Mafia 110: Mafia in Hell, Michigan (Tied.)

[Ythan]

Here's what I was looking for.

Glad the Richard issue was cleared up. And dead scum too!

Perfect tell, commenting on the obvious. You mostly appear town, but IGMEOY.

Morning all...
So Richard is gone and so is Crypto.
One townie, one mafia.
Not bad for a night 1...I guess. Although I could have done without seeing a townie PR gone so quickly. I am going to re-read day one and come up with a more substantive post a little later.

Nothing.

This is also an interesting piece of that particular puzzle if you didn't see.

[Nobody Special]

Mod, I voted for NS.

Yes, that fallacy that 1 bit of wrongness in a post makes its entirety incorrect.

You also ignored parts of my post.

Sorry, I'll check back on it and see what I missed.

And you never commented on your voting pattern related to horrordude. Only 3 posts about him yesterday, a vote, an unvote, and then a vote again.
First, horrordude is terrible.
Then, he is defin town.
And then you vote him just because of annoying bickering.

Note that I didn't hammer horrodude for being (or appearing) scum; I hammered because I thought it would be in the best intereest of Town to end that garbage and move on. I still think Beater could be scum.

And today, you fail to show any sort of commitment that comes with a vote, or even an FoS.
Even yesterday, you showed little commitment on your WRP vote once the Mod decided to add it to the vote count.

I haven't committeed today as the day is still young.

Your opinion on SK's opinion on WPR_Beater is also bad. If you believed what you said, why did you ask him why he FoSed instead of voting?

I explained this already -- I wanted to know StK's position on policy lynching. Asked and answered.

You seem to go after the lousiest "tells", despite your experience in Mafia, and seem to be playing much more different than those other games you've flipped town in.

Despite my 'experience' in Mafia (and thanks for the vote of confidence!), this is my first Large Game, and I feel like I'm floundering a bit.

I'm satisfied with my vote.

I'm so happy for you.

I still have to catch up on this page. Please bear in mind, if you happen to be following my mafia games, I'm doing more than just mafia right now. (I may actually have a date tonight! That's surely a rare occurence...for me, at least.)

[molestargazer]

@Jb - Could you please point out which posts of WRP's indicated to you before your vote for him in ISO19 that he had no intention of playing, and why?

[Ythan]

Congrats! Hot date will take your mind off a stretched neck.

[jbernier93]

@Jb - Could you please point out which posts of WRP's indicated to you before your vote for him in ISO19 that he had no intention of playing, and why?

His last post before that made no sense. He made no effort to respond to anything going on in the thread between that point and my vote. And he has since continued his behavior.

[farside22]

JB: I would love to see an actual case on Ythan instead of the post saying it's not going anywhere.

ythan: What happened from saying Jb is a solid lynch for tomorrow to going after WRP?

[farside22]

Unvote Vote Nobody Special

too. WRP_Beater seems to be getting no support as a wagon but this is pretty good too.

Why do you think NS is a pretty good wagon? Who are your top 3 scum suspectes?

[Ythan]

ythan: What happened from saying Jb is a solid lynch for tomorrow to going after WRP?

From whom?

[Riddick]

Here's what I was looking for.

Glad the Richard issue was cleared up. And dead scum too!

Perfect tell, commenting on the obvious. You mostly appear town, but IGMEOY.

Morning all...
So Richard is gone and so is Crypto.
One townie, one mafia.
Not bad for a night 1...I guess. Although I could have done without seeing a townie PR gone so quickly. I am going to re-read day one and come up with a more substantive post a little later.

Nothing.

This is also an interesting piece of that particular puzzle if you didn't see.

Can we hang him yet? Pretty please???

[Ythan]

Can we hang him yet? Pretty please???

Preaching to the choir.

[farside22]

In regards to Jb:

Makes sense. I'll definitely keep this in mind once NS is dead.

In regards to WRP

He can be scum tomorrow. Today NS is scum.

Your seeming to give yourself a lot of people to line up lynches with for tomorrrow.

[Riddick]

Unvote Vote Nobody Special

too. WRP_Beater seems to be getting no support as a wagon but this is pretty good too.

Why do you think NS is a pretty good wagon? Who are your top 3 scum suspectes?

For the reasons/inconsistencies I've outlined but

To summarise them:
He was busy/lurked through day 1, no real difference which as it can't be proven but his lack of contribution is scummy.
Hopped on the horror wagon w/o ever mentioning him before hand. Said horror was getting worse and worse, despite having never expressed suspcioun of him before hand.
Came out saying he thought Ythan was town/had him as a scum read in the same post- Shows he's making things up as he goes along (imo a scum mindset) or has a bad memory.
Some of his scum-hunting has been bad (using a 7 minute simul post as the sole focus of his case(
Hasn't answered all questions levelled at him
Also the quote Ythan just showed was very interesting. Ythan is suspicious for something he himself did...that's just ridiculous.

WRP_Beater is my second choice, as previously indiciated (I thought I was voting for him, actually). Jbernier is 3rd on a gut scum read, plus her play lately has been bothering me.

After that

[Nobody Special]

I still have to catch up on these last two pages.

Fixed.

[Ythan]

In regards to Jb:

Makes sense. I'll definitely keep this in mind once NS is dead.

It was a point that simply paled in comparison to what we have on NS.

In regards to WRP

He can be scum tomorrow. Today NS is scum.

This was more "Focus on NS today."

[Rikenslope]

Here's what I was looking for.

Glad the Richard issue was cleared up. And dead scum too!

Perfect tell, commenting on the obvious. You mostly appear town, but IGMEOY.

Morning all...
So Richard is gone and so is Crypto.
One townie, one mafia.
Not bad for a night 1...I guess. Although I could have done without seeing a townie PR gone so quickly. I am going to re-read day one and come up with a more substantive post a little later.

Nothing.

This is also an interesting piece of that particular puzzle if you didn't see.

Even though I don't like Ythan (by way of thinking he is scummy or at least a bully (anti-town)) I must concur with his logic against NS. It seems solid and until NS comes up with an explanation.

Unvote
Vote: NS

[Ythan]

How anti-town is it if you like the results?

[Nobody Special]

Okay, I finally get the quote thing about me & Rikenslope. I didn't say anything when Riken said the same thing Ythan said. (Hey, I never said I was quick.) Truth is, Rikenslope is way low on my radar. I just didn't notice it.

Big Post coming.

[jbernier93]

JB: I would love to see an actual case on Ythan instead of the post saying it's not going anywhere.

I made my case when I voted?

[Rikenslope]

Arguing that a point is not good because it comes from someone you're voting is patently ad hom.

Your words not mine.

[Nobody Special]

NS didn't mention horrordude untill he voted him on Day 1. I don't see any time he expressed suspicioun of horrordude before this. if there was could you point it out? Also what changed your mind on him? Is there one particular post or was it a number of things?

1. SaintKerrigan
4. WRP_Beater
6. RichardGHP

9. horrordude0215

Dude today, reevaluate cases on Kerrigan, Beater, and Richard tomorrow?

As much as it physically pains me to agree with Ythan, I do.

unvote
vote horror

He just keeps getting worse.
I'm not happy about Rikenslope's sudden jump onto the Beater wagon, either.

^^ this post is the first time I can find him mentioning him. if he 'keeps getting worse' surely you'd have noted the fact he was bad before?
(I ctrl _f'd horror in your posts to make sure i hadn't missed a reference)

I didn't mention horrodude until voting because he was only on my periphery. But he did just keep getting worse. Then, I re-thought the whole thing, and placed my vote on Beater. And, as has been said multiple times, I finally got tired of the bickering.

:Perfect tell, commenting on the obvious.

You mostly appear town,

but IGMEOY.

Bolded mind
Same post:

So, I guess this means my top three are, in no certain order:
Ythan
StKerrigan
Unsight
farside

Then that.
Nobody Special can you explain how someone who appears mostly town appears in your top 4 scum reads?? I'm really confused by this.

No, I can't explain that. Brain fart? Too many games? My first Large Game? Hell, I'd vote me right now if that wasn't a scummy thing to do.

Here's what I was looking for.

Glad the Richard issue was cleared up. And dead scum too!

Perfect tell, commenting on the obvious. You mostly appear town, but IGMEOY.

Morning all...
So Richard is gone and so is Crypto.
One townie, one mafia.
Not bad for a night 1...I guess. Although I could have done without seeing a townie PR gone so quickly. I am going to re-read day one and come up with a more substantive post a little later.

Nothing.

This is also an interesting piece of that particular puzzle if you didn't see.

I do not, at all, see what you seem to be implying here. The middle quote isn't even me! Are you implying a scumteam?

I get it now, see my previous post.

[Ythan]

JB's voting Kerrigan now I think. Although he's still holding onto an Ythan lynch for later.

[Ythan]

NS, are you explaining more that one point as a "brain fart"?

vote count please

[SaintKerrigan]

Posting to say that I'm extremely sleep-deprived and cranky from psych tests, so I'm only going to be handling my modding duties today.

[Ythan]

I sure hope you're not lurking now that the heat is on someone else.

[molestargazer]

His last post before that made no sense. He made no effort to respond to anything going on in the thread between that point and my vote. And he has since continued his behavior.

Before your ISO19, he responded to my question about his scummy-looking post (Link), and the one before was asking if people understood his scummy post (Link), clearly responding to the pressure. Before that, there was this. So, I disagree that his posts before your ISO19 didn't make sense, and whilst he won't be up for a scummy for Paragon of Mafia Hunting, he made some small contributions - which makes me wonder why, really, you switched your vote to him in ISO19 other than the fact that he would be an easy target.

What he's done since then is a moot point, that's not what I'm asking about.