Yeah,Wolf wrote:It isn't just 50% shot at scum though, if we do hit the scumpair we get a doc protect on the town pair for awhile.
What is this I don't even? We would lynch the first lover claim we come across, and one lover from the other pair would claim. If that lover pair is town, they would get protected. If scum, we would know who to lynch the next day.DoItRiley wrote:I think if the only potential problem is that if we get close to lynching a town lover and they claim, the treacherous lover wouldn't have to claim. Meanwhile if the treacherous lover are forced to claim the town lovers can counterclaim and the scum are dunzo.
I've decided this doesn't even make sense. Because if he's including the lovers that makes 14 players and if he isn't that's only 10 players. And there's 12 lol.DarkLightA wrote:
Where the lover couples are:
Trying to look pro-town?Riley wrote:Oh and for anyone who hasn't really been posting anything...a.k.a. Looker, Henry, ksen, Chrono, and easjo...don't come in here being idiotic and jokey/RVS stage junk because there's actual been some serious discussion going on and we don't need any momentum killers bullshitting around.
Softclaim?Nikanor wrote:Hey, I thought we were lovers.Yankee wrote:Vote: Nikanor
Do I need a reason? Plus he hasnt confirmed yet..... noob
I think that the way Riley totally opposed any ideas, it makes him look like scum... Just not open for ideas, you know?Nikanor wrote:DLA, how is this a scum tell?Riley wrote:Yeah okay how about we just not mass claim, sound good?
There was no need for this post.Oh and for anyone who hasn't really been posting anything...a.k.a. Looker, Henry, ksen, Chrono, and easjo...don't come in here being idiotic and jokey/RVS stage junk because there's actual been some serious discussion going on and we don't need any momentum killers bullshitting around.
No I just absolutely despise the boring RVS so I'm attempting to move out of that crap. And DLA it's not worth it because the percentage of scum/town will be higher after we've finished that little plan than how we started. It's best to just let the day run it's course and we'll have better chances.Nikanor wrote:Trying to look pro-town?
^^ THAT, rileyYankee wrote:Actually I was in the middle of posting something about your last post Nikanor about how I didnt understand how claiming lovers today and not lynching them made any sense, but then i thought about it for a minute, and that is like a safety net almost. The town lovers probably wouldnt be NK'ed because that would give away the treacherous lover pair, and even if they were, then we can choose to kill the other lover pair the next day, or just keep scum hunting knowing that the treacherous lover is in that lover group (i would vote to lynch personally). The only drawback I see to this is it may complicate things later on in the game when we get close to lylo, it could pose major problems if we dont lynch a lover pair on day one. But a benefit is that the doctor wouldnt be tied down on protecting a lover on Night 1 which is always a plus.
Yankee wrote:I think it would be a good idea because I honestly dont understand why lovers claiming would be a bad thing the way I have described previously.
XScorpion wrote:Let's assume worst case scenario (which, with your plan, has about 50% probability of occurring - VERY HIGH). We lynch two town lovers today. At night, a townie or doctor dies. Next day, we lynch the other lovers. Another townie/doctor dies. We're now down 5 townspeople, and we only hit 1 mafia. I don't know about you, but I think that a 50% chance of losing FIVE townspeople just to hit 1 mafia is pretty horrible.
DLA...the scum aren't going to care about exposing the treacherous lover because they've just taken out four townies in exchange for one scum. That's a pretty good trade-off for them and a pretty shitty trade-off for us.DarkLightA wrote:^^ THAT, rileyYankee wrote:Actually I was in the middle of posting something about your last post Nikanor about how I didnt understand how claiming lovers today and not lynching them made any sense, but then i thought about it for a minute, and that is like a safety net almost. The town lovers probably wouldnt be NK'ed because that would give away the treacherous lover pair, and even if they were, then we can choose to kill the other lover pair the next day, or just keep scum hunting knowing that the treacherous lover is in that lover group (i would vote to lynch personally). The only drawback I see to this is it may complicate things later on in the game when we get close to lylo, it could pose major problems if we dont lynch a lover pair on day one. But a benefit is that the doctor wouldnt be tied down on protecting a lover on Night 1 which is always a plus.
