Scummies 2010 Nominations

[curiouskarmadog]

Nominate VP Baltar for Best Performance Third Party

in Dark Goma Mafia

he was a SK in a 27 player game. There was about 100 ways from him to be killed and lived to see end game. The game ended in a draw(SK and the town), but he fooled almost every player in this game. I dont think i have seen anyone who worked harder. If had had better win condition he would have won.

[curiouskarmadog]

I beleive that is the 2nd, not Nth for the VP nom.

[curiouskarmadog]

Nominate Spyrex for Funniest Player

late to the party, but would like to second this.

[curiouskarmadog]

forgot I could edit, see below.

[curiouskarmadog]

Nominating Faraday for, Most Cunning Manipulation - "The Don Corleone" Award for Karma Mafia

we got an investigation on him and he claimed SK (with specifics) that not only saved his ass from a lynch, but won the game for his scum team...good show...Shanba also deserves some love for this nomination too, but it was faraday who deserves the actual nod.

going to have to chagne this Nom, according to faraday the actual claim (that in my opinion won it for scum) was due to javert,

so changing it to

Nominating Faraday/Javert for, Best Performance Scum Group
Award

for Karma Mafia

I personally dont think the entire scum team deserves it, just these two in particular.

[curiouskarmadog]

I'd like to unnominate both of the above - they both screamed scum to me -

really?! unnominate? Faraday(Shanba did replace him for a time) also had a claim that saved his ass and was crafted in such a way that made him almost impossible for the town to lynch. It was crafted by javert...who cares if you might or might not had them pegged, you died. They out manuvered you. that being said, the only real arguement you have to unnominate this, was that the town was full of blind sheep. Again, mafia, picked off the better players first.

[curiouskarmadog]

Nominating Vi's

Mafia on Holy Orders

for Best

Mechanic/Mutation

for its player-made setup:

Instead of starting with power roles all the town and mafia started as vanilla except for one

Seraph

on each side, who were not able to post but instead were able to give power roles to the players and try to assist their team by calling positive or negative attention to posts through halos posted every votecount.

3rd this.