And town using one on him makes sense? Seriously though, they lost a member on day 1 and he would be an easy mislynch to push today if something weird happened overnight. Additionally, it puts pressure on Ellibereth.EK wrote:Do you really think cult would waste a rez kit on CSL if he wasn't cult?
Ka-ching! We got a winner.elvis_knits wrote:No, I would never believe that a townie rezzed csl. I was thinking that cult rezzed csl because he is cult, or that elli didn't try to kill him (because she's cult or something), or they're both cult. I didn't think about the possibility of scum setting up a mislynch by rezzing a town CSL. I guess you're right that it could make sense.
2) is not pertinent, since CSL has claimed to be rezzed. A better alternative would be that both CSL and Elli are Cultist. In that scenario, I'm inclined to just ignore them for now and wait for one of them to die - just like the reason why scum mason claims don't usually work, if they're both Cultists they're putting too much on the line.Magua wrote:I think Ellibereth is almost certainly murderer. I don't see town resuscitating CSL, so there's one of two possibilities. 1) CSL is scum who got resuscitated, or 2) Ellibereth lied about the target. #2 seems more likely to me than #1. Ellibereth's surprise at CSL being resuscitated also rings false.
Eh, I can't tell whether or not you're faking. The answer was that you could've Robbed Nico's Grave along with Ani to take another Insanity with a free action.Elli wrote:I already proved I took twitchy today, so the only possibilty for me to be a murderer now is if I were retarded enough to take Psycopathy N0 then claim stalker out of the blue.
Vote: Start
*twitch*
I don't understand how the last scenario is an explanation.VP wrote:CSL not dying is well....irritating. Either the cult tried to set up Ellibereth last night by rezing CSL, CSL is cult, or Elli is cult who participated in the ritual.
Seriously, what the heck.Hayker wrote:*twitches*
I was murdered last night, but obviously saved as well. Looks like animorv decided to try to kill me...
If it means that we mislynch Elli for it, it's a valid scum move.E_K wrote:Do you really think cult would waste a rez kit on CSL if he wasn't cult?
Or that Elli lied about his stalk target, which is also likely.iLord wrote:Right now, we just gotta sit tight and wait for everyone who rezzed to claim. Especially the player who rezzed Hayker/Phate - they're both likely town. If CSL's rezzer does not claim, than we can assume it was done by scum and that Elli would probably not be a good lynch today.
This is pretty bad reasoning.iLord wrote:If CSL's rezzer does not claim, than we can assume it was done by scum and that Elli would probably not be a good lynch today.
If we do lynch Elli, then I need a second Grave Robber. Also, I recomend someone take a look at Day 1, to see if there are any early play changes, as it could be a clue.dramonic wrote:Because we have to lynch Elli at one point or another, he's a potential murderer and CSL, whatever he flips, doesnt tell us anything about Elli's alignment, while the opposite has potential to be indicative.
I must be missing something. If Elli is cult and therefore can't kill CSL, then how was he rezzed?VP wrote:ie Ellibereth is cult who never had any intention of killing CSL, but said so yesterday to explain his insanity today.
Everyone is a potential murderer, including you. I don't see how either flip is more information than the other.Dramonic wrote:Because we have to lynch Elli at one point or another, he's a potential murderer and CSL, whatever he flips, doesnt tell us anything about Elli's alignment, while the opposite has potential to be indicative.
Okay, I get it.Dramonic wrote:CSL can flip scum, town, murderer, doesnt tell us anything about Elli.
Meanwhile, if Elli flips scum, we know he couldnt have killed CSL and therefore know CSL is also scum since he'd be lying about the rez.
If I know what a GR is, Magua wanted me to test out my Paranoid. Page 15.dramonic wrote:@Ani: refering to the second GR.