Mini 922 - Mafia in Mo Town [Game Over]

[Netopalis]

Very well done. Superb play on the mafia side.

[Zachrulez]

Very well done. Superb play on the mafia side.

If it makes you feel any better, I'm still scratching my head about why you got lynched.

[Netopalis]

Me too, oddly enough. I admittedly wasn't at my best here...But really, the case was ridiculously flimsy.

[xRECKONERx]

Whoa, glad my Lowell case didn't pick up steam.

[xRECKONERx]

Forgot to add: FLAWLESS VICTORY

[AlmasterGM]

I nominated Reckoner for town MVP.

[KittyMo]

Whoa, glad my Lowell case didn't pick up steam.

Reading the scum QT, I was imagining you and hito quickhammering Lowell Day 4 "for the win." That would've been really depressing after how hard you worked, lol.

[KittyMo]

[5] No Lynch - (xRECKONERx, hitogoroshi, Espeonage, Lowell, AlmasterGM)

Easiest way to have won this game: lynch everyone on the NL wagon in order...

[xRECKONERx]

Lowell did you breadcrumb traitor?

[KittyMo]

Lowell did you breadcrumb traitor?

From what I noticed, he mentioned fairly often "How do you know there's 3 scum?" and things like that fairly often, and mentioned you and Hito often. Not sure he actually did a breadcrumb, though.

[xRECKONERx]

I had AGM pegged for traitor, hito had Bob and Esponage.

[hitogoroshi]

Wow do I feel stupid. Even after the quickhammer shenanigans I never, ever thought Lowell was the traitor. Jeepers we dodged a bullet with the quicklynch on Nik because I would have pushed for a Lowell lynch with all of my might.

[Lowell]

@reck- did you guys know you had a traitor? God no, I definately didnt' breadcrumb.

I have to say this is the first time I've played as a traitor. VERY frustrating role. The whole time I just wanted a way to scream out to hito and reck that I was on their side... particularly this last day. As soon as I saw how set pikachu was on lynching nik, I figured the only way to make it work would be to lead out on the vote myself and hope they followed. Especially since I felt I was probably the other most likely lynch, and certainly reck and hito would have both happily joined that one as well.

Anyway, good game everyone.

[Espeonage]

That game was alot more fun than my first one. Thanks guys.

[Lowell]

ah nevermind, just read the PMs.

Actually, had I known you guys

knew

there was a traitor I might have played it differently. I might have breadcrumbed... not sure how I would have done that safely though.

In my mind, I was assuming you guys didn't even know there was a traitor, and thus were playing this last day as if it weren't lynch or lose.

[almightybob]

Well done Mafia. Reck had me fooled good. That's twice now. Note to self: If you think Reck is Town, he's scum.

[KittyMo]

>.>

<.<

[DeathRowKitty]

TRACKER
You are the town Tracker! The mafia have infiltrated your town, and you're determined to stop before it's too late. As a hobby, you've taken up

stalking

...errr, tracking people. Each night, you can target someone, and find out who (if anyone) that person targetted. You win when all threats to the town are eliminated, regardless of whether you survive or not.

Please confirm by responding to this PM. The game thread is here: {insert hyperlink to thread}

^ I was destined to get this role.

I was way off day 1. I got my act together a bit night 1 and tracked Reckoner, only to be NKed (and of course I got the PM telling me Reckoner targetted me >.<). Bleh. For what it's worth, Lowell was one of my stronger town reads when I died and Hito was...well...I think 6th or 7th on my scumlist or something like that.

Good game scum. I voted KittyMo for MVP.

[KittyMo]

Suggestions from my Perspective:

AlmasterGM - I think you did an excellent job of showing that you were indeed pro-town. I really don't have any issues with your play besides that you didn't go after hito more when you had figured out he was scum. Also, you were good about not letting the scum realize you were a power role, or you would've been a more likely kill target.

almightybob - I think if you had invested yourself more in the game instead of going with the crowd you could've gotten support for a Lowell-lynch on the final day, which would've been absolutely detrimental for the scum team. So, I'd work on caring more about the game you're playing + lurking less, and better scumhunting and you seeming less suspicious will be helped by that, too.

DeathRowKitty - Being one of the few people to actually catch Reckoner is a great accomplishment! I don't really know what to tell you to work on, besides trying not to die as a power role n1, but that wasn't really something preventable, since the reason you were nightkilled was to not be a good scumhunter...

Espeonage - You were generally pretty good at seeming town, which in this particular game, was extremely helpful to the town. I would just work on scumhunting - realizing what is and isn't a tell. =]

hitogoroshi - You'd better hope I'm never in a game with you where you're scum and I'm town. Your scum playstyle is exactly the kind of style that is easy for me to catch. You clearly have mastered the art of staying under the radar; I don't think I ever had to prod you, yet you lurked constantly. The main thing I would work on is making your scum play more like your town play; you're easy to meta.

Lowell - Your play was just generally funny to watch. You caused a heck of a lot of problems within the town by being completely wacko, and somehow everyone still thought you were town. Your play was pretty risky, though, and thus had chances of backfiring at some points. (Especially with the hammer on Neto and the vote on Nikanor.) I would generally just consider how much of a risky your actions were.

MonkeyMan576 - Just generally work on your logic and scumhunting, IMO. I don't think your lynch was all that deserved, and though I could see why you wanted to claim JOAT, it definitely sealed the deal for your lynch. Don't do that.

Netopalis - I think you played pretty well. Day 1 didn't go that well for you. Then, you discovered Lowell was scum. When you pointed this out, everyone suddenly started pushing your lynch extremely hard. I just...really don't understand your lynch.

Nikanor - Basically the same as Almightybob. If you'd cared more about what was going on/were paying more attention, I bet you would've scumhunted better and have been better at finding scum.

Sakako - For some reason your playstyle reminds me of my own... Anyways, it seemed like you caught Reck as scum mostly on gut, so like me, you've got a good gut. Unfortunately, I haven't figured out what to do about that yet either, since people don't generally listen to reasoning that's based on gut. I think you should mostly keep playing games, and keep working towards figuring out scum tells.

xRECKONERx - Awesome job. Lol. Only thing I can really nitpick is that I've heard your scum and town meta greatly differ.

Zachrulez - Only I know how to meta. No, seriously, don't overuse meta arguments. That was your main problem, I think. And learn what kind of lurking is scummy and what isn't, and I think you're good to go.

[xRECKONERx]

Well done Mafia. Reck had me fooled good. That's twice now. Note to self: If you think Reck is Town, he's scum.

I've been told when people think I'm scum, I'm town. And when people think I'm town, I'm scum. Will work to change that.

[Nikanor]

I now have all of Reck's meta tells documented in my notes. Excellent.
I'm watching you next game, Reck.

[KittyMo]

2nd Place goes to...

DeathRowKitty, Zachrulez, & xRECKONERx

1st place goes to...

AlmasterGM & Nikanor

Yeah, large amount of ties in that category...

1st place goes to...

xRECKONERx

2nd place goes to...

KittyMo

and no, I didn't self-vote

1st place goes to...

xRECKONERx

[Netopalis]

2st place?

[KittyMo]

2nd

[xRECKONERx]

Whoo! Thanks guys =D