a girl on the internet wrote:
snow bunny
post 82: the "neutral on mike" is odd, why even mention him if you have nothing to say about him?
bunny/mbf +
Why not mention it? I had something to say: "neutral". If I say a reading on a player, it is bad. If then I suddenly comment something on a player I haven't said anything yet, it is bad. It's a no-win situation for me then. Tell me, why it is odd a "neutral on mike". It is odder that a "town on mike"? Odder than a "scum on mike"?
a girl on the internet wrote:post 285: me no likey. it's much like prozac with the pushing away from ray, while claiming to continue supporting his lynch. the last sentence in particular bothers me - it almost seems like gloating at the fact that the ray wagon has disappeared.
Again, tunneling is bad. Supporting two lynches is bad as well. ???. AGOTI was scummier, and thus I voted for her, but that doesn't mean that I'd forgotten Ray, nor that I liked the lack of pressure.
a girl on the internet wrote:wow, her posting on d1 was even more sparce than i remembered. no comments at all on prozac or tajo, but then, there's no comments on like half the players in the game. it's mostly just whining about the fact that anyone could have the audacity to suspect her.
I usually don't comment on anybody unless I have something on them. I fail to see the point here.
a girl on the internet wrote:post 614: makes no sense. i'm scummier than ray, but ray deserves to die more because "he's already survived one day". um, so did i? what?
it's nonsense that reflects well on her though. if she thinks it's reasonable to consider me scummier than ray, then one would think she'd also be trying to get me lynched over him if he was her scumbuddy.
So, you think I would push the lynch of my godfather when I could easily push yours? Right. Ray escaped D1 lynch, you didn't. Ray got to L-1. You didn't. That's why I say he survived one day.
a girl on the internet wrote:the reads on the other three, i think the mbf point looks the least like scum. "i had a town read on him before, but i'm starting to doubt" -> given that mbf was getting the most heat, that looks a lot like priming herself to jump on another townie if she felt the need later.
prozac is listed as town, with a "just gut" qualifier added. spyrex got "town" without any qualifiers; the fact that she finds it necessary to justify her town read on prozac in some way could be an indication that she was worried about looking connected.
tajo gets the "neutral", which i think is the most likely scumbuddy position, though. it says "i am totally not with this guy", but doesn't require one to actually push for a lynch on him.
I wouldn't push for anyone else as I felt that AGOTI is scum. And, it isn't the first time I used the "neutral read" on this game, so I don't see how can you come up with that. I hadn't given much attention to tajo, for that matter, just that small reading.
a girl on the internet wrote:post 680: wait,
crypto
was unnecessarily delaying ray's lynch?
bunny/tajo +
, because if that's a point against crypto, tajo clearly deserves heat for doing the same, only much worse.
What can I say? I honestly ignored tajo, as I had grudge against crypto.
a girl on the internet wrote:post 820: "And, on light of that new thought, I can't say much on Tajo. There's something I don't like about his posts. Can't say exactly what it is. As someone else said, there's certainly a connection between him and AGOTI, but I would prefer first an AGOTI's flip in order to build a case upon that."
whoever it was that pointed out how this totally looks like bunny hoping to make tajo look good off my town flip, you're totally right. especially when you factor in this comment of hers from 680: "Truth be told, I'm not much of a fan of scum-for-association (I think it can lead to many misunderstandings)".
bunny/tajo ++
I find you scummier than tajo. I find a link between you and tajo. What's the natural course of action? Lynch you and then draw conclusions. And, as you quoted, I'm not a fan of linking players like that. Anyone can buddy, town and scum alike.
a girl on the internet wrote:post 1007: OMG, this is ridiculous. elvis is not scum with crypto. here is the huge flaw in your reasoning:
"And, if the gambit is to save a town-rofl (Elvis-crypto), the risks are lower. If Rofl gets lynched, then Elvis and crypto would be left as confirmed towns, and surely getting them an insta-win."
let me narrow it down a little more:
"If Rofl gets lynched"
there it is! THAT WILL NEVER HAPPEN. elvis guaranteed that that will never happen by claiming innocent on him. something that she had absolutely no motivation to do if she is scum and he is not. he would have been lynched today, that's pretty much a fact. i almost certainly would have gone tomorrow. then elvis and crypto just have to turn whichever of you/mbf/prozac/tajo/white they decide to leave alive against each other, and easy money.
why on earth would elvis want to make it so much harder on herself by preventing the rofl lynch, and risk being counterclaimed, and force herself into coming up with results every day? there is no reason for her to do that. it is absurd to think that she would do that. elvis is not scum with crypto, you can take that to the bank.
I already gave my thoughts on why the gambit of claiming cop isn't exactly risky for scum. We know for sure that elvis isn't scum, but I had no possible way of knowing that, and I had a feeling that claim was shaky, and I went for that. So, am I scum for not trusting a cop with an innocent result on a player I found scummy, when there's a good chance it could be all a gambit?
a girl on the internet wrote:anyway. after isoreading bunny, i am surprised to discover just exactly how useless she has been, and definitely seeing a strong chance of a bunny/tajo pair from her side. enough so to counteract the negative data i got on that from the tajo read, fo sho.
in order of likelihood:
tajo/prozac
tajo/bunny
prozac/mbf
definitely think it's one of those three. so, lynch me, lynch tajo, lynch prozac. if tajo flips scum and prozac doesn't, lynch bunny. if prozac flips scum and tajo doesn't, lynch mbf.
(we can skip the 'lynch me' step if you want, i don't mind.)
done.
After reading this, I can only see you as trying to grasp to every small thing to make me tajo's partner. It's like religion: you want to take every small thing and make everyone believe it's all part of a divine plan. No, some times things just happen.
You made a big analysis, made some connections here and there between players, and finally setup the lynches after tajo flipped. A set of possibilities that give the town the feeling that they have the game in their hands. For me, you could easily be scum doing that. You might have impressed some of the other players with your big post, but for me you're just trying to make connections in order to setup lynches and clear you of fault.
Vote: Agoti
Taking a long break from mafia games.
In honor of Erika Furudo, my first scum win (Umineko Mafia).
Hope ya have a good one. 