Mini 901: Real Time Mafia (Over)

[Snow_Bunny]

7 Alive

Snow Bunny ( 1 ) Fishythefish
DeathRowKitty ( 0 )
don_johnson ( 1 ) animorpherv1
Flareonage ( 0 )
animorpherv1 ( 0 )
Juls ( 0 )
farside22 ( 0 )
manho ( 0 )
Fishythefish ( 1 ) Snow Bunny
No Lynch ( 4 ) Juls manho farside22 don_johnson
Total Votes ( 7 )

With 7 alive, 4 needed to lynch.
Next Lynch Available at: January 30th 00:01 EST
Lynch Will Be: No Lynch

I fail to see a connection between my claim and Elli's death. If any, scum is waiting for me to claim to make the kill.

Fishy, btw, I would love to see a proof of your claim. You claimed yesterday, I'm guessing you have something as of now worth of claiming.

In conclusion, proof or die.

Vote: Fishy

[Fishythefish]

I fail to see a connection between my claim and Elli's death. If any, scum is waiting for me to claim to make the kill.

Fishy, btw, I would love to see a proof of your claim. You claimed yesterday, I'm guessing you have something as of now worth of claiming.

In conclusion, proof or die.

Vote: Fishy

I've got no desire to reveal anything more about my role atm. I think doing so would hurt the town.

I think this is a horrible OMGUS. Nothing has changed recently, except for me voting you, and prior to this you had a protown read on me (expressed strongly in our QT).

[Snow_Bunny]

I had a protown read on you. In fact, I kind of still have it. But we can't ignore Elli's claim, and your unwillingness to claim make you suspicious.

For example, I fail to see a reason as of why not investigate someone. Useful info for town, you know.

[farside22]

First of all SB did fishy actually say anything to you in the QT about noticing the timing of the first kill?
Second I have to say that vote from SB comes off as OMGUS.
Finally I agree with SB some info from fishy in regards to his JOAT ability and anything he learned would be helpful

[animorpherv1]

@Fishy, I went through pages 15-26 and these posts do nothing to help town, or very very little:

oh well. that's too bad.

unless you're scum. then its great!

the numbers are dwindling here. i guess we have to hit scum sooner or later, right?

are you calling me an idiot?

unvote, vote: plumegranate

yeah. i think far's on the right track here.

unvote, vote: flare

time for him to go.

was i voting manho? i haven't really been paying attention, but flare seems atrocious. of course, i'm not looking much better now, am I?

fishy/annachie = scum

vote: fishy

vote: bigmc

i love how the scumlist is 3/4 low activity players and 1/4 the days leading suspect. classic.

feel free to waste your time.

unvote, vote snowbunny

its time.

^^ nice and oppurtunistic mr. president.

oh we'll learn something. i just don't know what yet. anyways, thanks for playing. MS needs more players like you(fun).

no. i like you. this has been fun. they don't hate you. they are just jealous of you. too many players here get all stressed out over stuff. i think some people forget this is a "game".

[don_johnson]

^^ brilliantly disguised omgus.

[Snow_Bunny]

First of all SB did fishy actually say anything to you in the QT about noticing the timing of the first kill?
Second I have to say that vote from SB comes off as OMGUS.
Finally I agree with SB some info from fishy in regards to his JOAT ability and anything he learned would be helpful

1- Yes, however, as I said to him, those aren't facts. For all I know, scum can have a recharge time of one day, and just decided to use it after I claimed. And, as I told him, I find rather suspicious that he tries to use that as a fact. I've caught more than one scum this way, you know.
2- Yes, a bit omgus, I agree. I also agree that I don't get a strong scum feeling from fishy. However, there's something there telling me that something's odd.
3- I agree with myself too.

Ani's case is good. Loving it. Lack of Dj's reply makes it better.

[manho]

i don't know why, but SB's iso smells scummy, maybe it's the gut feeling.

[farside22]

First of all SB did fishy actually say anything to you in the QT about noticing the timing of the first kill?
Second I have to say that vote from SB comes off as OMGUS.
Finally I agree with SB some info from fishy in regards to his JOAT ability and anything he learned would be helpful

1- Yes, however, as I said to him, those aren't facts. For all I know, scum can have a recharge time of one day, and just decided to use it after I claimed. And, as I told him, I find rather suspicious that he tries to use that as a fact. I've caught more than one scum this way, you know.
2- Yes, a bit omgus, I agree. I also agree that I don't get a strong scum feeling from fishy. However, there's something there telling me that something's odd.
3- I agree with myself too.

Ani's case is good. Loving it. Lack of Dj's reply makes it better.

1. Wait did he mention the kill time before or after the second kill? I'm looking for clarification on when he stated the time period between kills.
Also do you think the kill time would be so short and why? If given a kill would scum really wait so long just for WIFOM?
2. This doesn't help and makes me want to vote for you more especially based on fishy's comment before yours

Did DJ come online today to make a reply yet?

[Juls]

My apologies but I have been engrossed in some pretty craptacular homework today and didn't get a chance to do analysis. Hopefully I will be able to tomorrow but if I do I can guarantee it will be late because I won't be home until after 7p.m. central. That is also the case for Tuesday. Worst case scenario I get time Wednesday. But I will try to get to it before then.

[Fishythefish]

First of all SB did fishy actually say anything to you in the QT about noticing the timing of the first kill?
Second I have to say that vote from SB comes off as OMGUS.
Finally I agree with SB some info from fishy in regards to his JOAT ability and anything he learned would be helpful

1- Yes, however, as I said to him, those aren't facts. For all I know, scum can have a recharge time of one day, and just decided to use it after I claimed. And, as I told him, I find rather suspicious that he tries to use that as a fact. I've caught more than one scum this way, you know.
2- Yes, a bit omgus, I agree. I also agree that I don't get a strong scum feeling from fishy. However, there's something there telling me that something's odd.
3- I agree with myself too.

Ani's case is good. Loving it. Lack of Dj's reply makes it better.

The things I called facts are a) we had a kill after 10 days, and b) that

points to

a scum kill timer of 10 days. Not that there

was

a kill timer of 10 days, just that it pointed at one. The first of these is obviously true. OK, the second isn't quite a fact, but it's pretty clear to me that an kill happening after X days makes it more likely that it has a timer of X days. Trying to say that I had information only the scum have is ridiculous.

My originial comment came a few days after the first NK.

@manho: please elaborate as to why you find SB scummy. Who else is likely scum?

[manho]

SB's action-claiming post is approximately 10 days after the first kill, and i think she didn't include the 10th day after the first kill in the time duration of her action. except that the duration of her power is really short, i can't find a reason not including that day.

@SB, why don't you include the 10th day after the first kill in the time duration of your action?

[farside22]

Fishy did you learn or doing anything with your joat ability?
This is lylo and anything of value would be helpful.

[manho]

is it lylo now? it is likely that we have 3 scums, and with a maximum recharge time 10 days for a scum kill, they can kill 1 before we have 2 lynches, so scum can win unless we lynch right, the next scum kill is blocked, or we have a vig killing a scum.

maybe we need a mass roleclaim, right?

[farside22]

is it lylo now? it is likely that we have 3 scums, and with a maximum recharge time 10 days for a scum kill, they can kill 1 before we have 2 lynches, so scum can win unless we lynch right, the next scum kill is blocked, or we have a vig killing a scum.

maybe we need a mass roleclaim, right?

Usually with a 12 player game there is 3 scum so I can't imagine this game being any different. I can't even say any game that had only 2 scum in a 12 player game unless there is some recruit thing.

Since this is most likely lylo then a mass claim may be best.
claims so far:

SB - JK
fishy - JOAT
farside - VT
manho
DJ
Juls
Morph

[animorpherv1]

^^ brilliantly disguised omgus.

Then explain how those posts help the town.

[Fishythefish]

Fishy did you learn or doing anything with your joat ability?
This is lylo and anything of value would be helpful.

If at any stage I have information which I feel will lead to a higher chance of a scum lynch, I will reveal it. Until then, I'd much prefer to keep the scum guessing over what I can still do and when I can do it.

@SB: if you were suspicious over my guess as to the scum kill timer, why not say so before I brought it up? If not here, then in our QT.

[Fishythefish]

Fishy did you learn or doing anything with your joat ability?
This is lylo and anything of value would be helpful.

If at any stage I have information which I feel will lead to a higher chance of a scum lynch, I will reveal it. Until then, I'd much prefer to keep the scum guessing over what I can still do and when I can do it.

@SB: if you were suspicious over my guess as to the scum kill timer, why not say so before I brought it up? If not here, then in our QT.

[Snow_Bunny]

Why must I tell you of everything I think?

I don't understand at all manho's 636.

[Fishythefish]

I'd expect that, if you think something you find significant to the game, you either tell me or have a reason not to.

[don_johnson]

^^ brilliantly disguised omgus.

Then explain how those posts help the town.

you posted 11 quotes.

five contain votes. votes provide pressure and a literal trail of suspicions. pro town.

3 contain statements of suspicion of other players. pro town.

3 are conversational. they help foster an ideal of acceptance and enjoyment i would hope pervades these forums for those of us that have fun while playing.

if you have a point. please make it.

[farside22]

okay so far fishy says he told SB about the kill period. SB neglects to answer my questions based on her comment about the scum holding a kill back and the risk vs reward on doing so.
SB says she JK eli and it ended right before the kill to eli.
So far SB's reasons for doing this are none. I'm going to read back a bit tomorrow see if there is any connections to players and have a list of my top 3 suspects. I suggest everyone does the same.

[animorpherv1]

@ DJ:

5 votes - It's not the votes. It's the lack of reasoning followed by the vote.

3 statements of supision/ 3 contrersial - Don't see why you'd call it that. Explain further. Too me, it seems like a bunch of nonsense put in to look like your participating.

[don_johnson]

what is "contrersial"?

[manho]

Why must I tell you of everything I think?

I don't understand at all manho's 636.

the first kill is 10 days after the start, so it is reasonable to predict the second kill would be around 10 day after the start, that's 22/1, but you claim your action end in 22/1. so why not covering the 22/1 for a better chance to block the kill?