Stars Aligned II - Game Over!

[farside22]

I defended Plum because I considered it the optimal play, either way scum would be dead, and in best case we would have had an extra pro-town kill. Either plan resulted in the same scenario, as we will just lynch a suspect we could have lynched yesterday in lieu of Plum.I still believe that someone else should have been lynched, and Plum would have been revealed as scum today.

In any case, I don't see you as scum, I'm just showing that your belief that I am cult is unfounded.

That still doesnt' explain your comment about lynching me instead of trying to see if Plum was telling the truth and then WIFOM (since I knew I would be alive) saying I could still bel scum after the fact.

Please explain why a cultist would rez Adel.

[farside22]

Also for those who are still alive that rob graves the first time. Did anyone get a res kit from anyone that night?

[semioldguy]

I believe you already had a theory about this... why are you inquiring others about that action if you already had an explanation for yourself about it?

I think I saw 2 people believe me when I stated I didn't hear a noise. I figured if they don't believe me then the next day when I'm alive will prove she is lying. Some seem to think that her using the kit to help Adel day 1 made her seem town. I have a theory on this but it's more WIFOM then reality.

[animorpherv1]

Also for those who are still alive that rob graves the first time. Did anyone get a res kit from anyone that night?

By "The first time" do you mean the first to rob graves?

If so, that was me (and only me, Nicodemus lynch), and no.

[farside22]

I believe you already had a theory about this... why are you inquiring others about that action if you already had an explanation for yourself about it?

I think I saw 2 people believe me when I stated I didn't hear a noise. I figured if they don't believe me then the next day when I'm alive will prove she is lying. Some seem to think that her using the kit to help Adel day 1 made her seem town. I have a theory on this but it's more WIFOM then reality.

Do you think I'm a cultist?

[farside22]

Also for those who are still alive that rob graves the first time. Did anyone get a res kit from anyone that night?

By "The first time" do you mean the first to rob graves?

If so, that was me (and only me, Nicodemus lynch), and no.

Sorry I was talking about after Nico's lynch. I thought there was 4 bodies after nico's lynch and that no one rob'ed a grave till another night. I'm wonder if anyone found anything on those players that were murdered:
Sajin, iec or katy?

[semioldguy]

I believe you already had a theory about this... why are you inquiring others about that action if you already had an explanation for yourself about it?

I think I saw 2 people believe me when I stated I didn't hear a noise. I figured if they don't believe me then the next day when I'm alive will prove she is lying. Some seem to think that her using the kit to help Adel day 1 made her seem town. I have a theory on this but it's more WIFOM then reality.

Do you think I'm a cultist?

I'm not sure, but I certainly don't understand why you are asking someone else to explain something you've thought of an explanation for yesterday.

I don't think Kunkstar7 is likely a cultist.

If Plum resuscitated Adel/Hayker/Furcolow then it would make the person she targeted/saved a cultist, not the person trying to kill Adel/Hayker/Furcolow.

You going after Kunkstar7 makes no sense to me.

[iLord]

I am way behind, but I now have time. Catching up from where I left off.

[farside22]

I believe you already had a theory about this... why are you inquiring others about that action if you already had an explanation for yourself about it?

I think I saw 2 people believe me when I stated I didn't hear a noise. I figured if they don't believe me then the next day when I'm alive will prove she is lying. Some seem to think that her using the kit to help Adel day 1 made her seem town. I have a theory on this but it's more WIFOM then reality.

Do you think I'm a cultist?

I'm not sure, but I certainly don't understand why you are asking someone else to explain something you've thought of an explanation for yesterday.

I don't think Kunkstar7 is likely a cultist.

If Plum resuscitated Adel/Hayker/Furcolow then it would make the person she targeted/saved a cultist, not the person trying to kill Adel/Hayker/Furcolow.

You going after Kunkstar7 makes no sense to me.

No one claimed the kill on start and chaco pretty much did it the moment he was online. So explain why you think I'm a cultist

Did I state what my theory was at the time? Did I not say it was based on WIFOM? What part of my theory now that Plum has flipped as a cultist looks false to you and why?

I think Kunk is scum based on his defense of her over and over again without letting her answer for herself. He could have lied about targeting Adel for all we know after how many days later?

[rewq455]

@DGB- What was your 2nd night action last night?

[kunkstar7]

Also for those who are still alive that rob graves the first time. Did anyone get a res kit from anyone that night?

By "The first time" do you mean the first to rob graves?

If so, that was me (and only me, Nicodemus lynch), and no.

Sorry I was talking about after Nico's lynch. I thought there was 4 bodies after nico's lynch and that no one rob'ed a grave till another night. I'm wonder if anyone found anything on those players that were murdered:
Sajin, iec or katy?

Pretty sure no one got anything. One thing I found interesting, Dram has extra/missing graverobs, I tried to see if there was any inconsistency, but I think only he explains one of the mysterious graverobs.

Honestly farside any defense I can think of right now is only going to be WIFOM and you seem set on trying to drive an unreasonable lynch on me so whatev go ahead.

My opinion, 1 cult left, 1 murderer besides dram left.
Elli is a murderer,
rewq is the final cult. <-- have to check this over agaiin, I think someone may have checked this out for me.

[kunkstar7]

Please explain why a cultist would rez Adel.

Townie cred. They knew Adel was being stalked and hoped that by rezzing him they would show up as protown. It worked obviously, as it made it more likely in my mind that Plum was town and you were lying yesterday. I was wrong, but it still proves my point here.

Also since I know my actions, Plum had to have rezzed Hayker, otherwise someone else would have claimed it then. If you don't believe Plum rezzed Adel then explain who did.

[iLord]

Notes while skimming over:

semi's probably not cult or murderer.

DGB may be cult still.

farside's probably not cult. And probably not a murderer that's going to win anytime soon.

Percy, what will your put as the manner of death if a player were to be the target of the ritual and murder? I assume murder, because that resolves first?

kunkstar is probably not cult. And probably not a murderer that's going to win anytime soon.

Dramonic is murderer?

Where did the cult kill go last night?

Possible Murderer (1 left):

Ellibereth
farside22

Probably Town:

rewq455
semioldguy
VP Baltar
animorpherv1
kunkstar7
Furcolow

Probably Cult (2 left):

DrippingGoofball
Magua

Dramonic lost his action last night so we can lynch him tomorrow. One of Elli or farside is the last murderer, but they've grave robbed so much that they're not likely to be able to win anytime soon.

There's probably two cultists left. And conveniently, there's two in the probably cult column. I'd be satisfied with either lynch.

Who did we have rob which graves last night?

This is kind of rushed - more later.

[kunkstar7]

Lets kill cultists first. There isn't going to be a murder tonight since its an offnight so they aren't much of a menace.

Where did the cult kill go last night?

Guessing something to do with this:

Prerequisites: Only Cultists may take this action.

At least one third (rounding up) of the Cultists must submit the same name for the Ritual to take effect

, and the

Cultists must possess a Fetish linked to the target.

This is assuming the cult isn't dead.

[animorpherv1]

@iLord:

Cult may have tried to kill VP, and I Warded him.

[kunkstar7]

@iLord:

Cult may have tried to kill VP, and I Warded him.

I don't think ward prevents Ritual kills.

[animorpherv1]

@iLord:

Cult may have tried to kill VP, and I Warded him.

Um, woops. I thought wrong...

[dramonic]

Dramonic lost his action last night so we can lynch him tomorrow. One of Elli or farside is the last murderer, but they've grave robbed so much that they're not likely to be able to win anytime soon.

I'm short two murders, soonest I can win is night 10.

[iLord]

I'm short two murders, soonest I can win is night 10.

Just because you can't win does not stop you from doing things that hurt the town. We're not sure which of Elli or farside is the last murderer, but you've conveniently came out and claimed.

[VP Baltar]

Did you hear Noise last night? This is just me making sure I didn't get warded.

I did indeed.

My gut still says that Magua is cult. I'd be up for lynching him if we're leaving dram until tomorrow.

[Furcolow]

rewq was not more insane than i was. that pretty much clears him in my eyes. i now have 2 insanities.

[Furcolow]

Wait didn't Plum state she rez'ed Adel on night 1. I wonder why she would do that.
Then we had ksun saying that Dench stalked Adel with the intent to kill.
Why would cultist scum save one of their own?

Fos; Furlow

no fucking idea why the hell they would rez me, but maybe it was to build town cred as i am an obvious townie. in any case, i will say that rewq has no more than 1 insanity, as that's what i figured out last night.

[DrippingGoofball]

@DGB- What was your 2nd night action last night?

None, why? We can do two actions every night???

[VP Baltar]

no fucking idea why the hell they would rez me, but maybe it was to build town cred as i am an obvious townie. in any case, i will say that rewq has no more than 1 insanity, as that's what i figured out last night.

Adel was not an obvious townie. Also, rewq having low insanities doesn't really clear him of being cult.

[iLord]

DGB's almost trying to be lynched. VP, you still think she's town?