Mini 904 - Narnia: LWW Mafia (Game Over)

[manho]

where is PZ?

[Kdub]

Papa Zito and Gawyn have been prodded.

Vote Count

Riceballtail (2)

- Papa Zito, HackerHuck

Gawyn (0)

-

kikuchiyo (0)

-

HackerHuck (0)

-

Papa Zito (0)

-

wolframnhart (1)

- kikuchiyo

Narninian (1)

- wolframnhart

manho (0)

-

evilsnail (0)

-

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (5)

- Narninian, Riceballtail, Gawyn, manho, evilsnail

9 votes available, 5 votes needed to lynch.

Deadline is February 19, ~ 8:00 pm MST.

[wolframnhart]

I don't think PZ has posted on the site in a while, can we continue this without him for now?

[Riceballtail]

To expedite, if you haven't claimed and you post again, it should be there.

[HackerHuck]

Let's just keep things moving, but Papa Zito needs to claim as soon as he (or his replacement arrives). Let's hear your claim now Wolfram.

[evilsnail]

PZ did post on the site yesterday (he's modding one of my other games).

[wolframnhart]

I Oreius, and even though i lead aslan's army I am a vt. This is the main reason I believed Starbucks claim, I figured if I lead the army it makes sense to have an army member (who was not one of the main characters).

I don't care who goes next, i think all that is left is PZ and Gawyn, so whoever shows up first please claim.

[Kdub]

Deadline is less than 72 hours away. If replacements are needed, I will extend the deadline.

[HackerHuck]

OK, we need to remember that Papa Zito and Gawyn could still show up in the next day or two and we're stuck with a deadline that's three days from now. We'll be able to get claims from them before deadline, so let's make sure we've got someone to string up today. Five people not voting is unacceptable at this point in the day.

[Narninian]

So...

riceballtail - Professor Kirke
Gawyn - ???
kikuchiyo - Peter
Hackerhuck - Father Christmas
Papa Zito - ???
Wolframnhart - Oreius
Narninian - Edmund
manho - Susan
Evilsnail - Aslan

I'd really like to hear from the remaining two, before day's end of course but just to comment on the roles claimed. I'm not comfortable voting for an un-counterclaimed pensevie child, which leaves out manho or Kiku - nor would aslan make sense as a anti-town role. Professor Kirke and Father Christmas are secondary characters - but Professor kirke never enters narnia in the (lion witch and wardrobe) book. Oreius was a character in the movie, but I'm pretty sure he's not in the book.

Based on roles alone, I'd be suspicious of wolframnhart, but based on play so far I'm more suspicious of riceballtail.

vote: Riceballtail

Could we get a full role claim ?

[Narninian]

(from rbt that is)

[Narninian]

also off-topic- I think hackhuck's claim goes with his avatar quite well!

[kikuchiyo]

I would be okay lynching RBT at this point. I'd like the other claims, though. One is expectedly Lucy. We shouldn't be lynching based on claims, however. We should be lynching on scumminess. The Wolf wagon doesn't seem to want to go anywhere. Two days to deadline.

[Papa Zito]

I am really really sorry for holding the game up guys. Things just happened and yeah.

Nameclaim is

I'm Lucy.

[Riceballtail]

1)

VOTE:Wolf

least likely to exist from claims seen thus far.

2) PZ is indeed Lucy

3) I know that because I'm a rolecop.

4) Now that my role is in the open, I'll say I'm debating between Huck/Narn/Gawyn for my targets tonight.

[Papa Zito]

Oh god, not more rolecops. No no no. *shakes fist*

[Papa Zito]

unvote: RBT
vote: Wolf

bleh

[Narninian]

unvote

I don't want to lynch a rolecop.

Maybe we should have gawyn *not* claim and have RBT 'prove' his ability tonight?

[kikuchiyo]

Or we could lynch our traitorous little brother. What good does rolecop do for the town? I don't see why the claim makes him any less scummy.

RBT: Flavor with your role please. Also, why PZ?

Wolf, HH, Gawyn, and RBT should be our lynch pool today. I am also inclined to lynch Edmund. He is the only Pevensie with questionable ties to the White Witch.

[Kdub]

Vote Count

Riceballtail (1)

- HackerHuck

Gawyn (0)

-

kikuchiyo (0)

-

HackerHuck (0)

-

Papa Zito (0)

-

wolframnhart (3)

- kikuchiyo, Riceballtail, Papa Zito

Narninian (1)

- wolframnhart

manho (0)

-

evilsnail (0)

-

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (4)

- Gawyn, manho, evilsnail, Narninian

9 votes available, 5 votes needed to lynch.

Deadline is February 21, ~ 8:00 pm MST.

Gawyn has not picked up his prod, but he still has a little more time before I replace him. Due to his potential replacement, I have added 48 hours to the deadline. If Gawyn posts within the next day or so, that deadline will remain. If I need to replace him, I'll grant a longer extension.

[HackerHuck]

I'm not moving my vote yet.

Riceball - what exactly does your role do? Does it just confirm someone's name or does it give you an ability too?

I'd also like to know why you picked papa zito for your investigation.

I'm thinking that Orelius might be a red herring. Mod obviously gave safeclaims or made scum roles have some kind of connection.

I only like Narninian's plan of testing Riceball if gawyn's scum. Otherwise we've got to kill a townie to confirm him. I'm also suspicious that the

role

name cop claimed his ability after we all claimed. The only thing I think he has going for him is this post.

@manho: I disagree on PZ being scum, but I'm sure that the Kiku/Snail argument has at least one scum involved. I could also see it as a possible bus.

[manho]

@RBT, did your power investigate the name only or with the power?

[evilsnail]

We definitely shouldn't lynch RBT. A rolecop can be really useful and, if the claim is fake, there'll be some other investigative role.

Wolf and HH have the weakest claims, I think, though I'm not sure we can rule out one of the stronger claims being a safe claim.

I like a wolf vote atm. He was already one of my scum candidates and his claim is definitely the weakest.

Vote: wolframnhart

[Papa Zito]

What good does rolecop do for the town?

Breaks scum safeclaims.

I'm not saying he's not scum, not at all. Rolecop is far more likely a scum role than a townie one, and he could have just said "yeah that" after I nameclaimed to make him look credible when I get killed.

But it's possible.

BTW, I'm voting wolf both because he's been under the radar too much and because I get the feeling the game is based on the book and not the movie. Outguessing the mod is, as a famous philosopher once said, whoooosh but it's all I really have at the moment.

[manho]

wolf is at L-1 now. he may be the best lynch for now, but i would like to have RBT fullclaiming first.