Lay of Leithian Mafia: Game Over!

[Iecerint]

Aren't there three Silmarils such that CCing would pretty much be useless?

(Since when are protective roles not in large themes?)

Vote Count 2 - 07: Lynch

Nachomamma8 - 1 - Jack
J-Scope - 4 - Budja, SpyreX, Cobalt, Starbuck
FeFiFoFum -

8

- J-Scope, curiouskarmadog, Steam-Powered Shovel, Elscouta, MehPlusRawr, Iecerint, ooba, SocioPath
Elscouta - 2 - Cyberbob, FeFiFoFum

Not Voting (7): Drippereth, Papa Zito, xvart, Anon, Nachomamma8, SensFan, Kmd4390

With 22 players alive it'll take 12 to lynch and 11 to no-Lynch.

[Papa Zito]

Aren't there three Silmarils such that CCing would pretty much be useless?

(Since when are protective roles not in large themes?)

Game rule 2 says "The Silmaril". To me "The" = "One and Only".

Also sarcasm.

[FeFiFoFum]

okay I'd like to come clean....


I am the watcher but I dont have the silmaril.
I did watch j-scope and no one targeted him.
I made up that he targeted farside just to go with my suspicion that since no one targeted J-Scope at night there was a chance that he could be scum.
I didn't expect the Voyeur to come out and make a CC, so i didn't expect my town gambit to oust another town role. FAIL
It seems to me that J-Scope targeting Jack from the information gained has given some legitablity to the fact he could be town as well.

Reactions in the whole shebang from many people should be looked at, as well as opportunistic votes from different people.

Sorry for the terribad play.

[Iecerint]

Ah, OK.

I think there's already enough of an implicit contradiction in the existing claims that a Silmaril CC is unnecessary.

[Iecerint]

lolwat.

Jack, does he often do this sort of thing?

[SocioPath]

Oh shit I forgot this is a large theme. There are never protective roles in large themes. Dammit. You're right about the big target thing.

Oh shit I forgot this is a large theme. Sane cops always claim on D2 when they have a guilty verdict, because there are always protective roles in large themes. Dammit. You're right about the big target thing.

[ooba]

I made up that he targeted farside just to go with my suspicion that since no one targeted J-Scope at night there was a chance that he could be scum.

Wow...

P.S: You were telling the truth about your Sim ability - "that you can track who the person targets too?"

[Jack]

I feel like SpyreX is lurking today. What were you thinking about when you voted J-Scope?

[J-Scope]

Papa Zito, no Silmaril-fishing. If he does hold the Silmaril, then he could still easily be scum.

Oh don't be so lame. If someone else holds it then he's caught in a lie that no amount of crazy role shenanigans can explain away.

You too SocioPath.

he's already been caught in numerous lies? how many does he need to be caught in.

his whole explanation of why he did it is obviously bullshit and he needs to die.

[FeFiFoFum]

no my sims claim is true as well but I dont have the sim yet to use that abilitty

[Drippereth]

My(Elli) gut reaction is that FFFF is town.
Need to think about it a bit more though.

[SpyreX]

I just played catch up on the cluster that is today and woosh.

Unvote, Vote: FFFF

Now, while I am still boggled at the scum-rationale for the play today it just flat out doesn't add up at all - especially unless Jscope is a scum power role on high oobas CC is far, far too high risk/reward.

That, and 859 you're saying you DONT have the Simarillion?

Yee-haw buckaroos.

[FeFiFoFum]

READ 852 EVERYBODY....

[SpyreX]

God I skipped that.

Let me unvoteeee OHHH WAIT A MINUTE HELLS NO YOU BURN

[Drippereth]

READ 852 EVERYBODY....

The DGB half of the hydra concurs.

Oddly as it seems, he's prob town.

And I'm going to say that 70% of the wagon is scum.

[Drippereth]

J-Scope, CKD, Shovel, Elscouta, MehRawer, Icerink, Ooba, SocioPath, SPyreX

Now the job is finding the townie pearls in that heap of rubbish.

[Drippereth]

Unvote

[Steam-Powered Shovel]

Oh DGB/Person I don't know but I assume is similar to DGB, you always have to disagree, don't you?

Do you really find it plausible that FFFF would, after ooba's claim proved him wrong, just lie more instead of coming clean despite still not having a good reason to suspect J-Scope (unless you count no one targetting him at night for some reason)? FFFF's second and third claim are clearly intended to be consistent with what ooba claimed.

Iecerint, in the story Beren manages to steal one of the silmarils from Melkor, so I would assume that we are dealing with just one silmaril.

[Elscouta]

plz lynch FFFF.

kthxbye.

[Iecerint]

FFFF originally just claimed "information" on J. He then escalated his explanation piece by piece as people requested more details. He was probably originally hoping to backpedal out of it with the soft information claim.

If someone who isn't Jack can answer my question, that'd be fine, too.

[SpyreX]

Sorry Drip but while I am -expecting- a town flip this is going down regardless.

[Budja]

Yeah, I feel town-FFFF too but I wish I didn't.
But I also don't think the FFFF-wagon is as scum-laden as Drip. I was fully intending to vote him before I reached this page. Only now am I uncertain.

unvote

[Jack]

Not seeing FFFF as at all town. Barefaced lie != town.

[SpyreX]

Its the fear of "too stupid to ACTUALLY be scum".

No way not lynching but.

[Jack]

Did you read the last couple rounds of U2 SpyreX?