Mini 944- Town Suav├® - TAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANK!!!!! (over)

[Parama]

I don't think I could explain it any better than I already have.
Also, on a side note, anyone who has posted less than the mod isn't posting enough. This is a rule for any mafia game.
Glad to finally see some content come from you, but... you're judging people's towniness mostly on activity levels, yet you yourself haven't been very active at all. I mean, your post right here is probably ALL of the content I've see come from you. And it comes off as hypocritical for you to call out those who aren't posting enough.

[Nobody Special]

Okay, Parama, I'll just go back and read you AGAIN. If I have specific questions, you'll answer them, yes?

[SpyreX]

Nikanor: 27

Perhaps the busiest person in this game. Do you guys know my pet theory? No? Well, I'll tell you: scum tend to either lurk profusely OR post so damned much that eyeballs bleed. Guess what? I think Nik is making my eyeballs bleed. Lots of posts, lots of great content, but....still, that red flag is waay up for me.

Parama: 33

Another wall-o-text badguy. Except, this one is reddemed slightly because of actual (gasp!) content AND logic. I like this. (Have I told you the corollary to my Pet Theory? No? Well, here goes: I'm generally wrong about walls-o-text.)

Those two need to be right here, next to each other. Because, there's something fishy afoot.

@SpyreX: Generally, do you believe lynching all lurkers is a good idea? Why or why not?

If I had some bullets I'd be shooting lurkers out of the gate every time.

Lynching? Well, thats tougher and based on about a million factors soo this is a non-question.

[DTMaster]

@SPY

I made a boo boo so I wanted to type in Pink.

Town Cred

Noun.

A player may bus his buddies to gain town cred.

My original interpretation was: scum can defend townies to appear more creditable. So you were right, I am wrong about Parama and Drac scum team. The only thing that makes sense for that argument is: defensive play via a Chainsaw. But I don't like the chainsaw argument.


@Par

Because everybody does scummy things and one small thing doesn't automatically make a person scum.

Lots of small scummy things add up into a scummy read on someone. :{

Also: I posted less then the mod, but I'm pretty sure I've given lots of comments/reads/comments (according to Nobody anyways). Your policy fails against players like me :p

@Nobody
Your summary post is a textbook case of IIoA. I find the lack of scum reads dishearting. It feels like I'm rereading the thread and you're the echo of the common voice. What are your scum-reads specifically.

[SpyreX]

He's got some scum reads, to be fair.

However, they don't make sense in his own framework.

[Nobody Special]

Nikanor: 27

Perhaps the busiest person in this game. Do you guys know my pet theory? No? Well, I'll tell you: scum tend to either lurk profusely OR post so damned much that eyeballs bleed. Guess what? I think Nik is making my eyeballs bleed. Lots of posts, lots of great content, but....still, that red flag is waay up for me.

Parama: 33

Another wall-o-text badguy. Except, this one is reddemed slightly because of actual (gasp!) content AND logic. I like this. (Have I told you the corollary to my Pet Theory? No? Well, here goes: I'm generally wrong about walls-o-text.)

Those two need to be right here, next to each other. Because,

there's something fishy afoot.

@SpyreX: Generally, do you believe lynching all lurkers is a good idea? Why or why not?

If I had some bullets I'd be shooting lurkers out of the gate every time.

Lynching? Well, thats tougher and based on about a million factors

soo this is a non-question.

Bolded part A: I suppose you're the Perfect Mafia Player, who never makes mistakes? Sheesh, I even admiited, right there, for all to see, that I'm usually wrong. Doesn't stop it from raising a red flag for me.

Bolded part B: Way to dismiss the question. I think it's a valid question. Do you also doubt the existence of the Invisible Pink Unicorn?

[Nobody Special]

@Nobody
Your summary post is a textbook case of IIoA. I find the lack of scum reads dishearting. It feels like I'm rereading the thread and you're the echo of the common voice. What are your scum-reads specifically.

Scumiest so far, if you'd bothered to read, is Nikanor.

It's still early in the day, yet. Someone will slip up, sooner or later. (Hopefully sooner.)

[Parama]

Your scummiest read is the claimed town PR.
Good job.

[Nobody Special]

I didn't say I believed him.

[Nikanor]

Perhaps the busiest person in this game. Do you guys know my pet theory? No? Well, I'll tell you: scum tend to either lurk profusely OR post so damned much that eyeballs bleed. Guess what? I think Nik is making my eyeballs bleed. Lots of posts, lots of great content, but....still, that red flag is waay up for me.

Wot.
According to this, I'm scummy for posting too much content. Do you know what the Too Townie fallacy is, NS?
How is that the most noteworthy thing to you so far?
How is that scummier than duckduck's behaviour?
Why aren't you voting me?
Why are you making your connection to Spy so obvious? I think Spy is doing a decent job replacing someone so scummy. It's just so sad that you're giving him away like this.

Unvote. Vote: Nobody Special.

Your scummiest read is the claimed town

bulletproof

PR.

Fixed for you. Hopefully this makes a bit more sense motivation-wise.

[CoheedCambria09]

I am asking to be replaced out of this game. I just do not have the time to keep up wth it dues to school work.

[dramonic]

Your scummiest read is the claimed town

bulletproof

PR.

Fixed for you. Hopefully this makes a bit more sense motivation-wise.

you can still die quite easily.

[SpyreX]

Ohh nobody.

Bolded part A: I suppose you're the Perfect Mafia Player, who never makes mistakes? Sheesh, I even admiited, right there, for all to see, that I'm usually wrong. Doesn't stop it from raising a red flag for me.

Bolded part B: Way to dismiss the question. I think it's a valid question. Do you also doubt the existence of the Invisible Pink Unicorn?

A: You setup a tell in your framework (Posting too damn much). You then say Nik is posting a lot, with a lot of great content but red flag. You THEN PROCEED TO NOT COME TO THE SAME CONCLUSION BASED ON YOUR DATA BY PANAMA WHO IN FACT YOU SAY DOES THE SAME THINGS AND HAS MORE POSTS.

B: Its not a valid question because each game is its own precious flower and thus each lynch has its own set of criteria. On the base level, like I said, I'd shoot them all every time. The lynch, however, is a different beast.

Welp Dram maybe I be wrong up ins. We'll see

Why are you making your connection to Spy so obvious? I think Spy is doing a decent job replacing someone so scummy. It's just so sad that you're giving him away like this.

You take it back mr. TAKE IT BACK

Unvote, Vote: Nobody Special

[MrSuave]

Okay, replacement request noted. I am now currently looking for 2 replacements, if anyone has any good suggestions, then please let me know.

[DTMaster]

@Nobody. I'm going to comment on each person to show you how much your analysis fails in terms of outlining your scum reads. Allow me to begin.

Coheed: Not enough Content
Confidant: Feels Town
DTM: Town
Spy/Duck: Duck didn't do so well. Questions for spy. Duck didn't do so well? As in is he scummy-duck? or Did he just play poorly. No distinction made in the Spy/Duck moment here.
Ken: Needs replacement.
LL: Needs more posts
Muzz: Lots of activity. Looks potentially distraction. Potentially not scum hunting. Wait. Is Muzz scummy or not?
Nacho: Lots of posts. No content. Wait. Is Nacho scummy or not?
Nikanor: Lots of posts. Lots of good content. Scum either lurks or is hyperactive. Wait... did you just finger the

whole town and label them as scum?

. Red Flag on Nikanor? No accusation that Nikanor is scummy, just a red flag.
Para: Wall, plus content, plus logic. Hold on....

Wait a minute: Did Nobody just say he liked DTM and Para for content, but Hated Nikanor for content......... and posts.... and the... eff... ????!!$#.

Also: Did Nobody call Nikanor scummy and he didn't vote his scum read?

EDIT: Spy beat me. His is a Tl:DR version of my post. Except Nobody is as wishy washy as soap suds.

Unvote

Vote: Nobody

I support this wagon.
[/ooc]

[DTMaster]

@Suave
You should ask: KittyMo, Cojin, um post in the Replacement Thread, how about Vi (tell him/her/it Awesomeness known as Spy/DTM/Nikanor/Drac is here)

[SpyreX]

Suave I offered a cross replacement to help your blues out too.

So, we'll see how that goes.

(Is it bad that I get paranoid when something is THAT BAD that its town, every time these days)

[DTMaster]

@Spy
You know the too towny fallacy. It's like the too scummy fallacy.

Paranoia is part of the game, but follow your

heart of the cards

gut and instincts and

[Parama]

I didn't say I believed him.

Do you have a good reason not to?

unvote, vote: Nobody Special

I want to hear muzzz's thoughts on this matter.

[SpyreX]

GOTTEN HIMEL

I beat the drum on Dram and get nothin. This this fast.

I'm gonna lose my mind, I can tell.

[Nikanor]

That's because NS has very clearly contradicted himself. Everyone can agree to lynching that. Not everybody agrees that dramonic's lurking (active or no) is scummy, however. That is why there is a difference in the number of votes they have each garnered.

Just in case you wanted my view on things.

[SpyreX]

Ohh I'm running with it I just think I'm getting too paranoid in my old age.

And today was just one of those days IRL that makes me want to punch a kitten

[Parama]

And today was just one of those days IRL that makes me want to punch a kitten

BWAHAHAHA I get it!

[Nikanor]

Aww. Wanna talk about it?
(Unless you are just luring me closer for an uppercut).

[SpyreX]

I wont derail too much but lets just say running your own business has its ups and its downs. Its been a down stretch.