, we can discuss it (if it isnt obvious by) end game. I am never happy dying, if you check out my wiki, I care about my game wins and losses, I never just throw away games.

[Papa Zito]

Anon hasn't posted since the 30th. That's more grounds for a replacement than a lynch - something I wouldn't be opposed to for Cobalt, either come to think of it, though the posts that he

has

made have been far worse in terms of content than Anon's.

Dear town,

If Anon flips scum, Cyberbob is a buddy, Cobalt probably not.

Just FYI.


Love,

PZ

I don't think CKD is scum for the softclaim; there's no question that it was stupid as hell but at this point it looks like he'd almost be happy with dying because that would mean proving certain people wrong (which is anti-town as shit for a PR to do but scummy? IMO no).

CKD claims this isn't the case.

Give a pro-town reason for CKD doing this.

the waters are muddied as hell with all these competing wagons.

I <3 competing wagons. Competing wagons are gold. I'm sorry your buddy is on one of them.

[Jack]

Scum points for CyberBob.

[J-Scope]

Vote: Anon

This is my (Jah's) top choice. Good wagoners and gut vibes, but also I don't know how Anon went after Els for that weak RVS misinterpretation of post 4 while not seeing anything suspicious with xofelf-Sens Fan fight in his post 622. I would think that someone scumhunting on the wavelength to find Els scummy would also have some bad feelings about xof/Sens. Them both being town looks like a gift horse to scum, just leave it be and reap the rewards.

I don't know if he could be scum with SPS (who better be scum), because Anon had a lot of suspects and SPS just happened to be the wagon he apparently had to settle for day 1. I don't like his case because it seems to fit Anon's play too.

Steam Powered caught my attention with iso 3. I find people who use jokes to support a game stance, inherently scummy. Cyberbob in iso 3 uses personal experience to back up a position that cant be generalized.

This coming from the guy who, after being told Elvis was not in the game, came back with another player read on elvis.

We don't need a Anon replacement as much as we need a Anon lynch.

Does Cobalt lurking = Cobalt scum? I've seen him post as scum, but he was under plenty of pressure then.

I'm also not feeling the CKD wagon, and I need to re-read the Iecerint case.

[Jack]

Cobalt doesn't seem to be posting in other games either.

[Cyberbob]

If Anon flips scum, Cyberbob is a buddy, Cobalt probably not.

so you're saying we shouldn't replace someone who hasn't posted in nearly a week (minus Night 3)?

hahahaha yeah sure whatever mang. I love it when people ~GET ON AN AGGRESSIVE ROLL FTW~ and think they're just top shit at reading OBVSCUM into everything.

Just FYI.


Love,

CB

CKD claims this isn't the case.

Give a pro-town reason for CKD doing this.

If that's not the case then yeah his behaviour is scummy. Are you going to come at me this aggressively over literally everything I say because OMG I DARED TO DISAGREE ABOUT HOW WE SHOULD TREAT AN INACTIVE PLAYER?

I <3 competing wagons. Competing wagons are gold. I'm sorry your buddy is on one of them.

I <3 these kinds of "lol ur scum" posts. "lol ur scum" posts are gold. I'm sorry your hyperactiveness is stamped all over it.

[Cyberbob]

Scum points for CyberBob.

My name is Cyberbob. If you're going to make a oneliner +1 post (which of course PZ is going to let you get away with because you aren't disagreeing with him) it would be cool if you could get it right. Thanks.

[Papa Zito]

Overdefensiveness FTW.

Vigs, you know what to do.

[Cyberbob]

Overdefensiveness FTW.

Vigs, you know what to do.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias

hi you may have heard of this

[Papa Zito]

Wow you sure dropped the venom quick. But I can't link that to a Wiki article so I guess it doesn't count.

so you're saying we shouldn't replace someone who hasn't posted in nearly a week (minus Night 3)?

Oh yes. I'm saying we should lynch the scum no matter how often they post. And save poor Plum the trouble of finding a replacement.

OMG I DARED TO DISAGREE ABOUT HOW WE SHOULD TREAT AN INACTIVE PLAYER?

What's funny was everything was cool until I dared to call you scum. (you can put that in ALL CAPS if you want)

I <3 these kinds of "lol ur scum" posts.

lol ur scum