I agree with Shiv *shock!* that this statement is weird considering what happens later on, especially considering I find Shiv the scummiest player atm. I don't see how he's been neutral, let alone "pro-town"... That's really the issue here, the use of the word "pro-town". It suggests he's done something special to make it onto the good list, when I find the posts he makes after this and lead up to your putting him on your scum list more town than anything else he's done this game. The only reason I can see for those last posts to make him scummy to you is OMGUS.I like both of our new replacements' posts so far. Both Shiverer and Radical Hijinx gave me a pro-town impression on the whole, so I'm willing to see past my suspicion of SeerPenguin for now.
I don't think Shiv is tunneling. He's focused on a couple players and been open to discussing anything. Tunneling to me would be if he were pushing for a lynch on someone and refusing to acknowledge that other players are acting scummy (DS, for example).
I was prepared to drop my suspicions of PJ when Jack replaced in because I was getting a generally town feel from him (despite his unwillingness to read). His recent defense of evilsnail seems kind of weird, though, and I'm keeping the slot on my possibly scum list... only really relevant if evilsnail is scum, though.
My real issues right now are with DS. He's getting scummier with every post.
What do I need an out for? I've already stated on previous occasions that I'm suspicious of you. If you keep posting the way you have been all game I will probably end up voting for you, there's no hidden agenda here. If at the end of the day there are more people voting for you than for Shiv, I will switch my vote over to your wagon. I'm satisfied either way at this point.Giving himself an out to vote me if my wagon gains momentum.
Wow, misrep much? I was suspicious of DRK very early on in the game, when I was defending SP. I reread the thread and decided SP was the one who was actually suspicious, and I'm currently voting for his slot. I haven't thought DRK might be scum since the beginning of the game. I think there could be other reasons for the way he's been playing and I see those reasons as more likely than him being scum. And I don't have suspicions about everyone. LS, IK and Thor are on my absolute town list. Everyone else has done something scummy at some point or other in the game, that doesn't mean they're all scum.Seven: "DRK might be scum, but what about Panzer?" "Hey everyone I have vague suspicions about all of you, except Seer and DRK"
It's not a random FoS, it's a slight tell that I don't care to investigate at this point in the game. Depending on who we lynch today and what happens tomorrow it might warrant looking into. I only mentioned it so that if I do end up using it, there will be some record of me having noticed something and it won't seem to come out of nowhere.Par wrote:Your posts inbetween the last post I read before posting and my big post do not address this question, actually. You only mentioned why you're not going to build a case on me even though you find me scummy.
I repeat, why are you randomly throwing out FoSes without giving reasons for them?
@evilsnail: Why am I not on your scumlist?
