Stars Aligned II - Game Over!

[rewq455]

@Ani- my bad. I am still basing your gender of your old avatar.

I agree that DGB should be grave-robbing if not lynched ( I would prefer a lynch though).

@ mod- If person B rezzes person A and A rezzes B, are they both rezzed or is only 1?

[dramonic]

I'm against any of the Grave-Robbers taking avolition.

If none of our lynch and graverobbers are cultists we end up ridiculously close to a LyLo case, three days in a row.

[farside22]

If farside's scum, then she won't bother to rob the grave as she's dying anyway.

If farside's town, we don't want her to waste the body.

I was thinking something along those lines - I might've missed something, though.

So I'm damned if I do and damned if I don't.
I'm going to be alive tomorrow I hope you have a really good explanation why.

PLEASE DO NOT TARGET ME FOR A REZ TONIGHT. I DID NOT HEAR A NOISE.

[iLord]

I'm against any of the Grave-Robbers taking avolition.

If none of our lynch and graverobbers are cultists we end up ridiculously close to a LyLo case, three days in a row.

I seriously doubt that that's the case.

So I'm damned if I do and damned if I don't.
I'm going to be alive tomorrow I hope you have a really good explanation why.

PLEASE DO NOT TARGET ME FOR A REZ TONIGHT. I DID NOT HEAR A NOISE.

I don't get what you mean by the first part.

The point of this was to test for the scenario that Plum is investigator telling the truth. Tomorrow, we'll be in the same situation as today, minus one possibility.

[dramonic]

I'm against any of the Grave-Robbers taking avolition.

If none of our lynch and graverobbers are cultists we end up ridiculously close to a LyLo case, three days in a row.

I seriously doubt that that's the case.

So I'm damned if I do and damned if I don't.
I'm going to be alive tomorrow I hope you have a really good explanation why.

PLEASE DO NOT TARGET ME FOR A REZ TONIGHT. I DID NOT HEAR A NOISE.

I don't get what you mean by the first part.

The point of this was to test for the scenario that Plum is investigator telling the truth. Tomorrow, we'll be in the same situation as today, minus one possibility.

So do I, but the risk/reward isnt worth it.

[farside22]

I'm against any of the Grave-Robbers taking avolition.

If none of our lynch and graverobbers are cultists we end up ridiculously close to a LyLo case, three days in a row.

I seriously doubt that that's the case.

So I'm damned if I do and damned if I don't.
I'm going to be alive tomorrow I hope you have a really good explanation why.

PLEASE DO NOT TARGET ME FOR A REZ TONIGHT. I DID NOT HEAR A NOISE.

I don't get what you mean by the first part.

The point of this was to test for the scenario that Plum is investigator telling the truth. Tomorrow, we'll be in the same situation as today, minus one possibility.

You stated that if I'm scum I won't bother robbing graves.
Since I'm town you don't want me wasting the bodies. I feel like well I'm damned if I waste them and I'm damned if I don't do it with that statement.

Since I will be alive tomorrow what explanation will you have for that? How is it the same situation today?


As for DGB she never answered my questions. Yes I believe scum DGB would buss her scum buddies. DGB purposely took Aversion and this was after the discussion of forcing players to take Aversion to find the remaining cultist. And I still feel that when she took the penalty of no action for the night there was no pro-town reason to do so.

[iLord]

So do I, but the risk/reward isnt worth it.

Yeah, like I said, low-risk low-reward. Not a big deal either way.

You stated that if I'm scum I won't bother robbing graves.
Since I'm town you don't want me wasting the bodies. I feel like well I'm damned if I waste them and I'm damned if I don't do it with that statement.

To be clear, you are not to rob bodies tonight.

Since I will be alive tomorrow what explanation will you have for that? How is it the same situation today?

It's not up to me to provide an explanation - it'd be up to Plum, likely. And in all likelihood, your stories will contradict once more and we'll still be in the same position where one of you must be scum. Right now I don't want to lynch either of you on the chance that Plum's investigator with a stalk on you, we'd have wasted a lynch no matter whether we choose to lynch her or you.

[farside22]

It's not up to me to provide an explanation - it'd be up to Plum, likely. And in all likelihood, your stories will contradict once more and we'll still be in the same position where one of you must be scum. Right now I don't want to lynch either of you on the chance that Plum's investigator with a stalk on you, we'd have wasted a lynch no matter whether we choose to lynch her or you.

If no one Rez's me and they should not then how will there be a contradiction? If someone says they rez'ed me they should be lynched too.

[iLord]

If no one Rez's me and they should not then how will there be a contradiction? If someone says they rez'ed me they should be lynched too.

Plum has to claim that you were rezzed, if you are still alive tomorrow.

[kunkstar7]

If no one Rez's me and they should not then how will there be a contradiction? If someone says they rez'ed me they should be lynched too.

Plum has to claim that you were rezzed, if you are still alive tomorrow.

iLord, what would be your opinion if Plum claimed that she attempted the kill but apparently Farside was rezzed, and someone else claims the rez? What would you think of Plum, Farside, and the claimed rezz'er?

[iLord]

iLord, what would be your opinion if Plum claimed that she attempted the kill but apparently Farside was rezzed, and someone else claims the rez? What would you think of Plum, Farside, and the claimed rezz'er?

Rezzer would be Cultist. Plum could not be Cultist at that point, and Farside is would likely be Cultist (It doesn't make too much sense for the scum to save the death of an Investigator/Murderer and then have us mislynch that same player. It's sort of the same deal with CSL).

[Percy]

@ mod- If person B rezzes person A and A rezzes B, are they both rezzed or is only 1?

Neither.

[farside22]

If no one Rez's me and they should not then how will there be a contradiction? If someone says they rez'ed me they should be lynched too.

Plum has to claim that you were rezzed, if you are still alive tomorrow.

I don't get you at all. Why are you giving excuses for tomorrow if you believe Plum today.

[farside22]

iLord, what would be your opinion if Plum claimed that she attempted the kill but apparently Farside was rezzed, and someone else claims the rez? What would you think of Plum, Farside, and the claimed rezz'er?

Rezzer would be Cultist. Plum could not be Cultist at that point, and Farside is would likely be Cultist (It doesn't make too much sense for the scum to save the death of an Investigator/Murderer and then have us mislynch that same player. It's sort of the same deal with CSL).

And this makes less sense considering that myself and chaco both claimed to the kill on Start.

[iLord]

I don't get you at all. Why are you giving excuses for tomorrow if you believe Plum today.

You honestly baffle me just as much. Weren't you the one who asked me about tomorrow and the contradiction?

And this makes less sense considering that myself and chaco both claimed to the kill on Start.

That's a good point - I see what Kunk was getting at here. It won't make little sense for Cult to rezz you as either Town or Murderer, but you almost definitely are not Cultist because of the start kill. If you're alive tomorrow, things are not looking good for Plum.

And back in Kunk's scenario, I'd mark the rezzer as illogical, Plum as a murderer, and farside as town/murderer.

[farside22]

I don't get you at all. Why are you giving excuses for tomorrow if you believe Plum today.

You honestly baffle me just as much. Weren't you the one who asked me about tomorrow and the contradiction?

And this makes less sense considering that myself and chaco both claimed to the kill on Start.

That's a good point - I see what Kunk was getting at here. It won't make little sense for Cult to rezz you as either Town or Murderer, but you almost definitely are not Cultist because of the start kill. If you're alive tomorrow, things are not looking good for Plum.

And back in Kunk's scenario, I'd mark the rezzer as illogical, Plum as a murderer, and farside as town/murderer.

I didn't hear a noise. I see most people believe Plum over myself and the noise situation. I know since I didn't hear a noise that I will be alive. So anyone giving the WIFOM on this makes my sensor go up. I have already asked repeatedly not to rez me. If anyone believes Plum tomorrow once I'm alive I'm going to be even more suspicious about it. I am betting with some of the nay sayers that Plum will flip cultist.

[Furcolow]

i am going to see if rewq455 is more insane than me tonight
i have 1 insanity, and he has claimed 0 I believe.

[rewq455]

I will search for occult books tonight.

[kunkstar7]

I didn't hear a noise. I see most people believe Plum over myself and the noise situation. I know since I didn't hear a noise that I will be alive. So anyone giving the WIFOM on this makes my sensor go up. I have already asked repeatedly not to rez me. If anyone believes Plum tomorrow once I'm alive I'm going to be even more suspicious about it. I am betting with some of the nay sayers that Plum will flip cultist.

Farside, it comes down to this, if you are dead, then Plum is town. If you are not dead, you are likely town and Plum will be lynched. Its lovely when things are simple like that =)

Also you of all people know that we can't possibly know whether you did or did not hear noise, so discussing what the options regarding tomorrow are (which you deemed "WIFOM") is viable, so I don't understand why it "makes your sensor go up."

So, Magua is the lynch for today now that Dram lost his action, with DGB, me, and Elli robbing?

i am going to see if rewq455 is more insane than me tonight
i have 1 insanity, and he has claimed 0 I believe.

Yes, do this.

[DrippingGoofball]

OK so whose graves are we robbing?

[kunkstar7]

In fact, I don't like the grave robber coming up with the grave robbing plan. So, new plan is:

Elli robs evilsnail, wicked
DGB

Magua

robs EK, wicked
kunkstar robs EK, Evilsnail

[farside22]

I will do something that doesn't gain me a sanity.

[rewq455]

@kunkstar- Why should we lynch Magua and not DGB?

[Magua]

Elli robs evilsnail, wicked
Magua robs EK, wicked
kunkstar robs EK, Evilsnail

Is this the "official" grave robbing plan (from #2612, pg 105)?

[Magua]

So, Magua is the lynch for today now that Dram lost his action, with DGB, me, and Elli robbing?

Hold up. When did this happen? I skipped over this until I saw rewq's question, and then went back. I see a post from VP (#2630) with concern about the DBG lynch, but that's it.