Open 190 - Trendy and Subversive C9 - Over

[Cat]

That cookie-meta may have been true in this game, but I feel that cookies have a much more positive connotation here.

All: Do you like cookies?

[kunkstar7]

That cookie-meta may have been true in

this

game, but I feel that cookies have a much more positive connotation here.

You did mean

that

game correct? *Points at Cat* (Obvscum!)
Why do you feel the cookies different for this game?

[Cat]

Because cookies change.

[startransmission]

I love cookies as long as there are no nuts (except peanuts) or raisins.

I voted Mipe for shits and giggles, consider it a random vote.

This game isn't really taking off. I'll see if I can muster up some discussion starting questions that don't have anything to do with baked goods.

[malpascp]

Unvote, Vote: Startransmission

for just looking for reasons to vote someone but not actually believing it's a scumtell that he found.

Wait what?

Startransmission: So it's scumtell to answer questions that are intended for others but it isn't now? What's the difference?

Vote: Startransmission

Unvote

Mipe was pretty quick to jump on that. Star is still suspicious though. I don't think Star and Mipe are scum together, but I think one of them is scum. I'm gonna have to figure out which one it is before we lynch anyone.

Oh wait? This is 7p? Totally didn't expect that 4P has majority.. Thought this was 9p..

Mipe what the hell is this?

Vote: Mipe

[SaintKerrigan]

Cat, what do you think about Startransmission and Mipe?

[Cat]

Well, mipe lied about he read the questions wrong. Looking at his post where he quoted your questions:

This is the most lackadaisical random voting stage I've ever seen. Let's go with some questions.

Mipe: Why is Startransmission's avatar going to bother you?
Mipe: Why is it boring to play with people you know?
Mipe: Do you like cookies?
Mipe: What is your view on lurkers?
Mipe: How experienced would you say you are?
Mipe: Who is the central person in your avatar?
Mipe: Why are you asking these questions?
Mipe: What would you do if I voted you?

Every question began with mipe, when in the original they each were addressed to a certain person. Mipe obviously knew who the questions were supposed to go to and changed it. I'm curious as to why he lied about it.

However, startransmission followed with this:

Yeah. Mipe, answering other peoples questions is a scumtell.

with a vote for mipe, but the way I'm reading it now, it looks like he meant as a joke. If he's serious, I think he meant it with more serious questions.

In this case it isn't. But... sometimes answering questions intended for other people could be seen as scum coaching their partners, or just answering for them.

See, here he clarifies himself.

And I think mipe honestly thought that it was 9-player, but it's weird how he didn't unvote after he realized that.

[mipe]

Cat: It was already L-2 so unvoting wasn't so necessary.

[Sleepless Assassin]

Mipe's excuse looks believable maybe. I'd vote Star but that would make it L-1 again.

[kunkstar7]

Unvote: Startransmission

My random vote should not be in place anymore.

Why do you believe his excuses SA? Considering that he knew that each question was posed to a different player and he changed it to be for himself, I doubt he didn't understand, as Cat has pointed out. Do you believe that he really didn't understand? Although the unvoting one I believe as that does make sense. Do you in this instance not view the lie as a scumtell?

[Excedrin]

KittyMo is replacing SaintKerrigan.

[startransmission]

Mipe's excuse looks believable maybe. I'd vote Star but that would make it L-1 again.

Why would you vote me? Because I voted for Mipe?

[KittyMo]

Awww, I'm replacing SaintKerrigan? He's the only one I recognized on the player list. I was hoping to play with him again. I mostly inned as a favor to Excedrin, though. This game really needs an activity boost.

I haven't read the thread yet, but since it's only 3 pages long, it's not going to take very long.

~ KittyMo

[KittyMo]

Actually, I just realized mipe's playing. I don't know him from MS, but I know him from elsewhere. ^_^ Hi mipe!
---------------------------------------

Summaries:

Cat seems to go from serious business to kidding around very easily. Like he talks about cookies all the time, but then he doesn't understand how mipe is obv joking and calls it "lying." Reading his posts just kinda make me go...huh?

kunkstar7 is kinda meh. He says his reason for voting startransmission with the avatar reasoning was because it's "convenient." I just don't really understand why you'd worry about convenience if you're pro-town. Also unvotes his random vote without putting it anywhere else, which is pointless but not neccessarily scummy.

malpascp needs to learn to post more and answer people's questions fully. He doesn't really explain "why the hell" he finds anything wrong with mipe, either.

mipe is very joke-y, and needs to contribute more.

Sleepless Assassin is like really happy in the confirm stage. He then votes malpascp with no reasoning whatsoever. Seems to have already decided who is scum on page 2. That's actually probably a town tell, though.

startransmission is also a jokey dude. Also has yet to contribute much.

vote kunkstar7

for now.

[mipe]

Dahlia Hawthorne is a bitch.

Anyways, Welcome KittyMo . You replaced the person who I have played with in the past. And I have played with you in the past as well, hmm..

[KittyMo]

Mipe: What do you think of malpascp's recent post?

[KittyMo]

This game shouldn't continue to be treated as if it's still in the RVS. We've already had 2 bandwagons; there's plenty of information to go off of now. It's time to stop doing things for kicks and giggles. We have scum to lynch, and we need to lynch right 2/3 of the time. This game is

serious business.

[Sleepless Assassin]

@Strange: The only reason I unvoted was because I thought Mipe was scummy too but you weren't both scum together. Now I'm more sure that you're scum and Mipe isn't.

@Kitty: Welcome to the game. Yeah, I was excited to play again. My first game didn't go so well, but I was ready to give it another shot.

I voted Malp for his answer to the lurker question. I was waiting for someone to ask why, but no one ever did. But Strange got scummy, so I switched my vote.

Your summaries look like you have a better case on Cat than on Kunk. Why did you pick Kunk for your vote?

[kunkstar7]

kunkstar7 is kinda meh. He says his reason for voting startransmission with the avatar reasoning was because it's "convenient." I just don't really understand why you'd worry about convenience if you're pro-town. Also unvotes his random vote without putting it anywhere else, which is pointless but not neccessarily scummy.

There was a reason for my unvote of startransmission. Sleepless Assassin was afraid of voting him because of causing a L-1 situation, and since I did not have any actual basis for voting star I removed my vote to allow SA to vote without any fear of causing an early L-1. As it were, you are not required to be voting someone, and I haven't seen anything telling so far that deserves a vote from me yet.

@Sleepless: Who are you referring to as Strange?

[Cat]

KittyMo: I think you know me previously as skitzer in IRC games. Check my sig.

Anyway, I'm glad to have you here.

[KittyMo]

Your summaries look like you have a better case on Cat than on Kunk. Why did you pick Kunk for your vote?

It's not really a post of cases, just observations of play thus far. I'm not certain whether Cat's...mood swings (for lack of a better term) are scummy, and the convenient comment from kunkstar bothers me a lot, so I threw my vote down. I've got my eye on Cat, though.

There was a reason for my unvote of startransmission. Sleepless Assassin was afraid of voting him because of causing a L-1 situation, and since I did not have any actual basis for voting star I removed my vote to allow SA to vote without any fear of causing an early L-1. As it were, you are not required to be voting someone, and I haven't seen anything telling so far that deserves a vote from me yet

.

Fair enough, but in general I think people should use their vote more. That's kind of my mafia new year's resolution. =]

And @Cat/Skitzer- I recognize your name, but don't remember any particular games we've been in. Hi.

[Excedrin]

Vote Count

mipe (2): startransmission, malpascp
startransmission (2): mipe, kunkstar7
kunkstar7 (1): KittyMo
not voting: Sleepless Assassin, Cat

Activity is pretty low, but that's OK with me. I didn't state in the 1st post what happens at deadline without majority, please don't make me figure that out (it'll probably be nolynch without majority).

Also, as a note, I've edited a few posts to fix quote tags and such. I'm not annotating them with different color stuff so this is a FYI.

Cat, I like your avatar.

[KittyMo]

unvote; vote malpascp

[Sleepless Assassin]

Sorry, I mean Star.

[kunkstar7]

Any reason for switching to mal, kitty?Although I say his post voting mipe was bad, and his contributions have been, well lacking.