What do you need to be satisfied? He blatantly told us to not even suspect Farside on day one. Almost every one of his posts are overflowing with scum. His entire defense is based on Wifom.Boberz wrote:I also ask why the wagon on anon built up so quickly and I still ahvent really been satisfied.
Two scum in a four group of people in day 1? Really? Links or it didnt happen.Leech wrote:@Anon: What I don't like about your defense is that the majority of it is based upon Wifom. You're trying to tell us that RBT wouldn't have both scum partners in a scumlist, when I've seen that happen on numerous occasions.
Lol. Im not admitting defeat. I dont know how I can defend from having a bad read on a flipped scum, thats all. All I can say is that scumpartners are not that obvious and if they defend each other they usually let themselves an out, a typical "yes, I think player A is town but Im not sure". So they can exactly prevent what is happening here. But thats also wifom and we go back to the beginning so why should I bother if Im paradoxia, queen of circular reasoning?Leech wrote:Also, I really hate it when a player claims "I'm fine with my lynch" as it's almost admitting defeat. If you are town, maybe you should justify your actions that don't result in a wasted day phase.
Dont feel special. I have said the same thing to cooldog and boberz and poro. The idea is to share my town reads and my reasoning so that people left alive can win the game.Leech wrote:If you're scum, you're trying to buddy and win my vote. If you're town, you just outed me and this is probably my last day phase. I cannot believe you'd post that as a town role
I love that. If I don't find the games that this occurred in, in the many games I've read and participated in, it just simply didn't happen? If I had the time to track down the games I've seen this happen, I would. I simply don't have the time to read all the games I used to.Anon wrote:Two scum in a four group of people in day 1? Really? Links or it didnt happen.
It's called "hide in plain sight". You brush off my entire point by saying "link it or it didn't happen" all you want, but it is a very effective method of distancing. If you list scum partners in your scum list early on, when one of them dies you can very easily claim "I was suspicious of them from the beginning!" quite easily. That's one reason I almost never post scumlists. I said this before, that they allow the scum to know who's flying under the radar, and who's the most suspicious. Putting someone on your scumlist that is your buddy, is a way to show you are suspicious without voting. It's the safest form of distancing.Anon wrote:All I can say is that scumpartners are not that obvious and if they defend each other they usually let themselves an out, a typical "yes, I think player A is town but Im not sure". So they can exactly prevent what is happening here.
It's impossible to say how I'd react until I'm there. I don't really know as I wouldn't have put myself in that position in the first place? If you are truly town, you've made a plethora of terrible decisions. I can't see being in that position if I were town. I've played many games and I've never really made those types of mistakes as a town role. I can't assume you were town and enter that hypothetical, because I simply wouldn't be there.Anon wrote:Just, assume I am town. How would you defend from my position?
Maybe you forgot that I voted for you on day 1, and left my vote there. The only reason I haven't voted for you up until this point is due to the fact that it would lynch you. I felt that you deserved to defend yourself. From where I stand, though, all you've provided is Wifom, and more reasons to lynch you. I was giving you and others time to chime in on their thoughts, we've kicked ass this game so far so I didn't want to mislynch.Anon wrote:Im interested in something. Why is it taking you so long to vote me if you thought I was scum since day 1?
Lets see.scotmany12 wrote:Dear Anon: If you are town, please learn how to play mafia. Thanks.
DO.NOT.LYNCH.COOLDOG.boberz wrote:Why is this taking so long, my guess is you must be mafia or we would ahve been thrown into a night by now. That said cooldog's last posts would make him the person I will look at next. I just dont like that, it sounded like he was setting up excuses for him and others there.
On another note, if this is a mislynch anon, you have to take as much if not more responsibility for not making yourself look better, one thing not to do is ask the other players what they would say in your position it just looks bad.
Should we be talking in twilight??? (I am a hypocrite clearly, apologies.)
Wait. I have thought of something but I am so fucking wasted its not woreth takling about noe. You should see the red squigglu lines I see. DAMN YOU GOOGLE CHROME. Anyway, there is something in here thats a good idea, but I want to extrapolate it to make it even better. So dont do it, just yet. But I implore you (nice word, yes?) do not vote yet. I have a number of thoughts thus far.ortolan wrote:although there seems quite a good possibility that scum could hit the doctor. Scum could have nokilled but that wouldn't make sense from a tactical standpoint, only if scum were too incompetent to submit a kill. If doc claims now then we get all but guaranteed two innocents.