Scummies 2010 Nominations

[zoraster]

Nominate Ythill for Mafia Catcher

Yes, it's true he wasn't technically a player in the game, and I had to think hard about whether Ythill or shaft.ed was more appropriate, but Ythill was, until the very last, 3/3 in pegging scum. He lost it when there was a lot of evidence that exonerated Zang, but even then he had the insight that Zang might be a gunsmith framer -- not exactly a "normal" thing to have in a game. Shaft.ed certainly deserves honorable mention for pushing Zang so hard, but Ythill was amazing at catching scum this game.

Anyway, that game is: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 93&start=0
And the thread he did this in was: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 07&start=0

[Zang]

Nominate Ythill for Mafia Catcher

Yes, it's true he wasn't technically a player in the game, and I had to think hard about whether Ythill or shaft.ed was more appropriate, but Ythill was, until the very last, 3/3 in pegging scum. He lost it when there was a lot of evidence that exonerated Zang. Shaft.ed certainly deserves honorable mention for pushing Zang so hard.

Anyway, that game is: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 93&start=0
And the thread he did this in was: http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 07&start=0

Second

[animorpherv1]

nominate Zang for Best Role Claim - Almost No Rules Mafia link above)

That Bodyguard claim was amazing. I, as the gunsmith, believed we had a town win when I got TNM as having a gun,becuase the claim was not only belivable, but it was the fact the it said that he died if he protected right.

[zoraster]

nominate Zang for Best Role Claim - Almost No Rules Mafia link above)

That Bodyguard claim was amazing. I, as the gunsmith, believed we had a town win when I got TNM as having a gun,becuase the claim was not only belivable, but it was the fact the it said that he died if he protected right.

This was actually the fake claim I gave him at the beginning of the game, but I'll let him take the credit

[animorpherv1]

nominate Zang for Best Role Claim - Almost No Rules Mafia link above)

That Bodyguard claim was amazing. I, as the gunsmith, believed we had a town win when I got TNM as having a gun,becuase the claim was not only belivable, but it was the fact the it said that he died if he protected right.

This was actually the fake claim I gave him at the beginning of the game, but I'll let him take the credit

He played it believably well though.

[Mr. Flay]

Eh. Playing up a safeclaim isn't really what Best Role Claim is about... if anything, it might be Best Individual (Scum) or whatever they're calling it these days.

[animorpherv1]

I had no idea where to place it.

That can go wherever it fits best.

[zoraster]

Yeah, perhaps I should be clearer. Not only was it a safe claim, but the role PM itself was made by me prior to the game starting. I realized this would be necessary given the possibility of crypto claims.

Not to take anything away from Zang, of course.

[Zang]

Yeah, perhaps I should be clearer. Not only was it a safe claim, but the role PM itself was made by me prior to the game starting. I realized this would be necessary given the possibility of crypto claims.

Not to take anything away from Zang, of course.

thanks for the nomination though, ani

[Zorblag]

Troll will

Third Mustilicor for outstanding new player

for the performance in Newbie Game 917. Troll thinks the play was very strong (especially for a player new to the system here) and looks forward to seeing more from Mustilicor in the future.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[totallynotmafia]

Third Ythill

I wish he had actually been in the game

[PokerFace]

<Insert Giant Face Palm here>

I thought that let's play mafia thing was some crazy joke as i checked thread at work and did not understand it. Should have known something was up and checked it again considering that thread size but oh well. I had no idea it was some cool crazy bastard game. I give props to zoraster for running it. Kinda wish i had known about it and could have played along but meh thems the breaks. Guess I'll just have to read it for the lulz later or time travel

[animorpherv1]

Someone should make another sometime soon.
I already have a list of stuff I wanna run :/

[shaft.ed]

Nominate Town of Pick Your Power III: A Brave New Worldfor best performance town.

Utterly steamrolled the scum.

[Parama]

Nominating DocPotter for Best Scum Catcher in Last Will Mafia
Successful vigging of an entire scumteam. Doesn't get much better at catching scum than that.

[hp [leaves]]

2nding DocPotter in Last will Mafia

[Scummies]

Updated as of 340

[VP Baltar]

Nominate Sotty7 for Don Corleone for Gonzo Mafia

Sotty has time and again proven she's an excellent scum player who doesn't afraid of anything, but after both of her scum buddies were lynched Day 1 and Day 2 in this game I was certain she didn't have a chance. Did I mention she also had her kill prevented Night 1? Yeah.

[hohum]

Nominate Sotty7 for Don Corleone for Gonzo Mafia

Sotty has time and again proven she's an excellent scum player who doesn't afraid of anything, but after both of her scum buddies were lynched Day 1 and Day 2 in this game I was certain she didn't have a chance. Did I mention she also had her kill prevented Night 1? Yeah.

Second

she did really had us all beaten here.

[xRECKONERx]

Third Sotty

Brilliant play.

[ortolan]

Second Sotty

Brilliant play.

fourth

[Percy]

And fifth!

[Fate]

I read the end of 109 very briefly. I'm not a fan of reduced majorities needed for lynches, especially at LyLo. ESPECIALLY if it is then decided that "whoever reached the 2 votes first is the one that gets lynched"

Meh, seems like a win on a technicality rather than pro-town awesomeness or bad scum play by Spyrex.

[Iecerint]

Nominate

DrippingGoofball

for

Best Replacement

in

Kingdom Hearts Mafia

.

Replaced a player who had all-but-claimed his role D1, come under scrutiny, then lurked to replacement. Adapted beautifully to her situation by balancing measured suspicion-baiting to avoid the NK with town-leading to survive as an outed tracker nearly to endgame while catching pretty much every scum not caught by investigation along the way in a Large game.

[Kise]

^

Seconded