Open 205 - Medical Mafia - Game Over Too Soon?

[Mindgamer]

I apologize for my lack of participation in the past few days, but I haven't seen anything useful happen. It's time for a lynch, stalling for the purpose of stalling is a minor scumtell imo. SaintKerrigan, if you have something you have to discuss I propose you do it now and not continue to shout 'moar discussion' instead of thinking about your final vote for today.

I'll post my reads now. In a normal game I would not post my reads on Day 1, because the scum could just kill the player who has the consensus of being town. However, in this setup the scum won't be able to control their kill for the most part.

Assuming DiscoRoboto will be lynched:
Mykonian and Looker are town imo. Early in the day I was strongly attacking them, especially Mykonian, but their replies have convinced me of the opposite.
If DiscoRobot flips scum, SaintKerrigan has a good chance of being scum as well. I don't like his interaction with DiscoRoboto at all.
Phaen has so far only commented on the past, and she is quiet so close to deadline. Not a good sign. In the very surprising situation DiscoRoboto actually flips town, Phaen has a good chance of being scum since she is not contributing at all and let the DiscoRoboto wagon get easy steam.
Bio Hazard, Light, XScorpion: I don't have anything to add that has not already been said. Town or scum, I don't know.

I'm telling you this because I have a decent chance of getting killed tonight, be it the scum or one of the doctors, so you will at least know where I stand on people.

Vote Count #17

DiscoRoboto (3) - Mindgamer, mykonian, Bio Hazard
Light (2) - DiscoRoboto, Phaen
Looker (1) - XScorpion
SaintKerrigan (1) - Looker
Bio Hazard (1) - SaintKerrigan

Not Voting (1) - Light

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

The deadline is the end of March 10th, PST.

[Looker]

ok, guys, where is the information you promised me in stead of lynching Disco, like we should? We are just waiting for the deadline and are letting scum kill the game. Great, isn't it?

There

is

no information to be discussed. What could have been said has already been said and could be said on into twilight. As I've already stated, it was a stall maneuver.

Option 1: StK-Scum/Disco-Scum
StKerrigan is trying to protect Disco and build up a different wagon.

Option 2: StK-Scum/Disco-Town
StKerrigan is utilizing the concept of WIFOM to speed up a Disco lynch, seeing as we weren't "well on our way" to begin with.

Option 3: StK-Town/Disco-Scum
StK has been had by no error of ours and I cannot be held accountable for thinking his stalling is scummy.

Option 4: StK-Town/Disco-Town
We weren't going to lynch scum anyway so what's the difference between a Disco-lynch and a StK-lynch.

At present time, Light because I don't like how he votes, and right now he isn't voting anyone which contributes to no lynch.

Light Yagami over me...?

Only to avoid no lynch because no lynch is disastrous for town. If I can get you lynched I will because I think you are scum but if deadline was right now I would switch my vote.

Yeah, deefinitely using my Quack powers on you tonight, dead weight. Have you considered any of the posts where I addressed your allegations? (And no, the proper response is not: "Yeah, I consider them garbage.")

[XScorpion]

When your responses to my questions are "eggs", I find it hard to respond differently than how you suggest.

[Looker]

They were links explicating my pressure vote on Danny, but you're right. You have every right to vote me and should probably just stay in the background with your vote until whatever is to come actually comes. Sorry for trying to make you post when there's no reason for you to. Enjoy school and study hard, it'll pay off one day, as opposed to playing Mafiascum, which we already know is basically useless and a waste of time.

[Alduskkel]

Phaen has been prodded.

[SaintKerrigan]

Ok, I've gotten enough out of the day.

Unvote: Bio Hazard. Vote: DiscoRoboto.

[Looker]

YAY!

unvote
vote Disco

[DiscoRoboto]

Gonna flip scum, GJ Town. I don't really like being scum any way, sigh, would've hammered myself if Looker didn't do it.

[XScorpion]

WTF at looker hammering before a claim. If Disco is the nurse you deserve to get lynched next.

[XScorpion]

oh rofl
hes scum
my bad

[Bio Hazard]

At this point, I think we need to claim all our targets tomorrow and treat this like a game of Dethy.

[Alduskkel]

Final Vote Count

DiscoRoboto (5) - Mindgamer, mykonian, Bio Hazard, SaintKerrigan, Looker
Light (2) - DiscoRoboto, Phaen
Looker (1) - XScorpion

Not Voting (1) - Light

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

An epic battle of the wits had erupted between the sodas. Each one raised their own arguments, and after a while they agreed on who would be drained of their fizzy goodness.

"Bubble fizz bubble bubble!!" said Mindgamer.

"Ah hah, but fizz fizz gurgle gurgle," said mykonian.

"Gurgle fizz fizz!" said BioHazard.

"Blub blub blub," said SaintKerrigan.

"Fizzzzzzzzzz," said Looker.

"Bubble gurgle gurgle," said DiscoRoboto.

DiscoRoboto,

Mafia Goon

, was lynched Day 1.

It is now Night 1. Please submit all night actions before the end of March 9th (PST). Due to the complicated setup, the Night may or may not last a day or two more.

[Alduskkel]

You all awake from your soda-slumber to find that two of you have been popped. Fortunately, one was the remaining can of Doctor Pepper.

SaintKerrigan,

Normal Doctor

, was killed Night 1.

Light,

Mafia Goon

, was killed Night 1.

TOWN WINS!!!

[Alduskkel]

ROLE REVEAL

mykonian - Quack Doctor
SaintKerrigan - Normal Doctor
Looker - Weak Doctor
Mindgamer - Nurse
XScorpion - CPR Doctor
Phaen - Paranoid Doctor
Light - Mafia Goon
Bio Hazard - Naïve Doctor
DiscoRoboto - Mafia Goon

[CSL]

Woah. Best town ever.

This coming from a spectator.

[Alduskkel]

NIGHT ACTIONS

Night 1

mykonian (Quack Doctor) -> SaintKerrigan
XScorpion (CPR Doctor) -> Light
Looker (Weak Doctor) -> XScorpion
Light (Mafia Goon) -> Bio Hazard
SaintKerrigan (Normal Doctor) -> Bio Hazard
Phaen (Paranoid Doctor) -> Looker
Bio Hazard (Naïve Doctor) -> SaintKerrigan

RESULTS

SaintKerrigan was killed by mykonian.

Light was killed by XScorpion.

Light attempts to kill Bio Hazard, but he is protected by SaintKerrigan.

Looker attempts to weak protect XScorpion, but is blocked/protected by Phaen.

Bio Hazard did nothing of import.

[Leafsnail]

That didn't go just as planned.

Although it was an interesting setup... maybe OP for the town, especially with sanity roleflips.

[Alduskkel]

Mod's Comments

This was an extremely swingy setup. I have no idea if it was balanced or not. If you think about it, just shuffling roles around there could have been 3 night kills on Townspeople. Of course, Light, even with the best results, would probably have been lynched, unless SaintKerrigan was lynched and the night actions gave Light a victory. However Light would have to have been very lucky to get through all that.

Town play was okay, mostly I feel the Mafia self-destructed. Disco Roboto was pretty easily caught, especially considering it was Day 1. Light was not far behind on people's scum lists.

Kind of a fun setup, but again, very swingy.

Leafsnail: Sanities were not set to be revealed on death, I just revealed SaintKerrigan's because the game was over and there was no point in being coy.

[Phaen]

That was the freaking shortest game ever....

I'm kinda glad it ended though because I probably would have been hung on D2 for going AWOL.

[Alduskkel]

You picked up your prod, I'm sure you'd have been fine. If SaintKerrigan and Light had survived though I think SK might have been mislynched.

Also, happy birthday!

Leafsnail: Also, I love your Wayward Vagabond avatar.

[CSL]

Happy birthday, Phaen.

[Phaen]

OP for the town, especially with sanity roleflips.

There weren't supposed to be any sanity roleflips and indeed there weren't any while the game was in session. The "Normal Doctor" reveal happened after the game was over. Might have been a mistake might have been on purpose but it didn't affect the game.

[Phaen]

Thanks for the happy birthdays ~ ♥

I know I picked up my prod but I think I would have been under suspicion for "intentional absence"

[XScorpion]

SCORE!!!!!
I eventually decided Looker wasn't scum and went with the next guy, who was the right choice

[Leafsnail]

Ah, ok. That's a bit better then... still seems a bit swingy, what with the random kills/ blocks flying around. Meh. Light was in some pretty serious trouble anyway... town probably coulda won without roles.

And yes, I like this avatar too. Has a nice deranged feel about it