Mafia 110: Mafia in Hell, Michigan (Tied.)

[Ythan]

You posted content in iso 2 but you were just answering RQs and recycling other people's points. In 3 you ask one question. I don't count accounting for your own lack of attentiveness in your previous post. Spam until 8, which is just an affirmation of your vote. In 10 it seems you can't read posts in the thread, and that's not a slight at your reading comprehension, which is even worse than not contributing your own. Vague advice in 11 with no actual hunting. More spam until 19 the next day when you vote. 20 is fluff. 21 and 22 are spam. 23 is no content. Fluff until 26 where you vote again with no content. In 27 you recycles cases again. And now we're here. The fact that this post is so short is itself a testament to your lack of contribution.

Now, want to keep going on this road?

[Riddick]

I need to get going. I'm going to put the notes I have now and finish later.

MoleStargazer - I like how mole calls out crypto in his big post but I don't know if I agree with the reasoning. I really don't like mole's vote on horror at the ends. Just a meh whatever vote. I do have to say I really like how he looks at those who voted for horror, their reasoning and it's part of my feel on jbernier in there. His vote on NS slips him back to mmmm statist.
Mole has moments that make me cheer and then his vote at the end makes me not so thrilled with his play. He hasn't said anything today on who he finds scum so he's someone I just need to watch.

WRP_Beater - VI (aka the easy lynch for scum) he'll be around giving nothing to the game.

Kison replacing ace5993 - ace gives nothing but lurkerish tell. Why did you think musher's contribution is terrible?
Why is lowell lurking/catching up comments fos worthy but ray is voted on?
After reading kison's catch up post I noted he never said who he thought is scummy. His vote on WRp basically what really?
I get scummy vibes from kison. He's going for the lazy or the VI. I just don't see anything he post coming from someone who is town.
His vote from ray (lurker) to WRP (VI) is just scummy. He has no real scum hunting reason's and this is mostly a scum tell for me when someone keeps themselves from telling too much of who they find scum so they can't backtrack later.

i have to ask why you don't consider wrp scum in any of this, you seem to be certain he's town, for no apparent reason other than the fact he's a VI.

[Riddick]

Is something wrong?

Nah, just some of the stuff you're attacking with seems a little bit off, but your lack of experience explains it p well. Not a problem, was just curious.

[Riddick]

It's a shame pman is too active to replace.

his posts at the end of the day lean me towards overenthusiastic townie or mastermind scum (i.e. the stuff saying how badly he wanted horror to be his first scum lynch, and stuff like that) so i get a townieish read for that alone

[Ythan]

I don't think it indicates mastermind-if-scum.

[pman5595]

You posted content in iso 2 but you were just answering RQs and recycling other people's points. In 3 you ask one question. I don't count accounting for your own lack of attentiveness in your previous post. Spam until 8, which is just an affirmation of your vote. In 10 it seems you can't read posts in the thread, and that's not a slight at your reading comprehension, which is even worse than not contributing your own. Vague advice in 11 with no actual hunting. More spam until 19 the next day when you vote. 20 is fluff. 21 and 22 are spam. 23 is no content. Fluff until 26 where you vote again with no content. In 27 you recycles cases again. And now we're here. The fact that this post is so short is itself a testament to your lack of contribution.

Now, want to keep going on this road?

I don't care whether we keep going down this road or not. You have no right to dictate how a persons posts should and should not be. You are not the all knowing leader. You are no more significant in this game than I am.

I am scum hunting how I want to scum hunt. If it bothers you, tough.

[jbernier93]

CAN WE NOT GET INTO THIS BICKERING THING AGAIN? SERIOUSLY, PEOPLE HAVE THE RIGHT TO MAKE WHATEVER COMMENTS THEY WISH TO MAKE, BUT LET'S NOT GO BACK AND FORTH WITH ONE-LINERS.

With that being said, I don't like how pman completely brushes off Ythan's analysis of his posts that reveals that he has posted very very little content in the game.

But regardless.

Fine.

Dr. Cyanide - seems pretty pro-town, has made some good posts

Comments on this? I only ask because, uh, I really do not see the "good posts".

At the time his posts seemed fairly town, IMO. Obviously this was a rather incorrect read.

[Ythan]

I have every right to criticize your posting if, when, it interferes with the game. If you're not going to even right it from here on then you have no basis to complain.

[Ythan]

At the time his posts seemed fairly town, IMO. Obviously this was a rather incorrect read.

Can you clue us in on some factors that contributed to this read?

[jbernier93]

At the time his posts seemed fairly town, IMO. Obviously this was a rather incorrect read.

Can you clue us in on some factors that contributed to this read?

I would if there were any specific ones I could point to... sorry, I didn't really develop much of a read on him.

[Ythan]

Surely you remember which posts you considered good.

[Kison]

Why is lowell lurking/catching up comments fos worthy but ray is voted on?

Because Ray is not posting, after having ample time to get up to speed. Lowell

is

posting, at least. And I also have a slight idea of Lowell's meta because I have played with him in the past. Vote = incentive to post.

After reading kison's catch up post I noted he never said who he thought is scummy. His vote on WRp basically what really?

An incentive to post content.

I get scummy vibes from kison. He's going for the lazy or the VI. I just don't see anything he post coming from someone who is town.
His vote from ray (lurker) to WRP (VI) is just scummy. He has no real scum hunting reason's and this is mostly a scum tell for me when someone keeps themselves from telling too much of who they find scum so they can't backtrack later.

Votes are used for more than getting people lynched. Right now we have an abundance of people who just aren't doing anything useful. Instead of writing them off as useless, you do something about it, rock the boat, and get them talking. That's exactly what I'm going for.

[Kison]

The above is quoting farside22.

[Ythan]

Finished up in the other thread. I'll continue here when I'm around next.

[pman5595]

my only posting when necessary is interfering with the game? really. Yeah I don't think so.

I'm going to continue exactly how I was.

/argument

[Ythan]

You go on being unhelpful, anti-town, then, it will come around to you.

[pman5595]

I would respond, but the argument ended with my last post.

[Ythan]

I would think he'd want to display pro-town behavior. Oh well, there seems to be a vig out there.

[pman5595]

I don't think the vig would waste a kill on me.

[Ythan]

Common vig play is to kill anti-town but not overtly scummy players.

[pman5595]

let me rephrase that.

I don't think the vig SHOULD waste a kill on me.

[farside22]

i have to ask why you don't consider wrp scum in any of this, you seem to be certain he's town, for no apparent reason other than the fact he's a VI.

It's how I read him. Everything he has done has been wow really dumb. I don't see scummy I see nothing useful. His lynch is being pushed because he is doing nothing to defend himself.

[farside22]

At the time his posts seemed fairly town, IMO. Obviously this was a rather incorrect read.

Can you clue us in on some factors that contributed to this read?

I would if there were any specific ones I could point to... sorry, I didn't really develop much of a read on him.

Gee I wonder why this guy has been screaming scum to me.

[Ythan]

let me rephrase that.

I don't think the vig SHOULD waste a kill on me.

And why is that?

[farside22]

@kison: Who is scum to you and why?