Riddle Me This! NY111 - mafia dead - Town wins!

[Thestatusquo]

Ok...I'll try again tomorrow then. Sorry guys. Man I effin' hate school.

[mipe]

On mipe's claim: This supposed extra line at the end could be a number of things. Could state that he secretly wants to be lynched. Could state that he is a neighbour/mason with a couple other players. Could state that he secretly has loyalties to the mafia. Could be anything, and unless he elaborates, we won't find out untill he dies.

Unvote
Vote: RichardGHP

I would say it like this: "If there is another vanilla townie out there, and they haven't deleted their role PM, they can verify what I said"

[PaltryExcuse]

I hate to break this to you, Paltry, but it's Day 1.

To say my posts are "informationless" is just silly, too.

I'm sorry, but the lack of originality coming from you gives no information to the town beyond what we've already heard. You're wordy but there's nothing new when I read you in ISO.

I don't think Paltry or ihim are really very good wagons right now.

Elaborate?

---

@mipe: So Richard isn't a VT in your eyes then? What makes him scum? (A.k.a. why's your vote on him?)

[Korts]

mipe: do you think it's wise, assuming you're telling the truth, to ask another vanilla to out themselves in order to confirm your claim?

[dahill1]

Shea I'll give you the benefit of the doubt since I've played with you before but honestly you've been posting in MD/GD/etc., let's get some game contribution.

Mipe's last post gives me a very very very stupid and somewhat confused townie vibe. Also, I've been definitely getting more town reads from Vas in his last few posts.

Still pushing for ksun..

[FeFiFoFum]

vote count please

[VasudeVa]

vote count please

Your ISO is as cold and barren as my sex life. The only reason I see for you to hang around and post whenever you are prodded is if you are scum. I am very tempted to lynch your ass out of this game. >.>.

[DeathNote]

Vote Count

scotmany12- springlullaby (L-10)
Springlullaby- DizzyIzzyB13 (L-10)
dahill1- Thestatusquo (L-10)
Richard Massive- theopor_COD (L-10)
mipe - PaltryExcuse, VasudeVad, Korts, ksun482, sorasagoof, RichardGHP, inHimshallibe, FeFiFoFum (L-3)
Korts - Quagmire (L-10)
RichardGHP- scotmany12, Mipe (L-9)
ksun482- Shanba, dahill1 (L-9)
sorasagoof- iamausername (L-10)
Paltry Excuse- Anon (L-10)

With 20 alive, its 11 to lynch

Not Voting:

Richard Massive

I am going to set a deadline for one week from today, despite replacement needs.

~What is something that you can keep after you give it?~

[Korts]

FEFIFOFUM: ANSWER ME

[Shanba]

Elaborate?

inHim is giving me townvibes and paltry doesn't strike me as all that scummy.

[inHimshallibe]

scotmany12- springlullaby (L-10)
Springlullaby- DizzyIzzyB13 (L-10)
dahill1- Thestatusquo (L-10)
Richard Massive- theopor_COD (L-10)
Korts - Quagmire (L-10)
RichardGHP- scotmany12, Mipe (L-9)
ksun482- Shanba, dahill1 (L-9)
sorasagoof- iamausername (L-10)
Paltry Excuse- Anon (L-10)

mipe - PaltryExcuse, VasudeVad, Korts, ksun482, sorasagoof, RichardGHP, inHimshallibe, FeFiFoFum (L-3)

Those are good snapshots. I wonder what our numbers are.

unvote
vote: RichardGHP

[Anon]

Elaborate?

inHim is giving me townvibes and paltry doesn't strike me as all that scummy.

Explain clearly why.

More post tomorrow.

[DeathNote]

~The Fonz replaces Richard Massive. Thanks The Fonz!!!~

[mipe]

@mipe: So Richard isn't a VT in your eyes then? What makes him scum? (A.k.a. why's your vote on him?)

Richard is scum or town PR. If he is scum, good for us. If he is town, he gets killed during night anyway (unless something stops the kills).

[RichardGHP]

On mipe's claim: This supposed extra line at the end could be a number of things. Could state that he secretly wants to be lynched. Could state that he is a neighbour/mason with a couple other players. Could state that he secretly has loyalties to the mafia. Could be anything, and unless he elaborates, we won't find out untill he dies.

Unvote
Vote: RichardGHP

I would say it like this: "If there is another vanilla townie out there, and they haven't deleted their role PM, they can verify what I said"

Oh My God, You Suck.

Those are good snapshots. I wonder what our numbers are.

unvote
vote: RichardGHP

If you must vote me, at least explain why.

Richard is scum or town PR. If he is scum, good for us. If he is town, he gets killed during night anyway (unless something stops the kills).

This post is terribad, for two reasons. First, in your eyes, mipe, there is a 50/50 chance of me being a PR or scum. If someone had a 50% chance of being a PR, you should keep them alive until you can prove otherwise. While you shouldn't trust anyone, pessimism is not the way to go. Second, you say if I AM a Town PR, I'll get killed during the night. Well, uh, thanks for telling us that little plan of yours mipe. >.>

[The Fonz]

Hi guys. Will get caught up tonight.

[The Fonz]

I'm as far as page 8, and I've got this to say...

FOR FUCK'S SAKE, SHEA, STOP SAYING EVERY SINGLE THING I THINK! It's making it very difficult to come up with an original point when every time I think 'that seems off' you point out that exact thing five or six posts later.

As of so far, Izzy's clear reluctance to comment on the single biggest event in the game is the biggest scumlead. I'm not doing the vote as you go along thing, though.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

As of so far, Izzy's clear reluctance to comment on the single biggest event in the game is the biggest scumlead. I'm not doing the vote as you go along thing, though.

Which is?

[The Fonz]

It was the dahill wagon. You then responded to it in your first post after Shea points this out. I certainly don't like your leaving your vote on a lurker who is obviously not going to be lynched this late in the day.

I have a strong scum feeling about Shanba. It strikes me that optimal scum play for a 'name' player would be to be in the Shea (ok not recently)/Korts/Cody group in terms of activity, but to slip in a little bit more IIoA than they are doing. He looks and sounds the part, but I don't get the feeling of a sincere attempt to find scum.

That said, if he's scum he could well be bussing (ksun not in significant danger for most of the time he's been sitting there, as a target he feels a little bit arbitrary) and ksun is a decent enough target on his own- he's at least as guilty as mipe of all the things you are on mipe for, but he's made less effort to draw everyone's attention to how bad he's been. So I think I'm going to endorse the only remotely viable counterwagon, and also state that anyone who's a lone vote, and leaves it there, is likely to shoot up my scumrankings. Endorse one or other please, even as a less worse option.

Vote: ksun482

[The Fonz]

*Note: the mipe wagon is a little bit poor imho, and likely has scum on it, but it's not nearly so horrible that i'd prefer a nolynch.

[scotmany12]

Sorry for my absence as of late. I've been having slightly the same problem as shea here, school has been hectic for me this week.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

It was the dahill wagon. You then responded to it in your first post after Shea points this out. I certainly don't like your leaving your vote on a lurker who is obviously not going to be lynched this late in the day.

Would you prefer I wasn't voting for anybody?

[The Fonz]

It was the dahill wagon. You then responded to it in your first post after Shea points this out. I certainly don't like your leaving your vote on a lurker who is obviously not going to be lynched this late in the day.

Would you prefer I wasn't voting for anybody?

Obviously not, and this is a silly strawman. If I'm suspicious of you for wasting your vote on something that's not going to cause a lynch, i'd be even more suspicious of you wasting your vote on something that by definition can't cause a lynch.

What I imagine the correct protown play to be, once you realised you weren't going to get SL lynched today, would have been to look at all the other votes anyone else was pushing, and see which one you could get behind and attempt to drum up a wagon for. By leaving it as a sole vote on a lurker, there's very little there to glean- you can't even interrogate her to provide info for future days, because she isn't here.

Same problem I had with Shanba- I'd expect a decent player such as him, when he realised he didn't like the leading wagon, to make a concerted effort to push a counterwagon, not just go, 'Oh, i guess i should be voting,' vote someone, and leave it there.

[inHimshallibe]

You like ksun better than GHP?

Ok.

unvote
vote: ksun

[DizzyIzzyB13]

It was the dahill wagon. You then responded to it in your first post after Shea points this out. I certainly don't like your leaving your vote on a lurker who is obviously not going to be lynched this late in the day.

Would you prefer I wasn't voting for anybody?

Obviously not, and this is a silly strawman. If I'm suspicious of you for wasting your vote on something that's not going to cause a lynch, i'd be even more suspicious of you wasting your vote on something that by definition can't cause a lynch.

What I imagine the correct protown play to be, once you realised you weren't going to get SL lynched today, would have been to look at all the other votes anyone else was pushing, and see which one you could get behind and attempt to drum up a wagon for. By leaving it as a sole vote on a lurker, there's very little there to glean- you can't even interrogate her to provide info for future days, because she isn't here.

Same problem I had with Shanba- I'd expect a decent player such as him, when he realised he didn't like the leading wagon, to make a concerted effort to push a counterwagon, not just go, 'Oh, i guess i should be voting,' vote someone, and leave it there.

There's plenty of time left. There's no need to get desperate for a lynch yet. Thus, my vote is on the person I believe to be scummiest. If it wasn't on SL, it'd be on no lynch until we get desperate enough that any lynch will do.