Open 203: C/9 Mafia Wins!

[hewitt]

Simulpost

kyle's logic is:
This guy isn't making any worthwhile discoveries.
yours is:
This guy never helps town, whether he's town or not.

Your logic suggests that no matter what lowell does, we should lynch him. Kyle's says that Max is a worthwile lynch for now. There's a huge difference.

If that was my logic I'd still be pushing for a Lowell lynch.

Vote:Kyle99

Vote Count-Sho
Kyle99-Max, danakillsu, Gheb, Kunkstar7, JacobSavage, hewitt
Lowell-kunkstar7, kyle99, danakillsu
danakillsu-Lowell, wdjat
Wdjat-Tatetothetot
Max-the1fifi
Hewitt-Gayle

[danakillsu]

EBWOP:

Post 298 should read:
"hewitt's is:"
instead of "yours is:"

[danakillsu]

If that was my logic I'd still be pushing for a Lowell lynch.

That just means your contradicting yourself. The logic you used in that post still says what I thought is said.

[hewitt]

That just means your contradicting yourself. The logic you used in that post still says what I thought is said.

Now I'm very confused. Are you still under the impression that I want to lynch Lowell even though he claimed cop?

[danakillsu]

Now I'm very confused. Are you still under the impression that I want to lynch Lowell even though he claimed cop?

NO. I'm saying that the logic you used would lead to you lynching lowell under any and all circumstances, but you didn't. That means you contradicted yourself.

[hewitt]

NO. I'm saying that the logic you used would lead to you lynching lowell under any and all circumstances, but you didn't. That means you contradicted yourself.

That's completely inaccurate and doesn't even make sense.

[danakillsu]

But you can't explain why?

[hewitt]

I feel like every game I play with Lowell it's the same story. He doesn't really do anything and then cracks underneath a straw of pressure and lashes out and professes that he's more helpful than X player and that it'd be a mistake to lynch him and we'd be dumb to do that. I know that in every game I've played with him he's been extremely unhelpful and more of a hindrance to the town than anything. A player I would be very scared to see travel far in the game and have in any tight situations.

My past game history with Lowell doesn't affect my read on him this game but I do like to generally lynch weaker players earlier in the game. If there isn't a good lead on scum on D1 then I pursue a weak player lynch until a better option arises.

Incorrect statement. I voted to lynch Lowell because I know he's a weak player and hasn't done anything to change my mind in THIS game. He's someone I would be very frightened to have last far in the game if he is indeed a town player.

It's not advocating a policy lynch based on meta, I believe he's the weakest player in this game and I know from past experiences that he doesn't change after D1. So after the showing he's made this game, cracking under pressure, I know that he's going to continue being a weak player. And again, based on this game, he's not somebody I'd want to travel far in the game unless he is in fact a cop.

I feel like you're purposely ignoring the fact that I've stated that a lynch on a player like Lowell is only prime if there are no good leads on scum. And that I'm pretty sure I've made it clear a lynch like this is not preferable, but it's the best option when there's nowhere else to go.

I do not think Lowell is a moron. I think he's quite the opposite. I think he knows how to further himself in the game whether it's in the town's best interest or not by playing defense.

But you can't explain why?

How about you go explain how I'm contradicting myself. Because I'm clearly not.

[danakillsu]

alright, so you started off saying you want to lynch Lowell early on, then vote for him for the same reasons you want him lynched early on. Then, you suddenly change your mind and say that it's not important to lynch him now.

[hewitt]

alright, so you started off saying you want to lynch Lowell early on, then vote for him for the same reasons you want him lynched early on. Then, you suddenly change your mind and say that it's not important to lynch him now.

I feel like you're forgetting this happened.

I'm a

cop

.

I don't know about you but I don't vote to lynch claimed power roles on D1.

[kunkstar7]

So confused. It looked like dana was defending hewitt, but now its an attack?

Also this:

I feel like you're forgetting this happened.

I'm a cop.

I don't know about you but I don't vote to lynch claimed power roles on D1.

You are misrepresenting hewitt. Although he stated that lowell is never good for town, he didn't say that it made him a viable lynch all the time. He just said it made him a good candidate this time around as we don't have much else for leads. He, along with everyone else, adjusted for lowell's cop claim.

[Wdjat]

Can we lynch danakillsu yet? He's just flailing with this attempt on hewitt. I've seen this exact reaction from a mafia before. Try to buddy up, botch it, try to turn it around into a case.
There's nothing good I can see in his gameplay and his response to my first vote was awful.

[hewitt]

Can we lynch danakillsu yet? He's just flailing with this attempt on hewitt. I've seen this exact reaction from a mafia before. Try to buddy up, botch it, try to turn it around into a case.
There's nothing good I can see in his gameplay and his response to my first vote was awful.

I'm beginning to retract my statement about danakillsu being the only player I see to be town. Town players usually don't flail out with nonsensical cases.

[Lowell]

A lot of hewitt's posts lately are about how much he loves me. I can do without the buddying, thanks.

[danakillsu]

So confused. It looked like dana was defending hewitt, but now its an attack?

I think we're all confused here including me. I wasn't ever trying to defend hewitt, but my analysis of his logic may not have been correct. I'm willing to just drop it, as I don't find any huge significance in it, anyway. But I don't see how being wrong about this really makes me scummier.

[hewitt]

A lot of hewitt's posts lately are about how much he loves me. I can do without the buddying, thanks.

...Really. I'm SO sorry if you ever misconstrued my posts to get that message, that was not ever my intent...at all.

[Gheb]

I think we should just lynch Kyle -_-

[Gayle]

Got prodded in a few games. Give me until tomorrow.

[Max]

Mod Please can you actually make Hewitt officially a player in this game he still isn't in the player list

You know its times like these when banging your head against a brick wall could be appropriate.

[The1fifi]

Ahahaha. lets lynch the mod.

[hewitt]

Mod Please can you actually make Hewitt officially a player in this game he still isn't in the player list

You know its times like these when banging your head against a brick wall could be appropriate.

Oh yeah, forgot about that. Apparently I'm just some random person spamming the thread lol. It'd be kind of nice to actually be recognized as a player.

[JacobSavage]

Totally agree The1fifi, the first step to finding scum, is holding the mod to ransom

[Lowell]

Now that I think of it, what does jacob do? Besides show up for comments like this ^^^?

[Wdjat]

I'm willing to just drop it

Like you dropped your case on me? Man, what have you actually held up?

[Wdjat]

Now that I think of it, what does jacob do? Besides show up for comments like this ^^^?

He's also buddying up to you. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.