Pick Your Power - Game. Set. Match.

[Cobalt]

not only did I target and lynch scum, I also called faraday as doc and chamber as bulletproof by N2.
DBG, are we the best town pair ever or what? We need to be masons someday.

[chamber]

Someone remember this game when the 2010 scummy thread goes up, I likely wont.

[Seacore]

That was a fantastic game,

And also, I rock with power roles. I've got to improve my scum hunting game as vanilla, but give me an ability and I'll get the most from it

[TonyMontana]

This was a triumph.

Loved the draft setup, would love to play it again.

[Devotress]

I thought the whole draft set up was a great idea.
I did a bad job boo me.

Point of interest I bus drived onto haylen because we thought haylen would be town, and not have a night power incase someone targetted me with track.
I think I said that in the graveyard quicktopic anyway, but.

[StrangerCoug]

Way to shoot myself in the foot.

Ah, well, there's next time.

[DrippingGoofball]

COBALT!!!!

*hugs*

You were, like, a frikkin' PSYCHIC VIG!!!

I'm very proud that the vote analysis netted Cruciare because he didn't stand out as scummy otherwise.

Note to self: play more games with Seacore.

Both the people I started wagons on day 1 were scum. It was frustrating that the town was (rightly) refusing to lynch elvis, and the watcher made it impossible to night-kill her. If Devotress had managed to avoid the lynch for just one day she could have done the kill... but no. Frustrating.

You were scummy, and elvis as cop was not a good lynch from a town perspective.

Thank you Spyrex for running this game.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm also amazed that I wasn't targeted at night... especially by the NKs.

[farside22]

I think the only thing that surprised me was that no one picked RB or JK when picking roles. I thought for sure since I was so low on the pick that one scum would pick RB at least

[TonyMontana]

I was expecting the last scum to be someone more unlikely. Like DBG or Cobalt. I just felt we had too much luck, it couldnt keep up :p

[Vi]

HAHAHA

I saved Framer from falling into the evil clutches of... dramonic.

Oh well >.>

[dramonic]

my clutches arent evil, they're just misunderstood.

[Plum]

I'm a bit disappointed that I had to replace out. It was frustrating even making my big catchup post because both of my buddies were somehow going down the tubes. Then stuff happened and I had to replace out.

My great glory was being second-lowest in the Draft order and netting Empowerer.

[BloodCovenent]

Good game guys. I feel like i did rather poor this time around though. I look forward to the next game. Possible Pre-/in?

[Pomegranate]

Yeah, it was really frustrating replacing out. I saw Plum's QT, and well, we obviously couldn't stay in the game from there.

Plum and I won't play together anymore, since it doesn't work.

Spyrex, I really liked the game. It was fast paced, and the town rocked. Though I wasn't part of the game in the end, I'm still proud of the town, and its voting record.

Pre-post edit: I just iso'ed DeathNote, as well as myself, and I made more posts than him, on my part of D1 alone. I feel like a part of the game after all.

[Vi]

my clutches arent evil, they're just misunderstood.

That's what you WANT us to think.

[SpyreX]

And no, no blacklists this game. But I might need a composition on "Why I shouldn't have the amazing amount of inactivity not be a factor in your mod-god ire" essays from SOME players should they want to play in more in the future.

[Fishythefish]

I really liked this idea, and I'd definitely be in for a similar game. Many thanks to Spyrex for modding, and for the town for being totally awesome.

[Benmage]

I was expecting the last scum to be someone more unlikely. Like DBG or Cobalt. I just felt we had too much luck, it couldnt keep up :p

Word. We did too well....

[Faraday]

Future?

In the near future I am thinking about running this again (17 town - 5 mafia I think). That said:

- What roles would you like to see available?
- What roles should I nix?
- What overall should I change?
- What overall should I keep?

The next one I think I'm going to let the scum coordinate before the draft some. And, of course, I'm leaning on one big scumteam.

So, comments, concerns, questions, etc!

Man I loved the set-up as it was, there's not a whole lot needs changing really.

maybe change the roles up a bit, idk add in a regular bus driver? 1-shot dayvig? masonizer?
i liked most of the roles in it too, idk what you should leave out, I'll leave that up to you.
definitely one of my most enjoyable games on the site thus far though.

[Seacore]

What would be the effect of not giving out roles before powers were chosen?

[Cobalt]

What would be the effect of not giving out roles before powers were chosen?

everyone takes vig or jailer

[Seacore]

except that they wouldn't


so you know, what effect apart from that effect that won't happen

[Faraday]

What would be the effect of not giving out roles before powers were chosen?

Man I must be tired, but I can't make sense of this? Like don't make the set-up open @ the start?
I need to go to bed I think.

[SpyreX]

Seacore is saying do the draft before you know you're alignment.

Which I thought about - but there are some roles that are only helpful for scum and I'm not sure what it would do to balance if they got drafted HOPING they'd be scum.