Mafia 110: Mafia in Hell, Michigan (Tied.)

[Netopalis]

Official Vote Count

Players needed to lynch: 9

JBernier93

- 3 - Farside22, MoleStargazer, Konowa - (L-6)

Nobody Special

- 1 - Ythan - (L-8)

Rikenslope

- 1 - pman5595 - (L-8)

SaintKerrigan

- 1 - Unisght - (L-8)

Ythan

- 2 - JBernier93, Rikenslope - (L-7)

Players not voting: DedicatedScribe, Dr. Cyanide, Kison, Lowell, Nobody Special, RayFrostWikiManager, Riddick, SaintKerrigan, WRP_Beater

Also, apology accepted, Nobody Special, although to be honest I had forgotten entirely about that incident by the time you posted.

[Ythan]

I think it quite possible that someone's going to drag "I am probably going to skim most of it at most. It isn't completely required for my method of scumhunting anyway." up in the future. Not something I'd be so upfront about.

[pman5595]

I think it quite possible that someone's going to drag "I am probably going to skim most of it at most. It isn't completely required for my method of scumhunting anyway." up in the future. Not something I'd be so upfront about.

I don't care.

[Ythan]

That's the spirit.

[Unsight]

@Ythan

Thank you for your analysis of the cases/votes floating around. It was more of an "are you tunneling" check, but I always enjoy hearing others' thoughts on suspects/cases. I just wish I didn't always have to ask.

I think there are a few things I need to go back and reread now.

[Ythan]

I'm doing some rereading as well. NS might be a better lynch than SK today.

I don't really mean

might

, I didn't already move my vote.

[Ythan]

Make that did already.

[Netopalis]

Ythan's 3 posts with broken quote tags have been fixed.

Official Vote Count

Players needed to lynch: 9

JBernier93

- 3 - Farside22, MoleStargazer, Konowa - (L-6)

Nobody Special

- 1 - Ythan - (L-8)

Rikenslope

- 1 - pman5595 - (L-8)

SaintKerrigan

- 1 - Unisght - (L-8)

Ythan

- 2 - JBernier93, Rikenslope - (L-7)

Players not voting: DedicatedScribe, Dr. Cyanide, Kison, Lowell, Nobody Special, RayFrostWikiManager, Riddick, SaintKerrigan, WRP_Beater

[Ythan]

Thanks sweety.

[Kison]

Vote: Nobody Special

- That post of yours reeks of someone trying desperately to find stuff to comment on.

Vote: Nobody Special

[Kison]

Nobody Special, stop ignoring questions. What do you think about the rest of what Unisght said in her post? You discredit it based on one thing that, according to her, had nothing to do with the rest of it.

[DedicatedScribe]

Mod, I voted for NS.

Yes, that fallacy that 1 bit of wrongness in a post makes its entirety incorrect.

You also ignored parts of my post.

[DedicatedScribe]

And you never commented on your voting pattern related to horrordude. Only 3 posts about him yesterday, a vote, an unvote, and then a vote again.

First, horrordude is terrible.
Then, he is defin town.
And then you vote him just because of annoying bickering.

And today, you fail to show any sort of commitment that comes with a vote, or even an FoS.
Even yesterday, you showed little commitment on your WRP vote once the Mod decided to add it to the vote count.

Your opinion on SK's opinion on WPR_Beater is also bad. If you believed what you said, why did you ask him why he FoSed instead of voting?

You seem to go after the lousiest "tells", despite your experience in Mafia, and seem to be playing much more different than those other games you've flipped town in.

I'm satisfied with my vote.

[Lowell]

vote dedicated scribe

I'm going to work on another update post starting w/ D2.

Just briefly perusing the run-up to horror's lynch, posts 929 and 930 sit uneasy with me. Particularly, 929 looks like it was written by someone who had an idea about the lynch scene.

[Unsight]

Lowell makes a case for DS knowing too much. Possible, however I'd like to see the history between you two resolved before I consider that.

This was never answered:

EBWOP:

That was pretty cool by NS, IMO.

Also, pman looks good recently. I guess I can see why folks find others besides horror scummy, but I'm having trouble understanding the objection to his death. He doesn't do much and fidgets like scum, so let's just do this.

He fidgets like scum? how?

[Lowell]

Not sure what you're asking here. Basically I thought horror's defense made him look scummy. He lashed out rather than defended anything he did.

[Unsight]

Not sure what you're asking here. Basically I thought horror's defense made him look scummy. He lashed out rather than defended anything he did.

Going along with that, what is your view of SaintKerrigan's response to my case in Post Subject 997 (Page 40) and the following discussion centered around farside22?

[farside22]

Ythan: Do you believe that Jb's vote on you has some validation?
Lowell: Please expand more on this belief you have on DS. It's very vague.

[molestargazer]

I was simply showing how GHPs statement contradicted himself.

My point wasn't that he contridicted himself about his feelings towards it - my point was your making him look scummy over replying to an attack on him, no matter how fluffy it might have been.

His first posts seemed like he was a noob who didn't know how to play the game quite. Later posts made it seem like he was making no effort at even trying to figure out how to play.

Whether he was making an effort or not, he was still in fact a newb. Your earlier point still stands, that's a contradiction, no?

I had better fish to fry.

Like lynching townies?
My point was, you firstly decided he wasn't, then he was, then decided he wasn't and switched onto horror, who was revealed as town. Seems scummy to me.

93 DAMMIT!

What?

Will catch up on the recent developments shortly.

[Ythan]

Ythan: Do you believe that Jb's vote on you has some validation?
Lowell: Please expand more on this belief you have on DS. It's very vague.

32 Same here. His vote on me was not unreasonable and neither was his explanation for it.

[farside22]

Ythan: Do you believe that Jb's vote on you has some validation?
Lowell: Please expand more on this belief you have on DS. It's very vague.

32 Same here. His vote on me was not unreasonable and neither was his explanation for it.

Why? He's voting for you because basically he thinks your a jerk and bully.
Do you find scum tend to be that way?

Same question to JB. Do you find scum tend to push like that?

Also ythan: I have to say I find it odd you don't see his comment about you pushing a lynch on horror while he sat back and said nothing as a no comment and reasonable response.

[Ythan]

Point. It does seem as if there is enough going on in the thread not to vote for a bully.

[Ythan]

Also ythan: I have to say I find it odd you don't see his comment about you pushing a lynch on horror while he sat back and said nothing as a no comment and reasonable response.

Looking over this.

[farside22]

This for me is a big scum tell.

vote:Ythan

Crypto and Ythan agreed some and fought some yesterday. Lots of interaction between the two until Ythan started pushing the horror lynch way too hard. Crypto put Ythan low on his list. Ythan's bickering with Horror was very anti-town.

If you look he voted himself for horror and for the rest of the day stayed out of the argument but blames ythan for pushing the horror lynch way too hard.
Using Crypto's list saying you were low on his list of suspects is just sad. I can say looking at ythan's post although fun sucker is a word I would use his push, drive and questions doesn't look scummy.
Who stays out of players bickering with each other? Mostly the scum.

[Ythan]

Makes sense. I'll definitely keep this in mind once NS is dead.