Lay of Leithian Mafia: Game Over!

[ooba]

To clarify .. I targeted someone last night and got the result .. "Someone watched PlayerX" .. Could be another watcher also (maybe of the race of men?) but think FFFF's power transferring is more likely ..

Vote Count 4 - 03: Lynch

curiouskarmadog -

3

- Iecerint, Budja, SocioPath,
xvart - 1 - Kmd4390
Anon - 2 - SpyreX, Jack
Iecerint - 2 - curiouskarmadog, xvart
Cobalt - 1 - farside22

Not Voting (8): Starbuck, MehPlusRawr, Papa Zito, Cyberbob, Anon, Cobalt, ooba, J-Scope

With 17 players alive it'll take 9 to lynch and 9 to no-Lynch.

[SocioPath]

you just trying to jump on the wagon real quick and unnoticed?

Yes, unnoticed to those that don't read.

no sir...Wagon me if you will, thats fine...but you better put a case out there so it can be evaluated later.

No thanks.

[Papa Zito]

Hey kids. I'm going to catch up in another game and then do this one.

[Iecerint]

So it looks like CKD's defense goes like this:

1. CKD is 2SCUM4SCUM, ergo town.
2. We will regret wagoning CKD because he is a PR or something, but he dares us to wagon him, anyway.

More votes, please.

[Kmd4390]

Unvote, Vote CKD

[curiouskarmadog]

there is nothing to defend..what is your case based on Iec?

and yes, scum will want to jump on this wagon for no reason....

look SP and KMD have quickly jumped on the wagon without reason...PLEASE sweet god, hold them to the fire for this when the time comes.

[farside22]

I don't see why people are voting for CKD. I have yet to see a case.
Any reply on why your not voting for cobalt at this time would also be appriecated.

[Papa Zito]

ooba's telling the truth.

ooba
kmd
farside

all town woo

but I am telling you, you wont what you will find down there (oh was that a soft claim, lets push and find out).

OK.

vote: CKD

Kmd, why is xvart scum again?

[curiouskarmadog]

LOL.....why not just ask for the claim PZ?

[curiouskarmadog]

ooba's telling the truth.

ooba
kmd
farside

all town woo

I get farside...but why KMD and ooba? Lets say they are telling the truth about their roles (why does that say they are town?).

What about Jscope, did he have someone confirm is role too?

[Kmd4390]

Farside, CKD is scum for the need to softclaim after just three votes. I almost wanna say he's a better player than that and is doing it to intentionally seem scummy, but on Day 4? I dunno.

---------------------

Zito, xvart is scum for over reacting to votes and misrepping on Day 1.

[curiouskarmadog]

Farside, CKD is scum for the need to softclaim after just three votes. I almost wanna say he's a better player than that and is doing it to intentionally seem scummy, but on Day 4? I dunno.

wooo, wont you be excited to see the surprise..lol...sooo, I am better player (as town) than that?...or am I a bad player as scum...I am confused..why are you voting me?

[farside22]

Okay I did look and iec had one point that CKD completely ignored. During the wagon on SPS you voted for Iec without reasoning. Why did you switch to iec while still having suspicion for SPS?

[curiouskarmadog]

cross post...

if SPS is scum, then I think the claim is fake....I cant see scum coming out with this claim..it doesnt make since.

[curiouskarmadog]

Why did you switch to iec while still having suspicion for SPS?

It was a better wagon, yielded more information.

and I wasnt so sure SPS was scum....various reasons, but you and I both know they dont matter today....I am what scum is cooking for dinner, dear if you are town, you dont want to be last to get a bite.

[farside22]

cross post...

if SPS is scum, then I think the claim is fake....I cant see scum coming out with this claim..it doesnt make since.

And he also had another part of his claim that didn't suggest he was an elf and from reading the front page only elves go tot he hall.....so?

That still doesn't explain why you were voting Iec.

[Jack]

CKD was scummy, but the recent votes seem scummy too.

[Papa Zito]

LOL.....why not just ask for the claim PZ?

Wagons are informative.

Plus it would ruin the surprise! \o/

Zito, xvart is scum for over reacting to votes and misrepping on Day 1.

Arrite. I was hoping there was new data somewhere.

Someone vig Socipath plz. And Cobalt.

[curiouskarmadog]

Hmmm, I think PZ is right, my wagon will be informative....it is not going to end like some might expect...woo hoo...lets get to business then.

[Kmd4390]

CKD, I'm saying you are acting so scummy that it looks newbscum which you obviously aren't.

[farside22]

I think CKD is town. Call it a super secret town tell.
I personally hammer if I'm reading everything right.
I saw a few votes Anon anyone want to hazard to me why?

[SpyreX]

Call it a super secret hunch.

I wouldn't be opposed to Cobalt eating a bullet butttt.

[Budja]

CKD was scummy, but the recent votes seem scummy too.

Any reason why?

--
Lurker wagons (Anon, Cobalt) < Scummy player wagons (CKD)

[Jack]

Jumping on a soft claim seems a bit opportunistic. If I'm town and someone I really suspect soft claims I usually just demand full. It's way better than pushing a wagon up imo. And CKD is seeming fairly genuine, which they aren't acknowledging, it's just "soft claim blah blah 2scum4scum what a bad defense, let's wagon him".

[farside22]

Jumping on a soft claim seems a bit opportunistic. If I'm town and someone I really suspect soft claims I usually just demand full. It's way better than pushing a wagon up imo. And CKD is seeming fairly genuine, which they aren't acknowledging, it's just "soft claim blah blah 2scum4scum what a bad defense, let's wagon him".

If he's lying he's lynched what's the harm. If he's telling the truth we get rid of someone else we determine scummy who hammers.
Issue?