Mini 901: Real Time Mafia (Over)

[farside22]

9 Alive

Snow Bunny ( 0 )
DeathRowKitty ( 0 )
don_johnson ( 0 )
Ellibereth ( 0 )
Flareonage ( 3 ) Snow Bunny Fishythefish farside22
Plumegranate ( 0 )
Juls ( 0 )
farside22 ( 0 )
manho ( 2 ) Juls don_johnson
Fishythefish ( 1 ) Ellibereth
No Lynch ( 3 ) manho Flareonage Plumegranate
Total Votes ( 9 )

With 9 alive, 5 needed to lynch.
Next Lynch Available at: January 23th 00:01 EST
Lynch Will Be: No Lynch

I just took a glance thru manho's profile and I disagree with Juls thoughts. It seems he isn't a real chatty person who post much too often.
However I have issues with both flare and pom.
Flare I pointed to earlier. Pom seems to be having the same let me follow mentality with little to no scum hunting.

vote: flare

[Ellibereth]

Guys trust me on this one please, We NEED to wagon Fishy into the claim zone due to something I can't say, and something I won't reveal until after he claims.

Vote: Fishy

I really need you guys to trust me on this one.

[Fishythefish]

Guys trust me on this one please, We NEED to wagon Fishy into the claim zone due to something I can't say, and something I won't reveal until after he claims.

Vote: Fishy

I will make a partial claim at this point: I can think of no investigative role that would conclude that I am scum (barring sanity issues or the like). In particular, I haven't made any suspicious-looking visits in this game, and I'm not, to my knowledge, a miller.

[farside22]

Guys trust me on this one please, We NEED to wagon Fishy into the claim zone due to something I can't say, and something I won't reveal until after he claims.

Vote: Fishy

I really need you guys to trust me on this one.

Is this in regards to the time stamp you pointed to earlier?

[Ellibereth]

Guys trust me on this one please, We NEED to wagon Fishy into the claim zone due to something I can't say, and something I won't reveal until after he claims.

Vote: Fishy

I really need you guys to trust me on this one.

Is this in regards to the time stamp you pointed to earlier?

No.

Fishy. I would really appreciate a fullclaim from you. I don't give a damn if people think I'm rolefishing right now. This is important.

[Ellibereth]

Actually, we don't even need a fullclaim, Fishy, if you're able to:

Are you a (Choose one):
Protective (Role)
Investigative
Killing
Other

I feel no need to wagon you if you answer the above. I know this is blatant rolefishing, but as ridiculous as this sounds I may be able to peg the whole or most of the scumteam today.

[Fishythefish]

OK. I can go with that. Naturally, I expect some justification for this, probably sooner rather than later, but frankly I don't think scum rolefish by asking people what their role is. In fact, I can give you a little more:

The best answer to your question is "other". I also have the potential to play a part in at least one of the other role types. In the right circumstances, I could seriously hurt the scum. This is

much

more likely to happen if they don't know my role.

[farside22]

Actually, we don't even need a fullclaim, Fishy, if you're able to:

Are you a (Choose one):
Protective (Role)
Investigative

Killing

Other

I feel no need to wagon you if you answer the above. I know this is blatant rolefishing, but as ridiculous as this sounds I may be able to peg the whole or most of the scumteam today.

You really think people will give you an honest answer for no reason?
Also what scum would admit to the bold? I think an explanation is required.

[Ellibereth]

I'm going to claim after everyone else pops in and does the following:
I'm requesting every player's opinion of the Fishy/Annachie slot. Doesn't have to be in detail or anything like that.

[Flareonage]

I've always thought that one of the neighbors is scum. Assuming Ellibereth has some kind of Power Role then chances are Fishy is scum and thus the request for a claim

[Snow_Bunny]

From the QT and the game, I got a feeling Ann was town. Fishy hasn't done anything particularly to move up or down from that.

[Ellibereth]

Claim post typed.
I want Fishy to fullclaim before my claim, as he goes going to have to fullclaim after my claim anyway. I'll paste my claim in as soon as I see his.
I'm not going to wait for more people cause I don't want to be NKed before I can claim.

[Fishythefish]

@Elli: are you totally set on claiming? I think revealing my role right now would be a mistake. I have no idea what your role could be here, but if you are town, you are misinterpreting something.

I should warn you that, at this stage in the game, there is absolutely no way I'm going to fullclaim. There is a detail of my role I'm going to totally refuse to reveal, literally until I'm the lynch and it's about 12 hours until deadline. If your investigation hangs on that aspect of my role (which I kind of doubt), then this exchange is going from bad to worse.

[Fishythefish]

In case the above is misinterpreted: I am prepared to mostly-claim now, if Elli asks again. I'm not demanding that Elli claims first - just asking him to think things through one more time.

[don_johnson]

fishy/annachie = scum

vote: fishy

[Ellibereth]

In case the above is misinterpreted: I am prepared to mostly-claim now, if Elli asks again. I'm not demanding that Elli claims first - just asking him to think things through one more time.

Go ahead, I want to see your fakeclaim.

[Ellibereth]

Actually: screw that. Idon't want to be NKed.


I am a Gunsmith.
I was given an explicit list of roles that would show up as having a gun:
Cop/Watcher/Trackers, Vigs, Other Gunsmith, Paranoid Gun owners, SK's, and Mafia. NO OTHER ROLES HAVE GUNS.
It should be obvious now that I had a recent investigation of Fishy which he has shown to have a gun.
Coupled along with my gut read on Ann and some other stuff, it should be obvious I'm thinking that Fishy is scum.
The role questions I asked now are pretty obvious now. If he was a Cop/Tracker/Watcher/Gunsmith he would have chose the Investigative section. If he was a vig, the killing. PGO is impossible because I'm still alive.
His more recent posts shows he clearly does not have one of the listed town roles.
Hence he's Mafia or an SK.

[farside22]

I remember some of my read of anna was leaning between him, bunny, pom and flare.
Anna did the OMGUS vote on DRK and ignored the question possed by juls. i will have to look back and remind myself of everything I felt.

[farside22]

unvote:
vote: fishy

Eli: can I ask again did you really expect an honest answer in regards to the bold?

[Ellibereth]

unvote:
vote: fishy

Eli: can I ask again did you really expect an honest answer in regards to the bold?

Yeah, if he was town.
He's not.

[Ellibereth]

unvote:
vote: fishy

Eli: can I ask again did you really expect an honest answer in regards to the bold?

Yeah, if he was town.
He's not.

[farside22]

unvote:
vote: fishy

Eli: can I ask again did you really expect an honest answer in regards to the bold?

Yeah, if he was town.
He's not.

fair enough.

Sorry for the delay in post I was typing and got interrupted by my son so I saw the claim after I posted.

[Ellibereth]

The only "correct" anwsers to that question that would have made me doubt my read would have been Investigative or Killing anyway.

[Ellibereth]

bigmc109
Plumegranate
manho
TonyMontana
Annachie
Snow Bunny

two are dead, one is outed, making the other semi-confirmed.

Fishy - Plumen - Manho scumteam being called right now

[Flareonage]

I'm trusting Elli on this one

Unvote

VOTE: Fishy