Vote: Phlight
The hypoclaiming was extremely suspicious, but the fact that he hasn't defended it is even worse. If he was town and it was something that would actually benefit town he would have been able to do this.
My theory is that he probably discussed this with his scum-buddies last night, as a way of claiming an investigative role without actually claiming (so he could later say if counterclaimed "it was just a hypoclaim"). When the mod first put up kunk's and B&B's deaths they were just listed as town, and so Phlight may have taken this as that they were vanillas and hoped there wouldn't be a tracker in the game. I took the vote after the tracker hypoclaim to be implying that the track was true, but after the mod updated the nightkill post it screwed his plan completely. Then of course there's the potential for rolefishing of the hypoclaim push, which is an added bonus.
If I'm right I wouldn't rule out Trumpet of Doom either, bussing a scumbuddy with the claimed track would be a smart move, as it then confirms Phlight as tracker for the rest of the game.
I've also been suspicious of some of the people who haven't really contributed much (Macavity, lobster, wolf, dramonic) so I looked at them all in ISO, and the one who came off as most likely to be scum is dramonic. The only thing he's contributed really is votes on bandwagons.
FOS dramonic
StrangerCoug wrote:If I said that we know each other to be town and we actually don't, I'm effed. If I'm scum that fakeclaimed my buddy to be my mason, I'm effed. I may not be the sharpest knife in the drawer, but I'm not as idiotic as Phlight portrays me.
Well it was DS who claimed mason, not you, so if you were scum you really had no choice but to go along with it. I'm by no means ruling out the possibility you could be scum by the way, I think that would be stupid, but like I said the claim is good and I disagree with Phlight when he said:
Phlight wrote:Oh, and also: you're not a confirmable role until you're dead.
SC can be confirmed while he's still alive if his mason partner is Nightkilled and comes up as citymouse.
I think peanutman is right about Kunk's death, the two different flavours suggest two seperate kills. The "ran over" flavour piqued my interest because on the cover of country mouse and city mouse they are both in a car, this doesn't necessarily mean anything because there are other stories about vehicles but it's just something that I think is worth pointing out.
