Left 4 Dead Mafia - Day 6?

[jmj3000]

@jmj: Who's your top suspect?

I am always suspicious of lurkers, and I realize thats me in effect doing pot calling kettle black. Next, I am suspicious of all the people who speculated about the set-up. That does nothing except help scum by telling them what we do and don't have in town. Now, I'm going to weigh in on a couple of things that everyone else has already passed over.

Concerning DN asking for a sample Town PM:
I find it slightly suspicious that he would ask for a town PM. Its not enough to me to vote him, but it is enough for me to FoS him.

Concerning Charlie and his comment:
That had to be one of the stupidest comments to make. To me, that seems like a huge scum-slip.

I will post more thoughts after I wade through the multiple pages of set-p speculation that stagnated conversation.

[Pomegranate]

Been busy recently, and internet was down for a couple days- will post decently tomorrow.

[Glork]

I don't really get how Glork came to the conclusion that "I've clamined vanilla or anti-town" part. Mostly on the anti-town part. Aside from that, I think his long post is decent.

Unvote

If you believe that the town as a whole is powerless, and if you are protown, then it stands to reason that you have no powers.

[Socrates]

posting from my phone. I will have more to say once I have better access, but right now I would just like to ask if everyone on the deathnote wagon still feels that deathnote is the best lynch for today.

Also, the people not voting should throw out a vote.

[Charlie]

Brilliant deduction there, Glork. Now how about explaining the anti-town part?

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Brilliant deduction there, Glork. Now how about explaining the anti-town part?

Uh, because if you were scum you wouldn't claim scum, would you?

Well, maybe

you

would. But typically, scum do not claim scum.

[jmj3000]

Hey everyone, just checking in before catching the shuttle downtown to watch the St. Pats parade. I will post more of an analysis later today after I get done watching the parade and spending time downtown. Happy St. Pats Day.

[almightybob]

I voted for Ifrinn because he wants to line people up to take an item

That was Socrates' suggestion in Post 51.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

And Scorates has been consistently opposed to Ifrinn, in his own jerkish, anti-town kinda way.

[Glork]

Brilliant deduction there, Glork. Now how about explaining the anti-town part?

Obviously you'll claim to be protown (and thus vanilla), but I certainly won't take that claim at face value.

I currently *believe* that you are protown, but that's a far cry from you being confirmed as being protown.

[The AI Director]

Starbuck replaces Fongoid.

Francis

: I'm getting tired of these damn vampires!

Bill

: They're ZOMBIES, Francis.

The Fifth Vote Count of Day One

Ifrinn (6): Dr.Cyanide, Socrates, Anon, DocPotter, thatguy00, Glork
Pomegranate (1):

xofelf

DeathNote (4): Ifrinn, almightybob, bv310, Tarhalindur
bv310 (1): Pomegranate

Not voting (6): DeathNote, jmj3000, Starbuck, DizzyIzzyB13, Charlie, Amished

[The AI Director]

Your group of rag-tag survivors has made it this far with nothing except sheer wit and brains, narrowly avoiding being mauled by a few zombies who happened to pop out of the darkness. You know what would help you see in the dark? A

flashlight

... and, wait a minute! Lo and behold, there's one sitting on plain sight! Better get it quick...

The

flashlight

is up for grabs! 25% of the player list is eligible to reach for it so that would be

four players

! If you'd like to reach for it, you must publicly type

Grab: Flashlight

!

[Starbuck]

Grab: Flashlight

[Starbuck]

And hi guys.

I'll be catching up shortly.

[Glork]

Meh, why not.

Grab: Flashlight

[Glork]

Also, it should go without saying that nobody should try to grab more than one item in a given day. If they can't use both items in the same night, and they get nightkilled, we probably lose the unused item.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Grab: flashlight

[Charlie]

Better get it quick? Okay...

Grab: flashlight

[almightybob]

Also, it should go without saying that nobody should try to grab more than one item in a given day. If they can't use both items in the same night, and they get nightkilled, we probably lose the unused item.

Wrong. The unused item would be returned to the Town, as per Rule 3.

And I see I've been ninja'd by Charlie. Oh well.

[Glork]

You're right, Bob. I should have read the rules more carefully. My apologies.

[Socrates]

re: Ifrinn's response

Restating a series of events and then saying LOL doesn't qualify as a defense, I'm afraid I must inform you.

Also, I find it ridiculous that you are still hiding behind a need to consult with your other head in order to get out of contributing. Pray tell, where is the glorious insight from this other mystery head that you keep needing to talk to? At what point can we actually expect you to take a firm stance on anything?

Anon. In reference to why my vote is still on DN. I consider there to be a difference between chaotic evil and lawful incompetant evil. Be he town or be he scum, why would he have asked for a sample town pm? When rationally as town or scum you know your going to get into trouble for asking that question. So to me its WIFOMesque and only drawback for me is whether scumDN would be brave enough to pull off such a bold move. And this i have little doubt over if you reference X's - 100 mafia.

When something doesn't make sense for someone to do as any alignment, guess what that makes it? NOT ALIGNMENT INDICATIVE. You are explicity voting for someone for a nulltell. The scummyness, It astounds me.

(By the way, is this Farside?)

[Socrates]

Charlie's "scumslip' does not excite me. I wonder whether or not the town might take my thoughts the wrong way quite often.

The pressure on TG is interesting, but he dropped one of the secret town tells I was looking for earlier, though it was admittedly a weak one. He also seems like the type that doesn't know how to handle pressure regardless of alignment.

And Scorates has been consistently opposed to Ifrinn, in his own jerkish, anti-town kinda way.

You see, this is the pot calling the white china black. In what way are the shenanigans I pulled earlier anti-town, Mrs. Active lurker?

Are you still happy with your deathnote vote, Dizzy? How do you feel about his response? What do YOU think if Ifrinn? Who is your biggest scum read outside of those two? Why?

[almightybob]

The pressure on TG is interesting, but he dropped one of the secret town tells I was looking for earlier, though it was admittedly a weak one.

What is it with you and expecting Town to trust you about things you won't tell us?

What do you think of the point I brought up in post 257? Thatguy claims he is voting Ifrinn for lining up people to grab items, when in fact it was you that did that, back in post 51. So he's voting Ifrinn for a reason that's incorrect. Is that on your secret Town tell list?

[Socrates]

The pressure on TG is interesting, but he dropped one of the secret town tells I was looking for earlier, though it was admittedly a weak one.

What is it with you and expecting Town to trust you about things you won't tell us?

What do you think of the point I brought up in post 257? Thatguy claims he is voting Ifrinn for lining up people to grab items, when in fact it was you that did that, back in post 51. So he's voting Ifrinn for a reason that's incorrect. Is that on your secret Town tell list?

Is being wrong a scumtell?

(.oN :rewsnA)

[Glork]

Starbuck replaces Fongoid.

Francis

: I'm getting tired of these damn vampires!

Bill

: They're ZOMBIES, Francis.

The Fifth Vote Count of Day One

Ifrinn (6): Dr.Cyanide, Socrates, Anon, DocPotter, thatguy00, Glork
Pomegranate (1):

xofelf

DeathNote (4): Ifrinn, almightybob, bv310, Tarhalindur
bv310 (1): Pomegranate

Not voting (6): DeathNote, jmj3000, Starbuck, thatguy00, Charlie, Amished

You have thatguy00 listed twice, and DizzyIzzy isn't listed at all.

Unvote, Vote: DizzyIzzy

I don't like Ifrinn's play, but I don't feel so strongly anymore about him being protown. He/They might just be (an) idiot(s).

Dizzy is probably scum, though, and should be lynched posthaste.