Mini 905- Mafia in Sienna OVER

[Ellibereth]

Elli, why do you think that they're scum? This is a serious question here, I won't be happy with a jokey response.

Thesp: I always find happiness in Role PMs, because I always think "this is a chance to play this role to the best of my ability!" On this one I was even happier because its a chance to be against you Thespscum! Also Thesp, very upset to not see you asking yourself the hard questions!

I don't, I was joking.

[Oman]

Well I'm happy to start with a

Vote: Elli

simply for playing so differently to the opening of the previous game where she was town.

Granted, small sample size, but best I've got for now.

[Ellibereth]

Well I'm happy to start with a

Vote: Elli

simply for playing so differently to the opening of the previous game where she was town.

Granted, small sample size, but best I've got for now.

He damnit.
And noone came out and claimed 'nilla this time.

[My Milked Eek]

Eeky, You know I'm just screwing around for the hell of it.
Pman, London Bridge is Failling Down works.

Didn't think you'd give up on the joke this fast. I didn't even vote you yet.

I'm so ashamed that people are random voting in this game, especially from some people who were in the last game with me. It's embarassing.

RVS is over, as of now. If anyone "random" votes, I will stab them in the eye. Then I will vote for them and I may not leave from my vote for the day until they are lynched from the neck.

That's a rather silly policy and I'm tempted to random vote.

My Milked Eek, how scummy do you think you'll be this game?

It depends on how scummy my partner, Thesp, will be.

Elli, why do you think that they're scum? This is a serious question here, I won't be happy with a jokey response.

Thesp: I always find happiness in Role PMs, because I always think "this is a chance to play this role to the best of my ability!" On this one I was even happier because its a chance to be against you Thespscum! Also Thesp, very upset to not see you asking yourself the hard questions!

I don't, I was joking.

"

Not random.
Not semi-random

"

Screw the pman wagon attempt, elli is better.

Unvote. Vote: Elli

[Leafsnail]

Leafsnail, can you PM your scumbuddies and let them know we've started?

Uh... actually, looking at the OP, rule 6 implies that even the mafia members cannot communicate with each other at all.

Mod: Can the mafia members talk to each other? If so, how?

Also, since I haven't played a game with you before, why do you dislike RVS? Do you fear a hammer vote could randomly be reached or do you just think it's childish?

Ellibereth - If someone explicitly tells me they are not joking, I generally take that as an indication that they are not joking (I have it marked as the first serious attack on my notes). So, if it was, in fact, a joke, what were you hoping to gain out of it? What reactions were you looking for?

[My Milked Eek]

Leafsnail, can you PM your scumbuddies and let them know we've started?

Uh... actually, looking at the OP, rule 6 implies that even the mafia members cannot communicate with each other at all.

Mod: Can the mafia members talk to each other? If so, how?

Why do you want to know?

[Sotty7]

Sotty7, what's the best method for catching scum?

Paying attention.

Vote: Oman

I thought it was pretty clear that Elli was joking around.

[Leafsnail]

Why do you want to know?

The mafia will act differently if they can communicate with each other. Also, additional information about the game can't hurt.

[Sotty7]

Leaf have you played many games of online mafia before?

[Leafsnail]

Quite a few, although none on mafiascum.net.

[My Milked Eek]

Sotty7, what's the best method for catching scum?

Paying attention.

Vote: Oman

I thought it was pretty clear that Elli was joking around.

It was, but it's odd that when a little "heat" was coming her way, she immediately dropped the joke.

[Darkstrike_11]

Mod: Can the mafia members talk to each other? If so, how?

That rule has been amended. It's intention was to get across the point that you can't idly chit chat about the game in other threads.

6. Do not discuss this game outside the thread unless your role permits it. This thread is like fight club.

Hope that clears things up for everyone.

Vote Count as of post 60

My Milked Eek (3): [CrashTextDummie, Ellibereth, pman5595]
Ellibereth (2): [Oman, My Milked Eek]
Sotty7 (1): [Kitten4u]
Kitten4u (1): [Leafsnail]
pman5595 (1): [ConfidAnon]
Oman (1): [Sotty7]

Not Voting: [Jase, Wickedestjr, Thesp]


With 12 Players, a majority of 7 is needed for a lynch.
Deadline is 10pm, 24th Jan 2010 (GMT)

[CrashTextDummie]

CrashTextDummie, how good do you think you are at online mafia?

Very.

It was, but it's odd that when a little "heat" was coming her way, she immediately dropped the joke.

I don't see what's odd about it, and I question this line of thinking.

To reiterate my previous sentiment: Can we lynch My Milked Eek now?

[My Milked Eek]

It was, but it's odd that when a little "heat" was coming her way, she immediately dropped the joke.

I don't see what's odd about it, and I question this line of thinking.[/quote]
It felt like appeasing to me. What's odd about my line of thinking?

[Ellibereth]

I was joking around for the hell of it. I stopped because there was really no point in continuing it and I didn't feel like continuing it. Anyone who took it seriously is crazy.
Also: I'm a boy damnit.

[Wickedestjr]

Wickedestjr, how many scumpartners do you have?

I didn't think I was scum this game. *checks role pm* Yep, I'm
town-alligned.

RVS is over, as of now. If anyone "random" votes, I will stab them in the eye. Then I will vote for them and I may not leave from my vote for the day until they are lynched from the neck.

This seems contradictory to the fact that you still feel the need to ask these random questions:

Jase, do you enjoy having town roles or scum roles more? On an unrelated note, are you happy?
ConfidAnon, are you scum? If not, why are you lying?
Leafsnail, can you PM your scumbuddies and let them know we've started?
pman5595, why'd you do it?
My Milked Eek, how scummy do you think you'll be this game?
Kitten4u, how much have you played mafia in real life? What's one of your real life tells?
Wickedestjr, how many scumpartners do you have?
Oman, do you find happiness in receiving role PMs? Were you happy when you got your role PM for this game?
Sotty7, what's the best method for catching scum?
CrashTextDummie, how good do you think you are at online mafia?
Ellibereth, do you think lurking is a scumtell?

Firstly, what was the purpose of these questions?
Secondly, if we were out of the RVS when you made your post, then why didn't you make any serious comments?

So, if it was, in fact, a joke, what were you hoping to gain out of it?

What reactions were you looking for?

What was the purpose of the question in red, if the question in green pretty much gives Ellibereth a hint? Also, as for the green question, what told you Ellibereth was looking for reactions? I looked through his posts and I see nothing that indicates that. Those two questions were pointless. Also, it sort of looks like you are trying to help Ellibereth in a subtle manner.

Vote: Leafsnail

[My Milked Eek]

Also: I'm a boy damnit.

lol, sorry, it's just that the name "elli" seems female.

I was joking around for the hell of it. I stopped because there was really no point in continuing it and I didn't feel like continuing it. Anyone who took it seriously is crazy.

There are several points to pursuing that "joke".

[Leafsnail]

[quote=Wickedestjr]What was the purpose of the question in red, if the question in green pretty much gives Ellibereth a hint? Also, as for the green question, what told you Ellibereth was looking for reactions? I looked through his posts and I see nothing that indicates that. Those two questions were pointless. Also, it sort of looks like you are trying to help Ellibereth in a subtle manner.[/quote]
Asking questions such as these allows you to look for inconsistency of motive, a powerful scumtell. Often it's not necessarily what people do but how they explain it afterwards that shows their true colours.

As for the second question... well, I didn't want him to just post a vague "Looking for reactions" and have done with. It wasn't meant to be a hint, but a possible follow up question.

Ellibereth - why did you keep pursuing it if you weren't trying to get anything out of it?

[ConfidAnon]

Why do you want to know?

The mafia will act differently if they can communicate with each other. Also, additional information about the game can't hurt.

My scummy senses are tingling.

Unvote, Vote: Leafsnail

But Thesp, I want an answer to my question still. I've always been curious as to why people don't the RVS. I love the RVS.

[Leafsnail]

(If you want a corrected version of my previous post:

What was the purpose of the question in red, if the question in green pretty much gives Ellibereth a hint? Also, as for the green question, what told you Ellibereth was looking for reactions? I looked through his posts and I see nothing that indicates that. Those two questions were pointless. Also, it sort of looks like you are trying to help Ellibereth in a subtle manner.

Asking questions such as these allows you to look for inconsistency of motive, a powerful scumtell. Often it's not necessarily what people do but how they explain it afterwards that shows their true colours.

As for the second question... well, I didn't want him to just post a vague "Looking for reactions" and have done with. It wasn't meant to be a hint, but a possible follow up question.

Ellibereth - why did you keep pursuing it if you weren't trying to get anything out of it?

Anyway, ConfidAnon, what exactly do you find scummy about it?

[Sotty7]

Also, it sort of looks like you are trying to help Ellibereth in a subtle manner.

Are you saying they are linked then?

[Ellibereth]

WHAT DON'T YOU PEOPLE GET ABOUT DOING SOMETHING FOR THE HELL OF IT.
YOU PEOPLE = LEAF.

[Leafsnail]

If you were just doing it for the hell of it, then that means all you've done so far is joke and explain your joke.

Do you have any suspicions, or are you just going to respond angrily whenever someone puts a question your way?

[Ellibereth]

Jokes don't need explaining.

Unvote, Vote Leafsnail

[Leafsnail]

Ellibereth, you've once again failed to answer my question, and have instead just thrown a vote my way. Perhaps you could at least explain why you find me suspicious, or who else you find suspicious?