Stars Aligned II - Game Over!

[Percy]

Vote Count

Plum - 3 (semioldguy, DrippingGoofball, rewq455)

dramonic - 1 (Plum)
DrippingGoofball - 1 (farside22)

Not Voting

- 8 (animorpherv1, dramonic, Ellibereth, iLord, kunkstar7, Magua, VP Baltar, Furcolow)

Deadline for today's lynch is

Saturday April 24th at 4:00am (site time)

. You can view a countdown to the deadline

here

.

Activity check tomorrow.

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

[iLord]

Magua, how likely do you think DGB is scum?

[VP Baltar]

Farside does make a good point about the start kill. That makes me feel better about tonight.

Vote: Magua

*twitch*

[rewq455]

Why are we lyching Magua

[Magua]

Magua, how likely do you think DGB is scum?

I direct you to my post #2534.

The only person I feel more likely to be scum than DGB is dramonic, but I understand not lynching dramonic today because of the loss of the night action.

[Furcolow]

going to trust me read on this, and hope kunkstar isnt the murderer stalking me.

*twitch* change my

vote to: plum

*drools* *twitch*

I am checking in... definitely going to be checkin rewq. investigators consider rezzing me, as i'm trying to be more docile and helpful.

[Furcolow]

Sorry to split this up, but I do not see magua as being scum. I don't have any reason against him dying, though, so if you all want to lynch him i don't care.

[rewq455]

going to trust me read on this, and hope kunkstar isnt the murderer stalking me.

*twitch* change my

vote to: plum

*drools* *twitch*

I am checking in... definitely going to be checkin rewq. investigators consider rezzing me, as i'm trying to be more docile and helpful.

We don't want to lynch Plum today though. We want to lynch him tomorrow if Farside is not murdered.

[rewq455]

Un-vote, vote DGB

[VP Baltar]

DGB's not likely cult or murderer and I have thoroughly explained why. Out of our VERY small pool of suspects, Magua is clearly the best option today. Do it.

[semioldguy]

Sorry for being MIA, will catch up today sometime.

[DrippingGoofball]

unvote, vote: Magua

*twitch*

[kunkstar7]

(Can we lynch Furcolow just for kicks?)

Srs bsns:

Just had some thoughts. _{[Paranoid Moment]} VP Baltar: Besides the communing with iLord/SOG, is there any other ways you can prove that you are not cultist, besides behavior?

[VP Baltar]

VP Baltar: Besides the communing with iLord/SOG, is there any other ways you can prove that you are not cultist, besides behavior?

You mean besides being fairly early on every cult lynch, warding Adel as my first action, having my insanities proven by iLord, opposing several easy mislynches and generally sticking my neck out at most every turn?

Nope.

[kunkstar7]

VP Baltar: Besides the communing with iLord/SOG, is there any other ways you can prove that you are not cultist, besides behavior?

You mean besides being fairly early on every cult lynch, warding Adel as my first action, having my insanities proven by iLord, opposing several easy mislynches and generally sticking my neck out at most every turn?

Nope.

That works .
Just for a moment there I lost the reasoning why you were so obvtown.

[semioldguy]

Unvote, Vote: dramonic

*twitch*

I await good reasons not to do this.

At least one of farside22 and Plum is lying. At least one of them is scum. Let's lynch one of them rather than someone else.

SOG, do you still have your occult books?

I have two.

Semi, can you claim all your night actions if you have not already done so?

N0 - Search - Occult Books (no noise)
I think this is the most useful item.

N1 - Search - Resuscitation Kit (noise)
Second most useful item.

N2 - Search - Occult Books (noise)
Getting an extra now is better than having to use an action to get another later when it's really needed.

N3 - Search - Forensic Tools (no noise)
Cultists had been falling a couple days and this is good for finding murderers better than cult.

N4 - Commune - evilsnail (no noise)
As per the plan. Twitchy taken as my insanity.

Essentially actions in the late game are more valuable and I don't want to waste them on searching if it can be avoided.

[semioldguy]

I don't really understand or agree the voting for Magua.

At least one of Plum and farside22 is assured to be lying scum. Why are votes going elsewhere?

[kunkstar7]

I don't really understand or agree the voting for Magua.

At least one of Plum and farside22 is assured to be lying scum. Why are votes going elsewhere?

Because:

A)If Plum murders Farside, then dead Farsidescum, Plum is likely town.

B)If Farside lives, the we lynch Plumscum. Farside is likely town.

They do all the work for us, and we get to choose another likely suspect to lynch. No use wasting today's lynch by messing up the above setup.

[semioldguy]

Why does either conclusion draw the other as likely town? If Plum murders farside, she could be a murder and the town is just handing her a kill. If farside22 lives, this doesn't make her automatically town.

If Plum kills her, then it's another person to put on grave robbing duty forever. We aren't going to have enough bodies to ensure that none of these claimed killers don't go murderer in addition to other potential murders out there who are already doing their thing.

So even if Plum kills her, we are likely going to have to lynch her as she will have the only claimed kill that also allows her to have part of another existing kill and therefore the most potentially dangerous to town of all the claimed killers. Graverobbing isn't even safe for Plum anymore if she murders farside22, since if it is her second kill than she just ignores the turn she has to grave rob and wins. We'd have to lynch her if she kills farside22. If she doesn't kill farside22, we are going to have to lynch her also. It's going to happen either way.

Let's just lynch her.

[rewq455]

Apparently I missed something. I skimmed over the last 8 or 9 pages and I saw no posts saying why we are lynching Magua. Why are we?

[rewq455]

Besides POE.

[farside22]

Why does either conclusion draw the other as likely town? If Plum murders farside, she could be a murder and the town is just handing her a kill. If farside22 lives, this doesn't make her automatically town.

If Plum kills her, then it's another person to put on grave robbing duty forever. We aren't going to have enough bodies to ensure that none of these claimed killers don't go murderer in addition to other potential murders out there who are already doing their thing.

So even if Plum kills her, we are likely going to have to lynch her as she will have the only claimed kill that also allows her to have part of another existing kill and therefore the most potentially dangerous to town of all the claimed killers. Graverobbing isn't even safe for Plum anymore if she murders farside22, since if it is her second kill than she just ignores the turn she has to grave rob and wins. We'd have to lynch her if she kills farside22. If she doesn't kill farside22, we are going to have to lynch her also. It's going to happen either way.

Let's just lynch her.

I didn't hear a noise. I'm willing to let the lying Plum live because most people do not believe me even though Chaco told the truth about who he killed. You still have a possible 2 murders (those that killed N1) that are lying or hiding and you want to lynch one of me or her because you think we are murders without proof.

I sense someone looking for murders more then cultist in this post. And completely wrong about me. If I was lying I would push for Plum's lynch out of fear of being dead.

[semioldguy]

startransmission likely was one of the three murders, vikingfan another. I only view one of those murders as being open unless there was overlap.

I don't see it as more likely that she is murderer or cult than the other, just that she could likely be either and I want anti-town gone. Her being a potential murderer just requires a longer explanation of why we need to kill her anyway than if she was cult.

[DrippingGoofball]

I think farside is town.

[farside22]

I think farside is town.

DGB if you are actually town please tell me why did you pick averision to iLord and why are you so blah about mafia?