Mafia 109 - A Glitch in time - Game Over!

[Ythan]

You don't say.

[Maemuki]

...hai guys. Ahm. Nacho's a lurker lynch isn't he? Can somebody explain me why a lurker lynch is better than another lynch? (Please explain it like you would explain it to a 4 year old.)

[Haylen]

Anon, Kmd and Starbuck got prodded.

[Kmd4390]

Nacho, what exactly is your case on me? I don't feel I've lurked nearly as bad as I did on Day 1. I've kept up and been able to make my opinions pretty known. Day 1 was a fluke basically. Your suspicion on me looks more like OMGUS than anything. Oh, and the "cum" typo is pretty amusing.

[Drippereth]

...hai guys. Ahm. Nacho's a lurker lynch isn't he? Can somebody explain me why a lurker lynch is better than another lynch? (Please explain it like you would explain it to a 4 year old.)

(1) Scum lurks.
(2) There's always a scum that escapes detection for many days, by lurking.
(3) Lynching lurkers is pro-town.

[Haylen]

The Haylie Haylie Haylie Vote Count

Dramonic: Ythan
Nachomamma8: camn, SpyreX, Kmd, Drippereth ~
SpyreX: Anon
Ythan: Pulindar

Not Voting: Parama, Nachomamma8, Starbuck, Maemuki,Yosarian2, Weaboo


Lots of Love,
Hayl xxx

~ Pulindar and Parama V/LA's are noted.
~ I still required a big Dramonic hug.

[camn]

...hai guys. Ahm. Nacho's a lurker lynch isn't he? Can somebody explain me why a lurker lynch is better than another lynch? (Please explain it like you would explain it to a 4 year old.)

Lurking IS scummy.. especially in a quick game like this.

Imagine you are scum.
Imagine there is a giant town-town battle.. like Clergyhoops vs. Drippereth.

What is your optimal play?

OBV. Stfu and let it happen.

Also.. lurkers don't get nightkilled.
Lurkers KILL us in endgame.. because we have no read on them. We have no posts to dig through.

Right now, we are ahead. We lynched one scum and have avoided some nighttime carnage. We can afford to try and hit some lurkerscum NOW.

[Nachomamma8]

Well, there's the scum read on Anon that you haven't explained at all, for starters.

And you have improved in your lurking, but you're not nearly active enough to warrant pushing for a lurker lynch.

[SpyreX]

(1) Scum lurks.
(2) There's always a scum that escapes detection for many days, by lurking.
(3) Lynching lurkers is pro-town.

This sums it up decently.

[Kmd4390]

I'll make a full case on Anon later in the game if necessary.

And I don't exactly see how my play can be considered lurking.

[Drippereth]

I see absolutely nothing new.
Nacho is still scum.

[Nachomamma8]

Why can't you explain your suspicions of Anon now?

All the opinions you've had on people thus far have been unjustified/lazy. When you post, you rarely say anything worth reading.

[Kmd4390]

Why can't you explain your suspicions of Anon now?

Too lazy to strongly back a case on a lower suspect.

All the opinions you've had on people thus far have been unjustified/lazy. When you post, you rarely say anything worth reading.

My gut justifies everything.

[Drippereth]

Why can't you explain your suspicions of Anon now?

All the opinions you've had on people thus far have been unjustified/lazy. When you post, you rarely say anything worth reading.

The hypocricy is blinding.

[Nachomamma8]

The hypocricy is blinding.

The hyprocrisy in my pointing out of his?

[Drippereth]

All the opinions you've had on people thus far have been unjustified/lazy. When you post, you rarely say anything worth reading.

[Nachomamma8]

And I don't exactly see how my play can be considered lurking.

All the opinions you've had on people thus far have been unjustified/lazy. When you post, you rarely say anything worth reading.

[camn]

Whatever.
So we lynch both of you.

[Nachomamma8]

Then we just kill lurkers until the game ends, one way or another. Right?

[camn]

No
We kill a couple, and everyone else stops lurking.
Plus you are scum, so that helps too.

[Nachomamma8]

Town lurkers won't stop lurking; thus, neither will the scum lurkers.

[Anon]

Today I felt like repeating myself:

Here is where I am sitting at the moment:

Fact:

Nikanorscum lynched day 1 with some resistance and a possible counterwagon in CSL at some point of the day .

Theory:

Scum never put all his eggs on a basket.

What does this mean?

If we assume 4 scum, which is reasonable with 17 players then I think its extremely possible that there is 1-2 scum bussing and 1-2 scum out of the wagon and very likely defending Nikanor. Considering how fast the wagon went, if I had to guess, I would go with 1 scum bussing, 1 scum defending and 1 scum with no opinion.

In the lynch wagon:

camn, Anon, Drippereth, Maemuki

, McZombie,

CSL

,

Ythan

, Spyrex,

Parama.

Out of the lynch wagon: Dramonic,

Weaboo

, clergyman, kmd, nacho, yosa, miserableatbest.

Interestengly enough, I have a lot of reliable town reads on the lynch wagon, except by McZombie and Spyrex. And all fit in the category of the bussing scumbag for the type of posts used to vote Nikanor.

Now, my reads in the out of the lynch wagon are less reliable. I really think dramonic is more likely the wrong townie rather than the scumbag trying to save an inevitable lynch and use wifom for defense but I could be underestimating him and get this wrong.

I cant say the same of clergyhoops for obvious reasons

*. Kmd, nacho and yosa are kinda ok, still not sure, and palindar like a good wine, has gotten better with every post he makes, but still MaB's scummy ghost makes me rethink this decision.

___________
If I had to guess right now the scumteam is Spyrex,

Hoops

and some pesky one that should come up when other scumbags die in order.

Sorry kiddos but this HAS to be done today.

Vote: Spyrex.

Dramonic lynch is pretty non optymal even if he is scum, which honestly Im still pondering. And while not in disagreement with the Nacho tangent, I really think Spyrex has to go today.

Also, where the hell is Starbuck?

Kmd, I want your case against me now. Calling me scummy with no really basis is very antitown if not scummy. It seems that its mostly a gut thing from day 1 which its pretty nonlogical.

[Kmd4390]

Kmd, I want your case against me now. Calling me scummy with no really basis is very antitown if not scummy. It seems that its mostly a gut thing from day 1 which its pretty nonlogical.

Actually, it's perfectly logical.

[Drippereth]

@ Anon

Don't worry, we're going to kill SpyreX. The wagon analysis NEVER LIES. Remember that kids.

But only after we're done with Nachoscum.

[Drippereth]

We need 4 more votes to lynch Nachoscum.

Volunteers?