TheButtonmen wrote:What do you feel makes me scummy?
Your first few posts just read the same thing over and over. Stop talking about the roles. I agree with the sentiment, but it's not until you're attacked that I feel you perk up with a better case on TQO.
However, the final thing and most convincing for me is this. In my first game, I was scum and won. (Look at my wiki for references). Most of my game was spent giving my opinion on cases that had already started, and then after doing so it was question time. I never built a solid case until I needed to. I think your game is better than my initial one (as you built on a case Day 1) but I'm reading a similarity between the two plays as you ask questions to others but there's never really any follow-up afterwards... except when dealing with TQO. They seem like filler and your focus is undeniably on TQO and faked on others to cover up.
The only other thing that bothers me is I got AGar to elaborate on his case on you and then you completely ignore it and tell him to read the thread. It just seemed scummy as you previously never attacked a person (accusing them of not reading the thread when they obviously had by quoting you) as a defense and it just didn't make sense in my mind.
And most recently, you attack TQO some more... but what I'm looking for was reasonable suspicion on anyone else in the game with some backing. I think at this point, town should have more than 2 suspects with a semblence of reasoning. Your accusation that you don't like something in AGar's and Jack's posting is vague and it's hard to tell if you believe they have a more likely possibility than the rest of us they could be. The fact that you're not going down fighting by getting all your thoughts out tells me that you don't want to build connections to possible scum-partners.
You're not my strongest scum read (that's still Zang), but you're definitely up there.
Tl;dr:
A) You didn't start building a case until you were attacked.
B) Your play reminds me of my own scum play.
C) You ignored a post and gave a weak defense.
D) You seem hesitant to name anyone outside of TQO & Zang as possible scum.
TheButtonmen wrote:And do you belive TQO's story that when he was searching the wiki he never used the search bar?
Yeah. Do I find TQO scummy nonetheless? Yes. As he and many others have said, he's new he's new he's new. He recovered nicely with his wall post, but really having the fact he's new crammed down my throat so often and so early, and the uncalled-for roleclaim, still irk me.
